ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



Apollo on rewind

Posted: Tuesday, June 23, 2009 8:45 PM by Alan Boyle


Ron Batzdorff / Universal Pictures
"Apollo 13," starring Tom Hanks, Kevin Bacon and Bill Paxton, ranks
among the best fictional movies about NASA's moon effort.

If you're lusting to relive the glory days of NASA's early space effort, the best time for doing that is right now: Video resources about the Mercury, Gemini and Apollo programs are at their peak as the 40th anniversary of humanity's first moon landing approaches. Here's a Top 10 list, plus a couple of extra-credit pointers to more space video:

  • "Apollo 13": Some consider this Oscar-winning 1995 movie about NASA's most agonizing moon mission to be the best dramatic depiction of real-life spaceflight - and a wellspring of space cliches. The duct tape was real, and mission commander Jim Lovell really did say "Houston, we've had a problem" (though Jack Swigert said it first). However, flight director Gene Kranz admits that he never said "failure is not an option" during the mission, though he used the phrase as the title of his autobiography. (Watch a TODAY show video about the film and the reality.)

  • "Fly Me to the Moon": If you're looking for a kid-appropriate retelling of the Apollo 11 saga - in 3-D, no less - this 2008 animated tale about three flies who hitch a ride to the moon might be right up your alley. OK, maybe the reviews weren't super, but those reviews were written by grown-ups and not the movie's target audience. How can you go wrong when it carries the endorsement of Apollo 11 moonwalker Buzz Aldrin (who puts in a cameo at the end)?

  • "For All Mankind": This 1989 documentary uses the best technology of the time to tell the Apollo story, augmented by interviews with the astronauts (who were then 20 years younger than they are today). The film is structured to trace the arc of a single moon mission, using footage from Apollo 11 as well as other moonshots.

  • "From the Earth to the Moon": Big-name actors and actresses take on the roles of the astronauts and the people surrounding them in this 1998 HBO miniseries, hosted by "Apollo 13" star Tom Hanks and based on "A Man on the Moon," Andrew Chaikin's history of the Apollo effort. Many of the 12 shows are not straight-on space operas; rather, they recount the moon missions from the perspective of the astronauts' wives, or the ground controllers, or even (gasp!) the press corps.

  • "In the Shadow of the Moon": The thing I liked most about this highly regarded 2007 documentary was that you get to do the time warp between film footage from the 1960s and contemporary interviews with the Apollo astronauts. Also, audio recordings and film footage from Mission Control were laboriously synched up to flesh out the historical record. 

  • "Live From the Moon: The Story of Apollo Television": This brand-new documentary, produced using Spacecraft Films' video collection (see below), keys on the way that television was used to bring the Apollo experience into America's living rooms.

  • "Magnificent Desolation: Walking on the Moon 3-D": I'm a sucker for any 3-D movie (well, maybe not "My Bloody Valentine"), but this 2005 release is one stereo flick I have yet to catch up with. The film blends re-creations of stereo scenes from NASA's archives with re-enactments of Apollo moments. Director Mark Cohen told me it's a "multiformat, hybrid, documentary, experiential something." Whatever it is, it's on DVD - but I'm holding out to see it someday at a big-screen Imax theater.

  • "The Right Stuff": One of the funniest reality-based space movies, in my opinion, and one of the best. Like "Apollo 13," this 1983 film immortalized such space quips as "no bucks, no Buck Rogers" and "Spam in a can." Like the Tom Wolfe classic on which it was based, the movie focuses on Project Mercury rather than Project Apollo. But it's so good I just can't leave it off the list.

  • "When We Left Earth: The NASA Missions": The producers behind this 2008 documentary series went back to NASA's archives and remastered more than 100 hours of footage from Mercury, Gemini and Apollo in glorious HD. Six hourlong episodes trace the full story of NASA's space effort, moving beyond Apollo into the era of space shuttles, the Hubble Space Telescope and the international space station. 

  • "The Wonder of It All": This 2007 documentary is a complement to "In the Shadow of the Moon," which came out in the same year. "Wonder" focuses less on the technical side of the Apollo effort and more on the astronauts and their post-Apollo reflections. "I came away most impressed," NBC News space analyst James Oberg said in his film review.

In addition to the Top 10, no list of Apollo video would be complete without giving a big shout-out to Spacecraft Films, which offers a lineup of DVDs about space missions and aerospace topics that would easily fill a bookshelf. Most of them give you the straight stuff from each mission - for instance, the three-DVD set for Apollo 11.

