ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



Space rock buzzes past Earth

Posted: Wednesday, November 11, 2009 1:55 PM by Alan Boyle


NASA
A NASA graphic traces the asteroid 2009 VA's path within the moon's orbit and past
Earth. Each dot on the 2009 VA line indicates an hour of time along the route.

Asteroid-watchers say a space rock about as big as a garage came within 9,000 miles (14,000 kilometers) of Earth last Friday, just 15 hours after it was detected.

Experts quickly determined that the asteroid 2009 VA would miss us - and even if it came directly at us, it wouldn't have caused a catastrophe. Nevertheless, the close encounter serves as a reminder that someday a much bigger rock may well hit us and that it's best to be prepared.

In this week's recap of the event, NASA's Near-Earth Object Program Office reported that 2009 VA came well within the moon's orbit - so close, in fact, that the asteroid's orbital path was bent by Earth's gravitational pull.

NASA and other space agencies around the world have been keeping increasingly close track of near-Earth asteroids and comets, with a strong assist from amateur astronomers. In this case, the object was first detected by the Catalina Sky Survey at the University of Arizona. It was quickly identified by the Minor Planet Center in Cambridge, Mass., as a close-approaching asteroid. Then NASA experts worked out its orbit and gave the all-clear.

Why wasn't the rock found sooner? Well, smaller objects are more difficult to detect in advance, and this one was estimated to be only 7 meters (23 feet) wide. That's nowhere near as big as the 10-kilometer-wide (6-mile-wide) object that apparently did in the dinosaurs 65 million years ago - or even the 30-meter-wide (100-foot-wide) Tunguska object that was thought to have wreaked destruction in a Siberian forest in 1908.

For what it's worth, the Defense Department's Joint Space Operations Center tracks about 19,000 orbital objects down to the size of 10 centimeters (4 inches), and NASA tracks bits of space junk that are even smaller. But incoming near-Earth objects are trickier to track until they're almost upon us.

In the close-but-no-collision category, this one was No. 3 on NASA's list for cataloged asteroids: A meter-wide (yard-wide) asteroid came within 6,150 kilometers (3,821 miles) in October 2008, while another space rock about the size of 2009 VA passed within 6,535 kilometers (4,060 miles) in March 2004.

If 2009 VA had entered the atmosphere, it almost certainly would have blown itself up before hitting the ground - just as a larger asteroid did a month ago, without warning, in the skies over Indonesia. A somewhat smaller asteroid met a similar fate in the skies over Africa about 13 months ago. (Months later, students in Sudan found 4 kilograms (8.7 pounds) of meteorites that fell to Earth after last year's blast.)

Such atmospheric blow-ups release energy equivalent to about a kiloton of TNT. In comparison, the Hiroshima atomic bomb set off a roughly 15-kiloton blast.

So, for several reasons, we shouldn't hit the alarm button over 2009 VA. But that doesn't mean we should hit the snooze button, either: The Indonesia blast and the surprise pummeling that Jupiter took back in July are just foretastes of nasty surprises that could be waiting for us. The more we know about asteroids and how to fend them off, the better. Here are some reports that lay out the asteroid threat and what NASA has been doing about it:

Update for 3:35 p.m. ET: I've upped the estimate for the dino-killing asteroid to a whopping 10 kilometers (6 miles) across. Anything bigger than 1 kilometer wide would be considered capable of causing a global catastrophe.


Join the Cosmic Log team by signing up as my Facebook friend or following b0yle on Twitter. And pick up a copy of my new book, "The Case for Pluto." If you're partial to the planetary underdogs, you'll be pleased to know that I've just set up a Facebook fan page for "The Case for Pluto."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I believe that the dinosaur-killer was 10 kilometers (6 miles)--not 1 kilometer (0.6 miles)--in diameter.

[ALAN ADDS: Yes, you're right, the estimate I had was far too low. The 1-kilometer size is something of a standard for catastrophic collision events. I've corrected the estimate cited in the posting. Thanks for setting me straight, Jason!]

Alan,
If the thing lands on your head, regardless of size, it is a disaster!  The fact that there was less than 15 hours warning is the problem.  Our McDonald's worth of skywatchers is ridiculous.  If we go out like the dinosaurs we deserve it!  Of course our leaders will have re-located to a safe unspecified location.

It takes time to detect, identify and confirm an orbit.  Not much can be done in 15 hours.  You certainly can't hope to do more than lob a nuke at it.  By the time you could, the electro-magnetic pulse effects might be worse than the impact you might have prevented.  That's for just a little guy.

