ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



The race to find alien Earths

Posted: Tuesday, February 17, 2009 5:30 PM by Alan Boyle


ESA
An artist's conception shows a planet crossing the disk of an alien star. Planet-
hunting satellites watch for the dimming of starlight caused by such crossings.

NASA is gearing up for a space race that's expected to point to the first truly Earthlike worlds beyond our solar system - and, like the race to put the first human on the moon, this marathon will take several years to run.

The roots of the race go back more than a decade, as astrophysicist Alan Boss explains in his new book, "The Crowded Universe: The Search for Living Planets." That's when pioneers in the planet-hunting field started detecting worlds around suns beyond our own.

The techniques used back then couldn't find other Earths in planetary systems like our own. The first method, pioneered by Polish astronomer Alexander Wolszczan at the Arecibo Observatory in 1991, could detect Earth-scale planets (and perhaps even the first known extrasolar dwarf planet) around radio pulsars - but those planets were thought to be burned-out cinders and not Earthlike at all.

In 1995, astronomers began reporting the detection of Jupiter-scale planets around normal stars, by precisely measuring the gravitational wobble those planets induce in the stars themselves. (Our interactive tutorial explains how it's done.) As the years have gone by, planet-hunters have gotten smarter about using that "Doppler wobble" technique, and they've also trained sensitive telescopes on faraway stars to measure the slight dimming in their light as alien planets make their transits over the stars' disks.

This transit method takes center stage in the next phase of the planet-hunting space race: The European Space Agency's Corot satellite, which was launched a little more than two years ago, has a head start. Just this month, members of the Corot science team announced the discovery of a "hot super-Earth" that is less than twice Earth's size.

Next month, NASA picks up the pace with the launch of its Kepler satellite, equipped with a planet-seeking telescope that has some advantages over Corot. Astronomers expect Kepler to turn up some true Earthlike planets, in Earthlike orbits, around sunlike stars.


NASA
Astronomer Alan Boss is author of "The Crowded
Universe: The Search for Living Planets."

"If Kepler comes up empty-handed - boy, it'll turn out to be virtual harakiri," Boss, a member of the Kepler science team, told me earlier this month. "But there's little chance of that."

The first fruits of the $550 million Kepler mission won't be the coolest alien Earths, Boss cautioned. "Often the oddballs are the earliest ones to find, for some reason," he said. Boss expects the Kepler team to announce the mission's first discoveries of hot Jupiters and hot super-Earths within a month after science operations begin.

The biggest factor behind that schedule has to do with the time scale of a planet's orbit. It takes at least three orbits for astronomers to confirm that the dimming of the star is really caused by a planet rather than, say, the brightness cycles of a variable star or a binary-star system. If the planet is extremely close to its star - which would be an oddball orbit by solar system standards - that won't take long. For example, the hot super-Earth identified by Corot completes an orbit in just 20 hours.

Farther-out planets will require more time to orbit, and therefore more time to detect.

"The earth, by definition, will take at least three years to get," Boss said. "Roughly four years from now, we will be beginning to make our claims for Earthlike planets around solar-type stars."

Boss' book traces the buildup to the Kepler mission through a series of time-stamped entries, reading almost like a diary. It's often been said that politics can get as messy as sausage-making - and based on Boss' accounts of Kepler's budgetary travails, the same can be said for pre-launch mission planning.

Along the way, Boss also delves into the deep scientific issues of the planet search:

  • Are new planets built from the core up, like dirty snowballs, or do they whirl into shape like stars are thought to do? (Boss says both processes come into play.)

  • How do you define stars, brown dwarfs, sub-brown dwarfs, planets and dwarf planets? (Boss was involved in many of those discussions, including the IAU's efforts to define planethood.)

  • What will it mean if (or when) Kepler finds those alien Earths? (Boss says finding out how many such planets exist among the more than 100,000 star systems that Kepler is expected to survey will reveal "the most basic parameter in any estimate of the prevalence of life in the universe.")

