ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



Lights, camera ... Hubble!

Posted: Monday, September 28, 2009 7:43 PM by Alan Boyle


NASA
Astronaut Drew Feustel looms large as he moves a corrective-optics package from
the Hubble Space Telescope to a stowage position during May's final servicing
mission. This view was captured by the Imax 3-D camera in Atlantis' cargo bay.

"Hubble 3D," due to premiere next March in super-screen Imax theaters, is shaping up as a fitting sendoff for the world's best-known telescope as well as the most complicated flying machine ever built.

Atlantis' trip to the Hubble Space Telescope in May may have marked not only the last time that astronauts put their hands on the crown jewels of NASA's astronomical assets, but also the last opportunity for filming a Hollywood-style production aboard a space shuttle.

"It made me sentimental," admitted Toni Myers, the film's producer, director and editor.

Myers has been involved in half a dozen big-screen space documentaries, including "Hail Columbia!" - which dates back to the dawn of the space shuttle age in 1981. Almost three decades later, "Hubble 3D" may be the last of the breed.

"The film age is definitely pretty much coming to an end," she said. It so happens that the space shuttle age is nearing its end as well. If NASA sticks to its current schedule, the fleet's final flight will take place in the latter part of next year - perhaps just as "Hubble 3D" is coming out on DVD.

Of course, you're missing the whole point if you wait for the DVD. The idea behind Imax 3-D is that you get a seven-story-high view of the cosmos, as seen through polarized glasses that make you feel as if you can reach out and touch the spacesuits.

Myers' 2002 film, "Space Station 3-D," set the precedent for the Hubble epic - but for May's mission, which focused so heavily on five lengthy spacewalks, the Imax camera equipment in Atlantis' cargo bay had to be shrunk to the size of four shoeboxes. That's a particularly stiff challenge because the 70mm Imax film is twice as wide as standard movie film. What's more, the 3-D effect requires the use of a complex lens system that exposes one frame for the left eye, then one frame for the right eye, cycling 24 times a second.

The camera has to push through 672 feet of film for every minute of shooting, and because the remote-controlled camera was shooting in Atlantis' open cargo bay, there's no opportunity for changing film. "That camera takes a single load of film a mile long, and that mile gives us eight minutes," Myers said.


NASA
Camera operator Peter Kragh, at left, moves the Imax 3-D camera to film
astronauts Mike Good (foreground) and Mike Massimino (inside a Hubble mockup)
as they rehearse repair procedures underwater at NASA's Neutral Buoyancy Lab in
Houston in April, a month before their flight.

If you have only eight minutes of film to cover an eight-hour spacewalk, you have to choose your shots wisely. So, in the months leading up to the mission, the "Hubble 3D" film crew and Atlantis' space crew meticulously planned a list of shots for each outing.

Shuttle pilot Greg Johnson was put in charge of controlling the cargo bay camera from inside the crew cabin. After taking a look at the footage he shot, he pronounced himself satisfied with his gig as a cinematographer.

"I can tell you I didn't mess it up, I didn't screw it up," he told me last week during a talk at Seattle's Museum of Flight. "That was not a given, because of the changing lighting."

In fact, some of the footage is downright spectacular, Myers said. She marveled over one shot in particular, during which spacewalker Drew Feustel floated right in front of the camera while carrying a huge corrective-optics package away from Hubble. "You can see every stitch in his suit," she said.

You'll see the spacewalkers do their incredibly complex jobs in fine detail and glorious 3-D, against the backdrop of a sparkling telescope and a shining Earth. But you probably won't see a lot of footage about the mission's hairier moments - for example, the time spacewalker Mike Massimino had to wrench off a handrail with his gloved hands to get at an instrument in need of repair.

Although the movie refers to those twists and turns in the mission plan, Myers said she would have required a TV special to delve that deeply into Atlantis' tale. In fact, that's exactly the approach taken in "Hubble's Amazing Rescue," a "Nova" documentary due to premiere on PBS on Oct. 13.

The "Nova" show explains the nuts and bolts of the Atlantis mission - figuratively (by getting into the detailed mechanics behind the problems that spacewalkers encountered) as well as literally (by telling how engineers on Earth created specialized tools to help the spacewalkers unscrew more than 100 tiny screws).

"Hubble 3D" complements "Hubble's Amazing Rescue" by focusing on the big picture. "The main theme is to celebrate Hubble and its legacy - and that legacy is ongoing," Myers said.

To supplement the 3-D views captured during the spacewalk, Myers uses on-the-ground imagery as well as digital video that was taken in 2-D aboard Atlantis - and then converted to synthetic 3-D with Imax's DMR software.

