ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



A close one for the space station

Posted: Thursday, March 12, 2009 12:54 PM by Alan Boyle


NASA illustration
  Click for video: NBC
  News' Tom Costello
  reports on the space
  station's close call.

The international space station's three crew members climbed into their Soyuz lifeboat as a "precautionary measure" while a piece of space junk passed by today, NASA said. The space agency said the debris from a spent satellite rocket motor zipped past, apparently without causing damage, and the crew was given the all-clear to return to the station and resume normal operations.

NASA spokesman Bill Jeffs said this sort of maneuver is not unprecedented - it's happened at least once before. Usually, NASA has enough advance warning to move the station well out of the way. In this case, however, military debris-trackers alerted NASA on Wednesday night, too late to plan an avoidance maneuver.

Space agency spokesmen said this afternoon that the debris was about 5 inches (12.7 centimeters) in size, which would be larger than the initial estimates of 0.35 inches (9 millimeters). The space junk, said to be from a PAM-D, or payload assist motor, was projected to pass about 4.5 kilometers (2.8 miles) from the station at 12:39 p.m. ET, Jeffs said.

That was close enough to cause concern: Another agency spokesman, Josh Byerly, told me that a collision alert is raised anytime an object is projected to come within an imaginary "pizza box" around the station, measuring 0.75 kilometers above and below the station and 25 kilometers on each side (0.47 miles up and down, by 15.6 by 15.6 miles).

That's why the crew was told to put the station into unmanned mode, get into their Russian-built Soyuz capsule and wait. If the debris had struck the station and breached the hull, the crew might have had to fly the Soyuz back down to Earth and leave the multibillion-dollar orbiting outpost under remote control.

The three crew members - station commander Mike Fincke and flight engineer Sandra Magnus from NASA, as well as Russian cosmonaut Yuri Lonchakov - waited for a tense 10 minutes, looking out the Soyuz windows. "We didn't see anything, of course," Fincke said later. "We were wondering how close we were."

Orbital debris has been a big issue for NASA and the military these days, in part due to last month's collision of a Russian military satellite and an Iridium telecommunications satellite that created hundreds of pieces of junk. The space agency also noted recently that the space-junk factor has raised the estimated risk for an upcoming shuttle mission to service the Hubble Space Telescope - from a 1-in-300 chance of catastrophe to a 1-in-185 chance.

A 5-inch-wide piece of metal might not sound like much, but it can be a big deal when it's traveling 18,000 miles (28,800 kilometers) per hour. Critical parts of the station have been shielded to withstand the impact of objects on the order of a centimeter wide, and ground controllers try to make sure that the station can be moved far away from bigger objects.

Over at Spaceflight Now, Bill Harwood points out that "a 0.4-inch-wide sphere of aluminum moving at orbital speeds packs the same punch as a 400-pound safe moving at 60 mph."

Check out this archived story and this FAQ file from NASA for more about our orbital junkyard and the problems it's causing.

Update for 3:57 p.m. ET: NASA's Josh Byerly told me that the space station's crew has taken refuge in the Soyuz as many as five times before today due to concerns about passing space debris. You can listen to highlights from today's conversation between station crew members and Russian Mission Control by clicking through to this audio clip.

Update for 4:21 p.m. ET: Byerly has corrected the earlier estimate of the object's size. He said in an e-mail that the earlier, smaller number "was actually the radar cross section number, which equates to the larger size." The reference to the size has been revised above.

Update for 10:26 p.m. ET: The Associated Press report about the close call stresses the fact that there's much more junk where today's piece came from. "It's yet another warning shot that we really have to do something about space debris now. We have to do something on an international level," Harvard astrophysicist Jonathan McDowell told AP. Just yesterday, The Wall Street Journal delved into several heavy-duty methods for getting rid of space junk, including nets, magnets, lasers and rocket-powered water guns.

Earlier versions had the time for closest approach slightly wrong, and misstated one of the dimensions for the "pizza box" - which is an occupational hazard when a person has clumsy fingers and is trying to juggle a Twitter feed as well. (Tip o' the Log to Tom Sowa.)

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

WHY NOT SHIFT THE ORBIT OF THE STATION TO A VERY HIGH ORBIT WHERE THERE IS NO JUNK TO TO WORRY ABOUT OR HOW ABOUT CLEANING UP THE MESS/JUNK UP THERE!!!!
shields!
Will the present space station in the near future be an awesome and mystical relic- sort of this generation's  great pyramid for future generations to read about? We may have a civilizational decline like ancient Egypt hopefully followed by only a temporary lull in technological achievements.  
Is there room in the Soyuz capsule for all six when the space station has 6 on board?  Can it bring all six back to earth if the Space Station is damaged?  Is there a chamber handy where one or more could put on space suits and repair minor damage if needed?
Uh, hello!  Why are we leaving so much junk out there anyway?  Haven't we learned anything about littering?  Even my kids know better!
That's some technological marvel we've got that can't withstand a piece of debris that's less than half-an-inch wide....

