ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



How the Maya lived

Posted: Monday, November 09, 2009 6:56 PM by Alan Boyle


Courtesy of Nat'l Academy of Sciences / PNAS
The southeast corner of a painted pyramid excavated at a site in Mexico shows
scenes from everyday Maya life in the A.D. 620-700 time frame.

Murals found on a buried Mexican pyramid reveal how the average Maya lived about 1,350 years ago - shedding light on aspects of Maya society that are "virtually unknown," researchers say.

Almost all of the artifacts associated with the ancient Maya civilization have to do with the ruling class and religious life: the secrets of the Maya's ritual blue paint, or their monumental religious panels, or the arrangement of their temples, or even their controversial calendar.

In contrast, precious little has remained from the everyday lifestyles of ordinary Maya. Some hints have emerged in recent years. For example, archaeologists analyzed the chemical residues of Classic Maya settlements to determine that the Maya had a functioning market economy. But when it comes to visualizing how that market worked, the murals found at Mexico's Calakmul site provide the best picture yet.

The murals are "quite stunning," said William Saturno, an archaeologist at Boston University who was not involved in the Calakmul project but has found a few Maya treasures of his own.

One painting shows a man wearing what appears to be a colorful, broad-brimmed sombrero as he mixes up a big pot of maize gruel (think of thin corn soup). Another man with an ornate headdress and fancier garb drinks from a bowl of the stuff as a female server looks on.


Courtesy of Nat'l Academy of Sciences / PNAS
This black-and-white rendering of a painted scene from the Calakmul pyramid
shows the serving and drinking of "maize-gruel."

In a different mural, a female tamale-vendor offers her wares on a platter, to a man who is already munching on one of the tamales.

Other pictures show how the foodstuffs went to market:

  • A bearer carrying a heavy pot on his back wears a patterned headband to help him distribute the load.

  • A man with a basket and spoon is designated in Maya hieroglyphs as a "salt person." (Salt was a staple of the Maya diet.)

  • A group of figures gather around bowls and a tied sack in a picture labeled with the hieroglyphs for "maize-grain person."

  • A "tobacco person" holds a spatula and a pot that presumably contains a processed form of the leaf.

  • A woman wearing a sombrero sits alongside a basket holding ceramic pots. You guessed it: She's labeled as the "clay-vessel person."


Courtesy of Nat'l Academy of Sciences / PNAS
A mural reproduced in black-and-white shows a woman with ceramic cylinder vessels in a basket. The hieroglyphs above the pots identify the woman as "clay-vessel person."

The paintings and their meanings are laid out in a research paper appearing online today in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. The paper's authors include Ramon Carrasco Vargas of Mexico's National Institute of Anthropology and History, Veronica Vazquez of the National Autonomous University of Mexico, and Simon Martin of the University of Pennsylvania Museum.

The site where the murals were found is on the Mexican part of the Yucatan peninsula, near the Guatemalan border. Archaeologists have known about the Calakmul site since 1931, and it's been under study for more than 15 years. Over the past five years, Carrasco Vargas and his colleagues have been digging into an arrangement of 68 buried structures known as the Chiik Nahb complex.

The tallest feature in the complex, called Structure 1, looked like a collapsed mound from the surface. But it was actually a buried pyramid that measured about 36 feet (11 meters) on each side and once rose to a height of 15 feet (4.7 meters).

The researchers dug a tunnel to explore the interior, and found that the pyramid had been remodeled several times over as much as 600 years. They were amazed to find that one of the remodelings included the addition of murals on panels and sidewalls of the pyramid's three tiers. Based on the style of pottery depicted in the paintings, the researchers estimate that the paintings were done sometime between the year 620 and 700.

About 30 pictures have been documented so far. To create the murals, shades of blue, green, yellow, red and brown were applied to a gray-white stucco background, and each panel was framed with red lines. The paintings were apparently done in two phases, with the more skilled artwork created during the second phase.

"Costumes range from simple loincloths and tied-cloth headbands to more elaborate headgear and clothing decorated with painted or woven designs," the researchers reported. "Such distinctions probably reflect different social status. ... Women often wear face-paint, sometimes extending below the neckline, and both sexes wear ear ornaments, necklaces and pendants."

The pictures help flesh out our mental pictures of everyday life during the Maya's heyday, but mysteries remain: For example, several of the murals include hieroglyphs that denote the name or title of a female. Who was she? And why were such common but lively scenes painted on the pyramid? Was this the central monument for a Maya marketplace?

So far, the answers to those questions are far from clear.