Then there are the 3-D renderings of actual Hubble pictures, which could well outdo the spacewalks when it comes to jaw-dropping cosmic awesomeness. The telescope itself doesn't take 3-D pictures, but Myers' team worked with Hubble's handlers at the Space Telescope Science Institute to add the third dimension to some of the orbiting observatory's greatest hits. The movie will also feature imagery captured after Hubble's upgrade.

Myers said one sequence will take viewers on a 3-D flight from Earth to the Orion Nebula's Trapezium Cluster. Another will zoom out from the Milky Way out to the gobs of galaxies in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field, and from there out to the large-scale cosmic web. This YouTube fly-through of the Hubble Ultra Deep Field hints at what you can expect, but the 3-D effect will give you even more of a sense that you're moving through the universe at warp speed.

Will "Hubble 3-D" be Myers' swan song? Don't count on it: Film cameras may be on the wane, but Myers said professional-quality digital cameras will soon be ready to take their place in space. And even though the shuttle program may be entering its twilight time, Myers still has lots of space visions she'd like to pursue. For example, she's dreaming about a follow-up to "Blue Planet," a 1990 Imax film that featured outer-space imagery of Earth.

"I would dearly love to update that film," Myers said.

What about NASA's program to develop new spacecraft to replace the shuttle? Is there a "Project Constellation 3-D" in the works? Not yet, Myers said. There's still too much about that program that's, well, up in the air.

"For the public, you have to plan some kind of film that has some payoff to it. ... You can't really go shooting footage of some engine test with no hope of resolution," she said.

But when NASA sets a course beyond Earth orbit - whether it's heading to the moon, or Mars, or some other far-off destination - you can bet the 3-D cameras won't be far behind. In fact, virtuality may be the way that most people experience outer space a generation from now. At least that's where Myers is heading with "Hubble 3-D" and her other big-screen movies.

"That's definitely an aim of the films," she said, "to introduce people to the wonders of space, perhaps people who haven't thought about it before."

More 3-D delights:


Imax and Warner Bros. Pictures are due to bring out "Hubble 3-D" on March 19, 2010.

Join the Cosmic Log team by signing up as my Facebook friend or following b0yle on Twitter. And reserve your copy of my book, "The Case for Pluto," which is coming out next month.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

So when will I get a pay check from this movie studio for filming something I paid for with my taxes?
Myers has been involved in half a dozen big-screen space shuttle documentaries, including "Hail Columbia!" - which dates back to the dawn of the space age in ... 1981.  1981??  Apparently Myers never heard of John Glenn or Project Mercury which predated the 1981 dawn of the space age by only about ... 20 years.  This is intelligent journalism??

[ALAN ADDS: Sheesh, no. That was supposed to be "shuttle age," not "space age." I don't know where that came from, I suspect it was a combination of removing the wrong word and missing that in the editing process. Thanks for pointing out that sin of omission. Mea culpa!]
It's sad that the budget for this Film is probably enough to pay the mortgages and keep a roof over income challenged families for the next decade. Seriously, who cares, oh look the pretty stars! They know because if you look down you'll see all the people they are depriving of having a necessity.
What is really sad is the apparently narrow vision of people like x181 and echelon 64 in realizing the fantastic monetary gain made by private companys from the spinoffs from the space industry, and the jobs created to support it, not to mention the great gains in medical products and research. what is also sad is that most of the people that lost their homes due to the economy were probably living way beyond their means to start with. I would gladly , if asked, climb in the next shuttle and take to orbit, and operate the cameras at no cost to the taxpayers (I'd even pack my own pb&j sandwiches)....they wouldn't even have to ask twice!
Cynics know the price of everything and the value of nothing. I see a lot of cynical comments here. The Hubble is the premier telescope in the world, it's wonderful that it was repaired and updated for another ten years of amazing discoveries. Who knows? Maybe one of those discoveries will lead to cheap clean power, or a better way to manage our climate, or even new materials to put America's unemployed back to work with living wages again. We won't know if we don't try. But even if it does none of these things the effort and money are still well spent. If you're not busy growing, you are busy dying. I'm glad to see this country is still growing, still learning, still reaching for the stars. Go Hubble!
If we put space exploration (or any big science) on hold until the world was a liberal utopia, nothing would ever get done.  Some of the people on the planet who are in dire straights have also been the beneficiaries of science and technology.  Indeed, there are hundreds of thousands of people around the world who are still here because of money "wasted" years earlier on basic science.  If the world's space agencies spend the enormous sums necessary so that some day they actually prevent the impact of an extinction-event level asteroid/comet strike, that will be worth all the money ever spent on science.
Oh, come on echelon64. What does any of this have to do with your mortgage? It's not NASA's signature on your mortgage papers. NASA and the filmmakers aren't depriving anyone of anything. If you need to blame someone for your or others' situation(s), try checking the mirror.
I should know. I've been RIF'd for 18 months with plenty of outstanding debts. Haven't had medical insurance for years. NASA hasn't deprived me, the "rich" haven't deprived me (I hope to be one of them eventually), and the government, liberals and conservatives haven't deprived me. I made life decisions, and I'm responsible for them. I have no right to a job, medical insurance (it's a product, not a right) or happiness (only the right to pursue it). I do have the freedom to take whatever I can find or imagine and make something of it. Right now, I'm trying to get my own business off the ground using (interestingly enough) photographic technology that NASA helped to foster.
My thanks to the folks at NASA for your contributions to an enormously wealthy economy in which I have had the pleasure to live for 55 years. Sorry I didn't join you in the astronaut core long ago. I intended to, but decided to give up that dream (chickened out) when I saw how difficult it might be. Now I watch others do what I could have done. Oh well, it's never too late to get off my rear and do something, and  I'll just bet I can become very successful even in this economy.
As for the cost of what NASA does, I only wish we would give them some REAL money. No telling what could be accomplished.
Speaking of accomplishments, NASA's are many, and I hope to live to see many more. This time around though, I think they are going about it all wrong. Forget the moon and Mars. It's space and the technology to travel it that is the REAL prize. Once you accomplish that, people can go anywhere they want.
Yes, echelon64, look at the pretty stars! And thank people like those at NASA for the closeup. It helps keep us looking up.
I think this is great.  It hopefully will get a lot of kids interested in space, and they are the next generation of space travelers.  The ones who may make it to Mars.  For all the money we have spent between Hubble and the Shuttles, it will be great to see in depth footage of the two at work.  And on a huge screen none the less!