What are you going to do for something bigger that sneaks in under the the radar, so to speak?  Might be that the lucky ones are at the impact point.
These events seem to be increasing lately. Is it possible that like the Perseids event (comet remains) every Fall there is another event with much bigger period and substantial objects?
I'm curious to see what the new orbital track proves to be after 2009 VA starts outbound from the Sun (after being subjected to the earth's and Sun's gravitational fields).  And of course, it's new orbital period-when will it return, if ever ???
We should be focusing our efforts exclusively on Meteor Prevention, and other such mega events, not on going to Mars.
"Well, we got to Mars but now there is nowhere left to land back on Earth..."
the goverment should have a planned something for future threats. i think that the goverment should bulid a laser the size of a telesope so when the watch's see the threat then they can blast it in half.
Alarm button for whom?  What,if any,are the government/scientific parameters (size, distance, timeframe, etc)for public notfication of an imminent strike? Are all tracked asteroids singular or have they identified potential "clusters" (for example 3-small 1KM asteroids traveling in close orbit as opposed to 1-larger 3KM asteroid)?
Thank goodness for Jupiter. Our big ol' pal's giant gravitation field makes Earth collisions far less likely. Thanks you big gassy fella!
I think that more bigger asteroids is gonig to hit the earth
Wow! Fun stuff! It's new orbit can be almost any heliocentric ellipse, with one restriction: it must still intersect Earth's orbit at the same place. So, unless another planet does us a favor and changes it's orbit again, we will be seeing 2009VA again.....   and again . . .
too bad we couldn't attach a tracking device to that rock....just for tabs the next time.
An excellent duck-and-cover article Alan!  That was a little surprising in the not so good way Friday when I head about the near miss.  Good thing 2009 VA was small and wouldn't have done damage had it entered Earth's atmosphere.  Just goes to show how vast the space around our planet is and how difficult it is to spot these near Earth objects.  Amazing we can track stuff only 4 inches big in orbit.

Sure is a lot of space junk in orbit.  What's needed is a space garbage man with a space garbage truck to go around and collect all the trash that's orbiting around Earth.  Sooner or later something bad is going to happen as some piece of space junk hits the International Space Station or an orbiting manned flight or even just an already existing satellite.  Too bad the shuttles are being retired as the shuttles would be most excellent space garbage trucks with their own robotic arms to pick up pieces of space junk.
Well,I beleive that what took out the dinosaurs as well as a number of other creatures was the Biblical flood that Noah,his wife,his sons and their wives.And the bible does say that a huge star(ie asteroid) will hit the earth.Of course,I don't expect any of you to believe me or the bible.You are to busy believing yourselves.
this is very interesting 2 me & im only 10. this helps me a lot because i need a science current event & i  think this the one. well thanks again and wish me luck.
WOW. Guess the defense Dept. now has 19,001 objects to track.  I heard nothing about the explosion over Indonesia.  Hush Hush huh???  how close will it be when and if it returns because of the bend created by our gravity?
Seems to me that it's not "if", but when are we going to be hit again by a history altering asteroid. We need to implement an international defense in depth approach to protect Earth. I had a thought concerning how we might defend Earth from many of the potential threats from space. We should deploy a space-based sensor field around earth looking for objects that are on a trajectory to hit Earth. When an inbound object is detected whose size, speed and trajectory pose a big enough threat that warrants action, a space based pulse laser satellite field should be automatically employed to quickly target and repeatedly strike the object until it and its resulting fragments are broken up into small enough sizes that they no longer pose a significant threat.  This would be a last line of defense type of system for our protection. Other bigger threats could be delt with while they are further away. Numerous approaches should be explored for that.

I'm sure that this would be an expensive endeavor, but justifiable nonetheless given the consequences of a failure to act. I don't relish the thought of mankind or other creatures here suffering from an impact or worse - going the way of the dinosaurs who likely died off in a day or so due to the results of a major impact.
Maybe the earth is moving into a larger debris field within the arms of our own galaxy. Who knows, maybe more and larger ones one the way.  Anybody counting.
Isn't this story about a meteor strike in Canada also pertinent?

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/27848645/from/ET/

It was termed a "meteor," which I find a bit confusing. It seems that a rock which doesn't stike the Earth is an asteroid and a rock which does stike the Earth (or at least enter the atmosphere) is a meteor. There don't seem to be any quantitative distinctions in size, just destination.

First sentence... "came within", not "came with". Proofread!

[ALAN ADDS: Yup, I don't know how that one slipped by. Thanks!]