"The full implications of these finds will take time to evaluate and requires the exposure of all the paintings," the researchers wrote. "Ongoing excavations will more fully situate Structure 1 within the wider archaeological context of the Chiik Nahb complex and aid its interpretation."

At least one thing is clear, however: The Calakmul murals could well open up a new archaeological frontier.

"We have very little hard information about the social processes by which foodstuffs and goods circulated within Maya polities and the varying roles of festivals, gift-giving, communal feasting and exchange, all of which are attested in ethnohistorical sources," the researchers said. "These murals evidently depict one or more of these activities and thereby portray an ancient social mechanism that has left no other evidence of its existence."

Update for 7 p.m. ET Nov. 10: Boston University's William Saturno had more to say about the Calakmul research after he read the published paper. He agreed that the murals are significant and reveal a side of Maya society that has been seen only rarely.

"In terms of the work of public art, I don't know of others that show nondescript people," he told me in a follow-up phone call. "They're not nobility. You have titles like 'He of the Corn Gruel.' In that sense, they show a part of Maya life that is not commonly seen in public art."

He also agreed that the report raises further questions that have yet to be answered.

"I have to say I'm puzzled as to why the art is not being discussed as market scenes as opposed to scenes of everyday life," he said. "Some of the things I think are really neat about this are things that are not being emphasized."

Saturno noted that the murals almost exclusively show market transactions rather than, say, the actual production of the goods being traded.

Other researchers have surmised that Structure 1 and its surroundings were the site of an ancient Maya marketplace, Saturno said. "There are all these little, low-walled, stall-like structures that are unprecedented in other Maya sites," he observed. The implication, then, is that the pyramid indeed served as a public monument with a market theme.

"Maybe we're finally looking at a Maya market," Saturno said, "and if we're looking at a Maya market, that's really cool."

More about everyday life in ancient times:

While we're on the subject, I'll take this opportunity to mention a book that was written about everyday life in not-quite-ancient times: "The Year 1000: What Life Was Like at the Turn of the First Millennium." This readable volume, by Robert Lacey and Danny Danziger, delves into such topics as how to fasten your clothes in a world without buttons, or the recipe for a medieval form of Viagra. It's this month's selection for the Cosmic Log Used Book Club, a collection of books on cosmic themes that you should be able to find at your local library or secondhand-book shop.

And while we're talking about millennial matters, I'll note that Penn Museum's Simon Martin, one of the authors of the Calakmul study, also has some choice things to say about the "2012" Maya apocalypse claims


Join the Cosmic Log team by signing up as my Facebook friend or following b0yle on Twitter. And pick up a copy of my new book, "The Case for Pluto." If you're partial to the planetary underdogs, you'll be pleased to know that I've just set up a Facebook fan page for "The Case for Pluto."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hi Alan,

I take issue with the two statements at the beginning: "Almost all of the artifacts associated with the ancient Maya civilization have to do with the ruling class and religious life." and "In contrast, precious little has remained from the everyday lifestyles of ordinary Maya."

While I'm not a Mayanist, as in other regions of the world, much of the archaeological research that gets publicity has been focused on the elites and their lives while glossing over the research done on the common people (Egypt, Southwest USA, Central Mexico, etc).  Also, early archaeologists largely focused on the "big & pretty" things, which directed future researchers to focus on those as well.  More recently, there has been a significant amount of research done that does not focus on the big things and instead focuses on the overall community, including the regular folks.  I'm fairly certain there is a fair amount of archaeological remains from the everyday lives of the common people, you just have to look harder to find it as it's usually not as flashy as a pyramid or elaborate burials.
Good. However, you may also mention the need for compensation to what Mayas lost.
Tariq, this article is dealing with the Maya that were inhabiting the Yucatan way before any European intrusion into this part of the Americas.  While European contact several centuries later was a extremely damaging experience to the Maya and other Native peoples throughout the Americas, some countries are beginning to work with the local Maya in order to grow ecotourism associated with their rich archaeological past.