For something completely different, you can head on over to YouTube and click through the Disney videos that fired the imaginations of young rocketeers in the 1950s and 1960s. And stay tuned for more to come, including an Apollo 11 docudrama titled "Moonshot" that's likely to show up on the History Channel later this year. Most notably, the Buzz Aldrin role is filled by James Marsters, who made his mark as a bleached-blond bloodsucker in "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" and "Angel."


Did I miss your favorite space movie? Remedy that omission by leaving a comment below. You can also review my roundup of recently published books on the Apollo missions (including Aldrin's latest memoir). Stay tuned for a listing of online resources for the 40th anniversary of Apollo 11.

Join the Cosmic Log corps by signing up as my Facebook friend or hooking up on Twitter. And if you really want to be friendly, ask me about my upcoming book, "The Case for Pluto." 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I like 'humanity's first moon-landing'...makes me feel good...
How about "The Dish," a nice little Australian film about the contribution of land-based radio telescopes to recieve the downlink broadcasts from the moon? Based at least partly on reality, the film takes place at the giant dish in Parkes, NSW as Apollo 11 lands in July 1969.
It's Time Too Go Back (Man&Woman)To RETURN TOO THE MOON Maybe a MOONBASE Too. But First Lets Go back Maned. RETURN!!!to The Moon Luna.!!! 6/24/2009.
watch this movie when I first went to the moon for all of us really thought olacakmı possible? Imagine a day for humanity, such as after gelsede grandchildren will be able to travel to the moon
Alan, thanks for a great compilation there!! I'm six for ten, but when I get back from SD, I'll check out the rest.  Sorry, too old for Twitter or Facebook, but I'm hoping "The Case for Pluto" is a good one!!!!
The list should include "The Dish" (2000) a "true" story about a satellite communication station in Australia that almost prevented the world from seeing the Apollo 11 Moon landing. This looks at the unsung heroes across the globe that helped the world witness history. Starring Sam Neill and filmed at the Parkes Observatory in Australia.
People who consider themselves "sophisticated" movie goers probably did not like it (if they even watched it), but a good movie is "The Starfighter," a fun, good-time-in-the-TV-room flick, good time to watch a movie with the kids.  Space opera and cliches aside, this movie celebrates the human spirit; it is an unashamed celebration of human courage, instead of a screed  denouncing every human endeavor as exploitation of the universe.
Great article Alan that brings back fond memories of my youth watching the Mercury, Gemini and Apollo programs.  I really liked the series "From the Earth to the Moon, it was a great series showing each Apollo mission and did a nice job of showing us how things were back in the 60's.

I sure hope that President Obama rethinks Clueless George's idiotic space race revival of going it alone to the moon and Mars.  I hope that Barack opens up our Ares program to other nations like Canada, Europe, Japan and heck even Russia and China and any other country that wants to join in the space exploration fun.  We need to spread out the monumental costs by allowing other countries to participate and handle a share of those costs.  The International Space Station has shown us that going to space cooperatively with other countries is the best way to go now.
Destination Moon from 1950, written by Robert Heinlein, was the first attempt at a technically accurate space flight film.  The science is plausible, the primitive special effects well done, and the impact on a generation of impressionable ten-year-olds lasted a lifetime.
For an earthbound view of how the tv signals were handled, watch "The Dish." It is a mostly true story, but the characters are great in this Australian film.  Sam Neil is the main character operating the Parkes Radio Observatory, which is located (still!) in the middle of a sheep paddock!
(sigh) I've seen a ton of documentaries and I'm old enough to remember it all, first-hand.

It's sad that so relatively little has been done in the meantime. (Compared to what was planned and intended at the time...we were meant to have reached Mars in the early to mid 1980's, you know, and have a ton of commercial and other manned activity happening in LEO.)

We *should* have been able to commemorate the Anniversary right there *at* the Apollo 11 landing site, by now...

NASA's future is Apollo on rewind: it's future is all 'been there, done that.'

Innovation at NASA has taken a backseat to preserving the status quo...too bad for America and the rest of the world!

"Moon Machines" is a superb documentary series from the Discovery Science Channel.  It covers the Apollo program from the point of view of the (very) many engineers and scientists who were given the task to make it all possible, and provides an in-depth look at just how difficult this technological endeavor proved to be.  

It consists of six episodes: Saturn V, Command Module, Navigation, Lunar Module, Suits, and Lunar Rover.  Many interesting details for those interested in the tech side of things, and PLENTY of footage you've never seen before!