Just goes to show spending money on space(preventing asteroid collisions, future colonies) is not a waste of money..
I bet this is the one that is supposed to hit the Earth in 2012 and end everything!  I guess it got here a little early and will just have to float around for a few years before hitting Earth.  I wonder if asteroids twitter each other?  If they do, destoying the Earth may not be in their best interest.
Isn't it strange that asteroids and meteors can wiz past and through our atmosphere and never once hit a satelite and take it out or down in some spectacular fashion??
Theres also an asteroid, 433 Eros, that is believed to have a path that, in 800 years or so, will collide with Earth and, because of its high rpm spin in orbit, will impact the surface with devastating results.
2012, baby!
2009 VA illustrates a point I have tried to make previously, in other venues - and that is that asteroid orbits are not fixed things but fully reactive to a variety of environmental factors.  I was not happy with the NASA effort to impact a satellite into the comet they hit last year, for this very reason, because the asteroid or comet in question was in fact inert to Earth at the time and I did not think it appropriate to risk altering its' orbit so next time around it might hit.  The same can be said about any number of other objects that NASA has predicted as future misses.  They are not necessarily guaranteed misses because there are magnitudes of years, miles, and potential orbit changing encounters ahead of them - many if not most that we can not possibly foresee, let alone measure.   To say a recent near miss object will again be a near miss and not a direct hit, or conversely nowhere near item 15 or 20 years from now is to say the least an example of remarkable hubris.
i don't believe what they say they knew about the asteriod and they say it was detected 15 hrs before thats not true so why they don't tell us about the other ones thats ....
December 21 2012....Hmm, an omen? LMAO!!!
Jimmy Crackhorns: Space, to quote the late and great Douglas Adams, is really big. Satellites and astroids are so tiny compared to the relative size of this system that the chances of them colliding are incredibly remote. For this same reason, the space junk we leave in orbit around Earth (almost) never collides.

Dana: I'm starting to wonder about that too. As I understand it, meteorites are little space rocks that hit Earth, meteors are little space rocks that enter our atmosphere, meteoroids are little space rocks in space, and astroids are big space rocks, both when they are in space and when they hit Earth. I could be wrong though.
Come one 2012. I bet we get all the devastation of Y2K or maybe even less.  It would be good to have a permanent presence in space so that we could develop the technical resources that it would take to detect and deal with a threat of this nature. It is I think the best argument for continuing the exploration of space by men and machines. That 2012 foolishness is getting a little out of hand though.

The Mayan calendar predicted the end of this age. This means that our solar system is passing through the galactic plane as the year 2012 approaches. The mass of the sun and planets keeps them from deviating in their orbits. It is speculated that a region of space debris known as the "Oort Cloud" encases our solar system. Because the objects in this region are less massive, their motion does not coincide with the larger objects, such as planets, in relation to the sun's orbit.This sets up relative motion between them.In addition dark matter is located in mainly in the spiral arms that we are now tranversing. The visble matter is not the main gravitational consideration for the smaller objects, the dark matter is. Most objects that pass use do so unoticed. Also a meteor is the name of the rock when it is in space. A meteorite is there name once they strike earth. An asteroid originate usually from the asteroid belt near Mars and is suspected to be a planet that never formed or destroyed by impact. Meteors origins are unknown. They may come from the Oort Cloud, but it is unknown because an object that size is unobservable at 2 or 3 billion miles current technology.
"it's best to be prepared"
--
prepared... to do... what?
--
however, in the mean time...
--
reading this article (with a mix of "kilometers" and "miles") I've thought that (while waiting that NASA and others will, finally, abandon the imperial system) a great campaign (of ALL scientific journalists, magazines, books, wiki articles, space & science websites, forums and blogs) could be to use ONLY the metric system
--
do you want to start now this campaign?
--
astroids are space rocks, meteors are what they are when they enter the atmosphere, and its called a meteoroid when it reaches the earth's surface, so basically its three different words to describe the same thing and interchangeable depending on location.
Wow. So whose to say earth isn't just some giant space rock bound to collide with another giant space rock? Maybe not only will earths creatures die but maybe there will be life or some sort of clues of life other then earth traveling on these so called "space rocks". But even at that we need to in some way shape or form develop a defense system for astroids. Funny how the movie "Armageddon" pops into mind!
Myself personally, I’d blow it up with anything I had.
Whatever got blown out to space would miss us.
The rest would be the different between being hit by buck shot or bird shot.
Well, I think these little guys will always be hard to spot, but then again, they don't pose too much of a threat if they do hit.  However, even if we do spot them....then what?  Say a 10km armageddon asteroid is baralling down on earth,  would we be able to move it in time?  For an asteroid that size, that's an awful large mass.  We'd probably need decades of forewarning inorder to put together a plan and implement it....we're not going to be able to just blow it out of the sky like in the movies.  If we had, say, 1 year of warning, could it be done?  Hmmm...
My dog says that she thinks that Global Warming attracts Asteroids!
Bill I like 12022012 better
It’s unfortunate that information regarding approaching comets are not published.  Today we have the required data to make a calendar of these approaching rocks, and publish them, this will not create a sudden fear among people, it would protect innocent people from the drivers of the planet.