Well, the film was shot only 8 minutes on the shuttle. But, I believe it will inspire a whole new generation of thinkers who will make the world a better, kinder place. Thank you for filming the Hubble improvements. Thank you for improving the Hubble telescope. By the way, Hubble, I'm sure, can spot asteroids which might hit earth. We might be thanking our lucky stars for that!

[ALAN ADDS: I should correct the misimpression that it was eight minutes for the entire mission. Actually, it was eight minutes per spacewalk, and there were five spacewalks.]

Folks,
Instead of bringing out the negative opinions and points of view concerning this filming project and the funds required to make it, privately is more like it and granted there is the probability that our tax dollars have been used to fund this film.

How about taking the time and energy to look very closely at what the federal government and your elected representatives are spending our tax dollars on, shall we say kickback payback for political donations and how about all those bloated unnecessary pork barrel projects?

Let’s just try to enjoy the beauty of space and our attempts to explore and understand it all as curious children of a greater being (God, Allah or whatever we children currently call our creator).
It's sad that the others on this board have such a narrow vision that they can only think of themselves. This is science and history. There are still jobs to be had if you want to work. Stop waiting for King Obama's handouts! They aren't coming. Instead, take some pride in our great country's scientific accomplishments. The liberals have done all they can to destroy our country's heritage, history and pride. Stop stooping to their level and pull yourself up by your own bootstraps. Your fathers, grandfathers and greatgrandfathers did in economic times more difficult than today. They loved, believed in and died for this great country.  If you can't, move to Iran. Maybe they will take care of you.
echelon64, you're such a tool...
--
it's absolutely NOT TRUE that, ALL the space-hardware, "MUST" cost TONS OF BILLIONS, since, with LESS THAN ONE BILLION, we can build an "ISS-2" with ARTIFICIAL GRAVITY!!!
--
http://www.ghostnasa.com/posts2/054atvstation.html
--
It's about time the film industry will finally stop making space films and hopfully start making more adult films with cheesy space based themes.  
Can't wait to see this movie. My dream, as a young child, use to be to become an astronaut, to walk on the moon and explore space. I support NASA and everyone behind the scientific space explorations because there is no telling what will come next. We may be on the frontier of a new age of moddern science. Like one of the posters above said, we'll never get anywhere if we put this thing on hold. there is still so much to be discovered. I love being able to watch as new breakthroughs come about every day and if they have to take a whole TWO DOLLARS out of my paycheck every month to do that than so be it. haha 2 DOLLARS if that. [...]
I dont understand why the hubble telescope can take clear pics of far away galaxies, and yet, we still do not have super detail of our own heavenly bodies,the people are getting tires of blurred shots of the moon and other local planets. I like many americans am color deficient and cant see regular 3d at all. so the clear photos help. the clearer the better. I approve of all exploratory space missions,and would like to be able to see everything they find out there.no more censorship. I will enjoy the film im shure there will be much debate over its authenticity.as to where it was actually filmed. have to love immagination.
Hey echelon64 without science we would not have house's and would still be living in the trees to stay safe! and without NASA there would be no computers for you to cry on Boo Hoo
NASA doesn't pay for mortages? I beg to differ. How many thousands of people work for NASA? They buy homes,cars,childrens education,etc. The list is endless as to the effect that NASA has had on everyone in this and other countries. It has put food on the table for many who don't even work in the space field. It has raised the hopes and dreams of many. The poor will always be among us and it's our job to help take care of them. Not just the government's problem.
RG: What an extremely well-thought out and beautifully worded post you had in response to "echelon64's" cynical and negative rant.  You obviously "get it" and took the words right out of my mouth.