Alan, I didn't want to make it sound as if I didn't enjoy the article.  It's still a very interesting article and thank you for bringing it to a wider audience.
the last of the Maya people number less than 5000, today as we marvel at their lost art we also are attempting to gather them up in the wild.
Seems we are sending some of the same teams from national geographic...seems the did the same in the 1970's in Brazil...those indians died in the slums of brizila...we study history but do not learn, not even from recent history. then the Maya calandar dose end in 2012 just about time for those good people from NG to make contact and move them from the jungle. perhaps they could see the future and their own demise. it Ok there are resources to find and gold is at $1000
Compensation from whom?  The mayans kind of imploded and destroyed themselves, as near as we can tell.
who would one compensate. The advanced Mayan civilization collapsed long before Mexico was conquered by Spain.
Compensation from who and why?
Tariq,  Compensation from whom?  The Aztecs, Spaniards, or Africans who rode reed boats to the Americas?  Perhaps you might consider compensation for the Sumerians, Mesopotamians or Babylonians from your own distant past.
Fascinating stuff ! Thanks for the report and you have re-ignited a hunger in me to continue to follow more recent developments in discoveries related to ancient peoples ( North Americans, the most relevant to our society and lifestyle ). I'll be seeking the Calakmul writings and would be very interested in hearing more from you as more is discovered and linked to how it all relates to life in 2010 "and Beyond ! ""
Wow, the ancient Mayans cooked food and ate it.  We sure learned a lot from this startling discovery!
Excellent article Alan!  So nice to read an article about the Mayans without a mention of their apocalypse prediction.  Since they couldn't predict the end of their civilization why should anyone believe their apocalypse myth?

Not surprising that most of the art revolves around the rich and religious, those who control society control it's art.  Nice that some art has survived to give us a clue as to how the regular Mayan lived.  We are so lucky to be living during such a golden age of Archaeology where we learned so much about our past.
Like the Cherokee, Chocktaw, Chickasaw and Creek, not to mention all Native Americans - myth's abound - bottom line, different species of most Native Peoples way of living, have been "assimilated" although those who carry a passion regarding their own personal individual 'roots' continue to study the (right) origins.  For those of us doing just that, a much better understanding and appreciation for the 2-5000 years prior to [AD, BC, etc.] exists.  Life goes on...
I just returned (Sat.) from Mexico.  While there I toured the ruins at Chichen Itza.  Yes, there is a
great deal of focus on the Mayan elite classes and
religion, for in their culture, religion was life
and death.  There was no separation of church and
state, and like the Egyptians, the elite class were the only people wealthy enough to build the monuments that survive today - thus the focus on elite and religion are as they are.  The Mayan culture is quite facinating in many regards and I'm still utterly at a loss as to their capability to comprehend and do accurate celestial mechanics computations.  One has to wonder.....regarding the end of the long count calendar in 2012....is it a rebirth into a new age, or a violent end to the old ways....only time will tell.
The need for compensation for what the Maya lost?  What idiocy is this?  Whatever the Maya "lost" happened over 400 years ago, no one is responsible for their long-dead ancestors actions.
Tamal vendor.  One Tamal, two tamales.
Everyone shouldn't get so touchy about Mr. Mahmood's  comment.  Just chalk it up to another person on the planet who feels that there were things that happened 500 or 1000 years ago that make current persons or peoples responsible.  Following that logic we could hold Italians Sophia Loren, the Fiat Corporation and others Romans responsible for crucifying Christ, the Diamond Match Company responsible for the Burning of Alexandria, and, who knows, Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling responsible for the Salem witch trials.  Keep up the good work Tariq.  Great comment.

Dear Friends:
The story of people so far away and so much told and artistically told.  The clothing looks like plaids. Were these from ships that they traveled to.  They have one woman that is sitting that appears to be with child, can you see? They are fashionable, vibrant, the hat or sombraro like is not of straw it appears but leather or other fabric.  The woman use hair pins in their hair gathering is a sophisticated society.  The culture! is there, it shows summer clothing in length and for the heat.

 One woman has something over her face, red, was this for disease, health, religious fashion, the culture.  The men appear respectful of the woman. The advance cuts of the framed pieces are fitted together. Vessels and bags or packaging sophisticated.  Artist today replicating this art works for decor,  frames, homes, business, etc, what a find for design.  Note they are pyramid-like in shape.  Were these from seeing them in that region or mountains of others?  Mankind mimics nature.  The dyes on the plaster casts so strong.  Homes of these in Northern America are they the same?

  Learned techniques as water and nature mix naturally and the learnings and intellect brings forth design, music and art.  Writings on the wall, History!  

Would these people in these art works have existed or the artists if Abortion and government were mixed and allowed or asked for as in Pelosi and Obama? Or other nations?  This is why certain religions and persons are against abortion.  Health care in the USA could soon pay for these with tax dollars if Obamas have their way and the Democrats.  Is this so in your nation? ...

[ALAN ADDS: Sharon's message continues to go wildly off-topic after this point. I'll just note that archaeologists say the Maya practiced child sacrifice, so I'm not sure we'd want to emulate all the aspects of ancient Maya culture.]