So when are they installing shields, sci-fi style? Or do they need some space janitor robot satelite thingies to clean up the space junk?

[ALAN ADDS: They've already installed debris shields on the station (but not the cool force field type).]

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/18944495

[Just yesterday I linked to a story that discussed way-out ways to clean up space junk:]

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123672891900989069.html

Thousands more debris parts were generated from the recent collision of two satellites.  Hopi prophecy speaks of a "dwelling place from high in the the heavens [which] will crash to earth. It will appear as a Blue Star...". The Blue Star kachina - let us prey that the astronauts make their escape safely when the time comes.
Well, when it comes to space, it is better to be safe then sorry. Based on the history of a VERY dangerous undertaking(space exploration), safety of the individuals  involved is of paramount importance The right call was made. Good Job.
I wouldn't help but to laugh of our own litter destroyed the space station.  

Give a hoot, don't polute!
I wonder if maybe a Joint Space Mission could be developed to do a litter cleanup in space?  The problem will do nothing else but get significantly worse otherwise.
I think that all of the junk that they are sending into space is expected. (what goes up must come down)!! Shooting satelites down, letting the debris to orbit the earth. One of these days, they'll send up way too many and it will all come down. Ever read about the Battle of Armegedon on earth? Besides, we are living in trying times and the money they use for space research could help stop all the forclosures that are going on.
Wake up NASA look at our skys and see how you are literally destroying other atmospheres as well as our own.
You talk a lot abouta how close it comes in space, how about all the debris that has been getting back to earth.

0.75 meters doesn't equal 0.47 miles--believe you missed a kilo there.

[ALAN ADDS: Thanks to Steve and the scores of other folks who pointed out that I missed typing the "kilo" in there. I think I'll forgo approving all those messages repeatedly pointing out my error. I wish I could say I did that on purpose just to see if you were watching. Sorry about that.]

clean it up!
http://telecomsat.blogspot.com
Exploring The Frontier will be like the Westward Ho The Wagons people found Mickey D's wrappers along with the sage brush and buffalo turds!
It's amazing that so many pieces of space junk , I think they number in the thousands, are in orbit endangering not only the ISS, but our space shuttles and all of the world's satellites as well.  With so much expensive and irreplacable hardware orbiting Earth, why aren't there more preventative measures to eliminate or cut down on space junk?  Not to mention, invaluable human lives are placed at risk simply climbing into a rocket; why subject them to something as ridiculous as space trash as well?  I am glad at least that measures have been taken, like the Soyuz capsule, to protect astronaut's lives.
Could someone please explain how a piece of debris only one-third of an inch wide could damage the space station so severely?  I would think that in order to launch into space the station and it's components must have some pretty tough skin to begin with, doesn't it????
The space station is a multi billion dollar venture?...that kind of capital could do a lot of good here on the ground..hmmm..deep thought when people in such places as Afica and the like are facing disease and starvation.
Wait, you mean the carelessness of mankind has unwanted consequences on his surroundings?  NO WAY!  How unheard of!  Who'd have thought.  Why, here on Earth, we can just toss stuff aside without consequence or concern.  It's a shame the vastness of space cannot offer us the same disregard which we show our tiny little planet.
I wonder if there is a way to retro-fit the space station in the future to decreace the risk of getting shredded by small space junk pieces...  Could we set up a "box" of some sort around the station (with the exception of the solar panels and the outside science lab).  A multi-layered panel could reduce the risk of problems.
frankly ......... I believe it is just a matter of time until something "MAJOR" happens because of all OUT junk obiting. I was once HIT by a 3/4 inch size of gravel behind a truck on a motorcycle. The object hit me in the chest near the right sholder and REMOVED my arm from the handle bar and caused a bruise the size of a SOFTBALL on me.
Not to be pedantic but I think you meant .75 kilometers instead of .75 meters...

cheers,
Keith

BTW thanks for all of the great articles, I read them everyday...
It's all fake people!
Why don't we research ways of cleaning up this "space junk" instead of letting it accumulate as it has done?  It seems to me that this would be just as important if not more important than global warming.
how can they be littering when they know better than anyone about global warming. they should be given a ticket for littering and cause more global warming!!!
I'm amazed that we can track such a tiny piece of debris. I wonder at what relative speed the bullet-sized piece of metal was traveling.
Right now we seem to be bumping-along on the Big-Sky-Little-Bullet theory, but it seems that eventually, someone will have to collect or redirect all that junk
Can't they devise some way of cleaning up some of that junk? Say, go up there with some high powered magnets attached to a bunch of maneuverable satellites? It seems kind of ridiculous that we're going to junk up space to the point where we'll eventually be grounded because of it.
When is someone going to start a new business:   garbage collector in space?  
I am an experianced military man and Disabled Veteran now.  I have seen Russian technology.  Although they have fundamentaly and theroretically great equipment such as the AK47, they usually have shotty work that leaves more to be desired.  Their Mig 21's and the such must roll carefully or they flat spin out of the sky, while our US jets roll at the pilots will and demand.  