And echelon64, IMAX is a private company, not a taxpayer-funded venture.  I should know, IMAX was one of my customers when I worked at the Kennedy Space Center.  They funded their space missions with their own venture capital, with the idea of making a profit showing the footage in cinemas, worldwide (which they successfully did).  Please, spare us all your platitudes of how this money could have been used to pay off the mortgage of some idiot who bought a house that was too much for him to afford in the first place.
To Tom from Mansfield,

Eloquent and correct.
Thanks for the heads up on the new Hubble 3-D film Alan!  I took my Granddaughters to see Space Station 3-D and it was awesome and my Granddaughters enjoyed it immensely.  I look forward to seeing this new Hubble 3-D movie.  Too bad we have whiners here who can't see past their selfish noses to what a great achievement that Hubble and the International Space Station are.  An excellent investment of taxpayer dollars that otherwise would have been wasted on junk if left in taxpayer pockets.
I cannot wait to see this documentary.  Echelon64 and x181, I think, have no clue.  The commenter who said cynics know the price of everything and value of nothing was spot on.  I think it's impossible to overstate the value of Hubble.  Thanks to it's discoveries humanity has a much better idea of how we came into being, our place in the cosmos, the size and shape of our universe, and on and on we could go.  Humanity and science has progressed so much farther than we would have if we spent that money buying off deadbeat mortgages. This movie will stoke the imagination of another generation and remind them of what we can accomplish. I see it as money VERY well spent.
Strange how the best of what we spend our tax dollars on is demeaned by those who most likely approve of pouring trillions of dollars into pointless wars or earmarks for their own pet causes regardless of their merits to the nation as a whole. If left to their own devices, these folks would still be living in the stone age, ranting about the idiot trying to smelt the first bronze tools. The space program has done more to promote the ingenuity and goodwill of our nation and its people than almost anything else we've done. It stands as a beacon of hope in a vast sea of failed political boondoggles.  If the vote is between a rocket to mars or a couple more nuclear subs, I choose the former.
Apparently, the bulk of people who complain about spending money in space, are primarily selfishly motivated.
So sad that not everyone can see the beauty in space, and in exploration. This ability is one of the key things that makes humans stretch their capabilities, and achieve so many things, for the good of all.
We should all work toward a more selfless world, by sharing, and by giving, to those that deserve, not to those that demand or expect.
I think it's hilarious that the people who feel they have a right to complain, are always the first to do so and never reply to back up what they started.  So people who read these articles, if you are planning on complaining, stick around to debate the issue, don't just stick your nose into something of which you know nothing about!!
The people who rode the shuttle,
The people who supported from the ground,
The children who wondered,
The world who watched,
These people still believe and they make good company.
The only thing out in space is some raw material at a few dollars per pound. All the wealth that it represents is still right here on the ground in peoples pocket. It's the best bargin tax payers get for their money. I even got a little of it by helping create equipment that made the metal used to make the Shuttles' engines, as did a bunch of my  coworkers.
Anyone who thinks that space exploration takes money away from society is ignorant or uninformed.

How many people work in the computer industry?  How many people work in solar panels, new generation ceramic materials, or have had their lives enricked by communications satellites, or just the internet?

The billions invested in space technology have already repaid the US economy (and economies around the world) with trillions of dollars circulating through our economy.

If you want to complain about the rich people strealing all the corporate wealth and leaving many without a job, thats got nothing to do with NASA or space.

If you can not get a mortgage, blame your banks and Wall Street for squandering your money, and by giving all the profits to the CEO instead of reinvesting in the US economy.

Our economic suffering is the result of tax giveaways and deregulation of energy and banking industries.

Blame the people who facilitated the greatest theft in US history and then gave the thieves a tax break!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=2082228

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google