Study says ancient Maya sacrificed boys, not virgin girls
http://www.reuters.com/article/scienceNews/idUSWRI32680820080123

As a Mayanist, I would heartily agree with Shaun's sentiments. Over the last 50 years, archaeologists have recovered thousands of artifacts associated with the non-elite Maya. Excavations have examined the remains of non-elite houses, workshops, and agricultural fields.

This mural is unusual because it is possibly the only example of artistic depictions of non-elite (and one of the few to depict people who aren't members of the royal family).

And, it should be noted that the Maya are still alive today, and number well in excess of 5 million people. Saying that the ancient society imploded or that they did themselves in is a gross mischaracterization of what actually happened. Determining what happened to the Classic Period civilization is a complex problem that archaeologists are still trying to determine.
"Wow, the ancient Mayans cooked food and ate it.  We sure learned a lot from this startling discovery!"
RonC (Sent Tuesday, November 10, 2009 9:41 AM)

How much we learn is often limited by how much we are able to learn.  For some people that limit is just a little lower than for others.
I guess the flood of Noah's time missed them !
Fascinating.... looking forward to hear more about this. It's true that we have of the Mayan culture only the more religious depictions up to now... .
In a society that was huge, in both population and land utilization, these wall paintings can give insight into the culture in very specific ways.  First, the headdress of the woman who is serving the maize gruel might have been consistent for that "line of work" or station in society.  Since communications would have been difficult for such a vast empire, bright colors and specific dress might have been used as advertising, or just like we currently use a business sign.(Their homes or businesses painted in those colors)  It is all conjecture, but since the accomplishments of these "ancient" peoples is unquestioned, we must also assume that they had systems in place to simplify their interactions.  These paintings say a lot more than they prepared and ate food.
"Wow, the ancient Mayans cooked food and ate it.  We sure learned a lot from this startling discovery!"
RonC (Sent Tuesday, November 10, 2009 9:41 AM)

How much we learn is often limited by how much we are able to learn.  For some people that limit is just a little lower than for others. Tim Rommes, Washington, UT (Sent Tuesday, November 10, 2009 8:41 PM)

Maybe Tim could enlighten us dimwits as to the startling part of this discovery.  Is it that they cooked and consumed food or that the refered to the tamale guy as "tamale guy".  My dim brain has always imagined that each human civilization consumed local food on a more or less daily basis.  But then, I'm no Tim Rommes.  

[ALAN ADDS: The key discovery is that we get a pictorial glimpse of how ordinary folks (as opposed to royals, priests and their victims) lived in the ancient Maya culture. Specifically, what their market activity was like, what they wore, what they used... I hope Bill Saturno's comments (added after the item was originally published) provide further insights into the significance.]
I noticed nobody responded to John, who might be interested to learn that modern Mayan populations are estimated to total about 7 million people.
The problem is that we can not be sure YET if it is a market place scene and that the Chiik Nahb Acropolis was, therefore, a market (and the original PNAS text doesn't say that). Other explanations include ritual and communal feasting, a banquet, etc. The precinct in which Structure I is located has a southern delimitation which show mural paintings of a completely different kind: with watery imagery of waterlilies, birds, aquatic snakes, fishes, and turtles.

I am not sure either if these are so ordinary folks. They are important enough to be painted on a pyramid. Some wear jade jewelry: bracelets, necklaces, and/or earrings. Some wear too elaborate headdresses, one even the so-called Spangled Turban headdress. I would guess most are elite, though maybe not of the royal kind. There is one woman wearing a magnificent transparent blue huipil with glyphs who is without doubt higher elite. There are some servants and carriers, too, which might be non-elite. Clearly, more excavations in the parallel buildings of the complex are needed to get a better idea of the whole precinct and of the actions depicted in the mural paintigs.  
Great article!! but Jon from Cincinnati apparently doesn't know that there are still over 8 000 000 Mayans in Yucatan, Belize, Guatemala and Honduras. Many do not speak Spanish; others have it as a second langu
I agree with Michael, Toronto, that the current Maya population far exceeds 5000.  I've lived in Guatemala within the past 12 years.  I've seen as many as 5000 Maya people at one time at one festival or another within the borders of Guatemala City, not to mention all those I've seen in the towns west and north of the city.  Many of them speak one of the 23 or so Guatemalan Maya languages better than they speak Spanish.
HEY.!
WHATS THE MARKETPLACE ABOUT?
CAN SOMEONE TELL ME PLZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ!!!!!!!!!!!!
I NEEED IT FOR MY SOCIAL STUDIES PROJECT!
:]]
HELP ME! I NEED HELP! FROM YOUUUUUUUUUUUUU! I NEED IT FOR My SOCIAL STUIDES DEBATE PROJECX!
:]]


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=2123180

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google