It will be released on DVD July 7th, so I will finally be able to retire those copies I've keeping on my DVR for the past year :-)

http://www.amazon.com/Moon-Machines-Christopher-Riley/dp/B0026IQTR2/ref=wl_it_dp?ie=UTF8&coliid=I222YDL6XPB09B&colid=1KMZCTO4NFSCW
I always liked Tony Palmer's The Space Movie. With plenty of NASA footage, voice-overs by astronauts and music by Mike Oldfield, what's not to like? Too bad it was never reissued on DVD. VHS copies are hard to find.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0062827/ Countdown 1968 a One Way moon landing, with supplies delivered until Apollo is finished. James Caan.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0064639/ Marooned 1969 U.S. Astronauts stranded in orbit.  Inspired the Apollo-Sputnick joint missions, leading to the joint space station missions. David Janssen.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0088611/ Space 1985 - 13 hour mini series, repeats 'The Right Stuff' adds through Apollo plus a fictional backside landing.  James Garner, Blair Brown.
"People who consider themselves "sophisticated" movie goers probably did not like it (if they even watched it), but a good movie is "The Starfighter," "

Are you sure you don't mean 'The Last Starfighter?'

The first film to use extensive CGI for spaceships and space effects, I believe. (the CRAY-1 computer even got credit)
What about Le Voyage dans la lune (Voyage to the moon) of George Melies?? Maybe the First movie about going to the moon.
'Moon Beat' is a new (2009) award-winning documentary which recalls the flight of Apollo XI and the NASA space program from the perspective of the top journalists who covered the mission and the U.S. space program for many years.

News Reporters who appear in Moon Beat include:

John Noble Wilford, New York Times
Reg Turnill, BBC
Al Neuharth, Founder USA Today and Florida Today
Joe Morgenstern, Wall Street Journal Film Critic

and many others. (see website for information and entire list)

http://www.moonbeatthemovie.com/

Also, there is a page (Apollo Memories) on the website where visitors can actually write their own memories of Apollo 11 -- where they were, what they remember, who they watched it with on TV, what newspapers they read, any ideas or thoughts they have about the 40th anniversary and so on.


http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1399582/
Do try www.spacecraftfilms.com for a pile of "golden age of NASA" DVDs.

(I have no connections with these folks, but I am an armchair enthusiast.)
Congratulations on a worthwhile "Top 10" list.  What a pity it wasn't a Top 20!

You really should acknowledge the film "October Sky", based on the autobiographical, "Rocket Boys".  It is a touching and inspiring film, and possibly a great one for kids (depending upon their age).

Also, don't forget the documentary series "Cosmos" by Carl Sagan.  It's a little old nowadays, but still uplifting!

Sagan also wrote the fictional book upon which the film "Contact" (starring Jodie Foster) was based - another film worth a recommendation, in particular because it is the only film in this entire list which features a female scientist as the main character and a positive role model.

Finally, being an Aussie, may I add my endorsement to a couple comments above regarding "The Dish".
Just to correct a comment made above (Michael Prator, Phoenix, AZ)regarding "The Dish", I'm sure you didn't intend to say that the Parkes Observatory in NSW Australia "almost prevented" viewing the moon landing! The film is a humourous fiction, whereas in reality Parkes Observatory had the highest quality reception for the televised footage that was broadcast from the moon, a fact that was belatedly noticed in Houston several minutes after Armstrong stepped onto the surface. The decision was eventually made to use all the footage that was rerouted through Parkes, and that is what the world was watching for almost all of the first moonwalk. This was in part because of the particular design of the satellite dish, which became a model for all the NASA Deep Space Network receiver stations. See the following info:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkes_Observatory

http://www.parkes.atnf.csiro.au/news_events/apollo11/t
v_broadcasts.html
Go to the companies website they are selling these things around the world. I would imagine the companies who are going to lose their jobs over this are pressing very hard to keep it out.
I always liked Tony Palmer's The Space Movie. With plenty of NASA footage, voice-overs by astronauts and music by Mike Oldfield, what's not to like? Too bad it was never reissued on DVD. VHS copies are hard to find.
I like 'humanity's first moon-landing'...makes me feel good... It's Time Too Go Back (Man&Woman)To RETURN TOO THE MOON Maybe a MOONBASE Too. But First Lets Go back Maned. RETURN!!!to The Moon Luna.!!! 6/24/2009.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1974994

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google