I use an asteroid watch widget, one can get it from Nasa’s website, since it work’s on yahoo widget suit, one has to download and install the suit first, and then download the widget, one can get the information on Nasa’s page itself, in today’s time one needs to keep such stuff since more harm may be done by the people themselves then the asteroid.

An asteroid 2009 VZ size 190 meters will pass by on 16th from a distance of 15 LD the date of which was recalculated from 22nd to 16th
It's sad the money we waste on things. We spend millions of dollars on rovers and satellites that only paint small pictures for hope. We as humans need to see the big picture here. I understand what they are doing on mars and the use of satellites around other planets. I'm not saying they're bad ideas. I just think we need use our money and resources in a better way. 15 hours is sad. I dont care what size it is. NASA and the US government better start rethinking their spending and come up with a better defense and better lookout. Why do they think mars looks the way it does...if we dont act now millions of years from now some other life somewhere else is going to wonder if there was ever life on earth....
That crack about the bible is a beauty, whether or not "we" believe it or ourselves is neither here nor there in this comment section, we certainly have the right to believe who and what we choose to. However I am totally amazed to "learn" that Noah and his clan were living at the same time as the dinosaurs, that IS a new one to me. I always thought that humans missed the dinosaurs by a few million years!
Actually, Lewis, we believe the evidence, and the bible doesn't pass even the most basic smell test. It stinks.
I saw the first meteor on 11/12/09 at 1:15 in the morning there was a bright flash in the sky when i looked over to my left i saw a stream of fire and the meteor in front of it that just melted away scared me but i thought it was the coolest thing i had ever seen
what difference will it make we will have done the world long before we get hit keep on burning that gas!
For all you fools who believe in 2012 u are fools...just like Y2K right!!
Breaking News
Our Favorite Community Orgnanizer, B. Obama, just appointed an "Asteroid Czar", so everyone can sleep easy tonight!
to francisco oroville WA
you have been watching too much TV.
cant be done that easily.
BTW, we already have HUGE lasers bigger than any telescope ever built.
I think events like this underscore three things that the human race needs which are not being met by the current world government's woefully inadequate program funding. 1) The need to develop and deploy technologies to accurately identify space hazards in a timely manner, 2) technologies to mitigate space hazards, if at all possible, when they are identified, and finally 3) The need to develop and deploy technologies to permit life to be seeded on other worlds so that worst case, unavoidable, space hazards will not have the potential to wipe out higher life forms in this solar system.
It is really sad that we are supposed to be the most intelligent creatures on this planet yet we put so little into the budget to protect this planet from outside rogue celestial objects that could end life as we know it. But we can spend insane amounts of money on immediate issues when those “could happen at any time” events would wipe out those immediate concern issues along with most of the life on this planet.

  Space is our future and we should be putting the focus on that future both in exploration and ways to protect our planet for outside dangers.
 It is truly sad when people cannot remove their focus from right now results when they could save money, energy and time but looking at the future while planning for the here and now.

 If you want an example of this process; just look at the mortgage crisis that just happened. Focus on right now profits and not looking at potential future results. We all know how that IS working out.  
OMG the bible comment was hilarious.I am astounded that you think humans and Dinos lived together. According to common sense and EVIDENCE; humans missed the dinos my tens of millions of years.

we need to protect ourselves from outerspace junk rather than waste money on other things. But you know us humans; we only learn from mistakes. I just hope if an astrioid does hit us.. it doesn't hit anywhere near north America and the size of the asteroid is pretty small
To the people saying that we can simply blow up incoming objects....
Remember, these things are travelling at hundreds or thousands of miles per second. Even if you break the object up into little pieces, those pieces are still going to follow the same path because of their momentum. While our atmosphere is better able to burn up smaller pieces, it is not an ideal solution.

Diverting objects is far more realistic. Think of how small thrusters on the space station are used to move it to different orbits to avoid debris. The space station is travelling on average at over 17,000mph, yet it takes a relatively small amount of thrust to change it's orbital position.

That same theory can be applied to the orbital path of other objects. A small change in the orbital path can mean the difference between a collision or a near miss.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=2124702

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google