I wish the US could develope an escape pod for the space station, that I would personally feel more comfortable with.  Now in this time offinacial difficulty it can wait, but once we recover that should become a NASA priority rather than a trip to Mars.
I wonder if there ever will be a point when we will have to go up for a mission to start cleaning up any of this space junk that can be retrieved.
On one hand it is pretty amazing they are able to track a piece of debris les than 3/8" wide but on the othre hand it shows you how fragile the space station is to be threatened by something so small.
Why not use the space based laser to get ridd of the space junk.  I know we have something of this type?.
How dod they know such a small piece was on a collision path? Can they detect a piece less than a half inch from earth or do they monitor from sapce?

Also, How fast was the debris travelling?

DeeMan
mmmm, pizza, arggggg
I still can't believe it.  NASA is doing absolutly nothing to reduce and or remove "Sapce Debris" that has beed acumulating since the late 1950's.  You idiots just don't get it.  Pack it in, Pack it out!!!
Are we to wait until NASA kills more people?
NASA had better put money into learning how to capture space debris and do so fast.
It's insane not to do so if going into space it to exist, this should show the world that NASA is worthless and we should of seen it when the moon landings we saw the juck they scattered on the moon, what slobs
Alan - the "real" news here is that the Pentagon is obviously able to track objects profoundly small -- 0.35" -- at the altitudes of the ISS.  We know they can track basketball-sized debris and objects, but a third of an inch, with accurate orbital characteristics??  Wow.
maximum power to the shields Mr Sulu
Multitasking: Screwing up several things at once.
I don't know how serious this post is, but I thought I share it anyway: http://cjcs.com/tib/2853/the-snot-approach-to-clearing-space-debris/
I know I'm kind of stupid when it comes to these things but why not send up powerful magnet satellites that can maneuver a bit to snare some of this crap up there? Is it possible?
Not only are we "junking" our planet but we are extending our sloppy ways into space. What must other life forms think of us...There goes the neighborhood!!!
Kick ass!!  We trash space just like we trashed earth!!
Space junk was bound to happen eventually.  We must treat space as delicately as we treat our earth, better in fact since we do not know what the impact of too much debris in space upon the surface of the earth will be in the future.  All nations must jointly cooperate in designing a space craft to destroy or retrieve space junk and clean up space, we will have to face it one day and better sooner than too late.
If would be nice if all that space junk and debris be collected and hauled off into the sun...
Where's WallE whaen we need him?
NASA is really hyping up this whole collision possability issue big time... likely to try and increase funding to NASA.  The chance of a collision is so rare that of the hundreds of satalights and thousands of pieces af degree they have only had one collision.  Think of the planes colliding on a typical day in the World, but that the planes are the size of a penney. Even in dense flying locations the chance of a collision are likely less than winning the Lottery.  The were worried about an odject the size of a dime comming within 114 cubic mile area.  Likely the crew was in space suits and all the segments of the space station where closed off.  Likely a hit would cause a small hole releasing air in one area and require a crewmember to repair it with a space walk.  The chance of a catastrophic fairure of the space station from a hit that small is negligable at best.  NASA needs to stop begging for money and cancel all wasteful adventures like a return moon mission or any other missions beyond Earth's orbit.
Just a week or so ago, the world learns it was skirted by a near hit of an asteroid just a scant 3 days before it passes harmlessly without incident.  Only 3 days?  Then the ISS learns it may be on collision course with space junk with even less time.  One can only conclude that space is in fact a very hostile jungle full of very dangerous unknowns.  

While I am and have been a huge advocate of humans in space exploration, it comes with perils.  All to often that message isn't clear and becomes imperative that the hundreds of billions of dollars spent in space travel (not just US dollars) be recognized for what it is.  Exploration.  Were a calamity to occur in space or on earth, we must continue on in the spirit of future endeavors in our solar system and beyond.  To loose that pionering spirit and adventure is to become lost without understanding, ideas and creativity.

And.. BTW  A near miss would be a collision.  Think about it!
NASA been waste of money to send space and left for more than 30 year old space like Saturn V for stay long time and we wonder how abused space as beat in future if happen full junkyard of space in earth obit will chnace hit new brand space and we demand clean up of machine space to bring it to down for muserm or push to sun to melt space if has hazardous like checimal or etc also  new space law  banned for 30 or more year old need down or go to sun if needed
not very convincing. seriously.
"Space Junk"...or UFO? Come on people, the truth is out there!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1833933

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google