Kepler's primary mission is due to last three and a half years, but Boss hopes that the spacecraft will be up for some extra laps around the racetrack. Which mission will be the first to reveal just how common alien Earths are? Corot or Kepler? Considering that Boss is on Kepler's team, he's not the best person to handicap this race objectively. But in the end, it doesn't really matter who reaches the finish line first.

"Either way," he writes, "after centuries - if not millennia - of speculation and wondering, we will finally know just how crowded the universe really is."


For another perspective on "The Crowded Universe," check out Jeff Foust's book review in The Space Review.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I've been following this exploration process like an expectant father.  As an engineer, educated during our first landings on the Moon, all I can think of is when (not what)we could be sharing our lives with an extrasolar life form.  I hope I live long enough to know.
"How do you define stars, brown dwarfs, sub-brown dwarfs, planets and dwarf planets?"

The Meghar Scale of Planetary Mass Classification :

http://groups.google.com/group/sci.astro.amateur/msg/

Classification Mass Range   Mass Unit

Dwarf Stars     100 - 1000   Jupiter mass
Brown Dwarfs     10 - 100    Jupiter mass
Super Giants      1 - 10     Jupiter mass

Mass Sun = 332,946 Earths
Mass Jupiter = 318 Earths

Giant (Super)   500 - 5000   Earth mass (Super Giants) Jupiter (Giant)  50 - 500    Earth mass (Giant Planet)
Neptune (Gas)  5 - 50     Earth mass (Gas Giants)
Earth        0.5 - 5       Earth mass (Earthlike)
Mars           0.05 - 0.5     Earth mass (Mars class)
Lunar*      0.005 - 0.05    Earth mass (Moon class)
Pluto        0.0005 - 0.005   Earth mass (Plutoids)
Ceres*      0.00005 - 0.0005  Earth mass (Asteroids)
Enceladus* 0.000005 - 0.00005 Earth mass (Ice Moons)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Graph_showing_relative_masses_2.png

* - Added by the author.
Three or more years?  So the chances of us finding an alien civilization willing to buy mortgage backed securities in time to stave off financial disaster is pretty slim I take it.
Any thinking person must necessarily realize that we are in the pioneering phases of such efforts and that it is only in the last 20 years that technology has progressed far enough to begin planet finding endeavors.
This should be, no matter what becomes it, only the first of many efforts to find not only earth like planets but life elsewhere in the cosmos.
I hope too, to live long enough to find definitive answers to such interesting questions.
Ask the American Indians how much fun it is to greet explorers from distant lands!!!
It's not a question of life elsewhere...it's a question of a simple model of physics.  Do we, or do we not, understand the fundamental nature of the Universe. I suspect the answer is not.
These are very much amazing times. We are so close to getting that answer to "Are we alone?" that it really just makes me tingle. Once this step of finding earth like planets out there starts to come up with the first, I believe/hope the push in technology to be able to peer into it much closer will be very close behind. Once we do that, even if the answer is negative for that one, we can just keep going on to the 100/1000/millions that will come after very quickly since we will know where/how to look from then on.
Truly amazing.
Since I was a youngster, I loved reading the Isaac Asimov books about distant planets and other life forms.  I loved his "I Robot" short stories.  My brothers and I grew up in the Star Trek age and hardly ever missed an episode.  It became a part of who we were. I hope Obama will support these kinds of projects as they could produce Earth changing ideas and provide a hope that we have not experienced before.  Talk about "Change"!  After all, gazing at the stars and dreaming about what may be out there has a way of minimizing the trials and tribulations on this planet and make us all feel a little less significant.  I think we will find life on these other planets in a distant solar system some day.  I only wish Isaac could have been here to see it.
Call me crazy, but unless we find another habitable planets to colonize, homo sapiens may go extinct. Think 300 - 400 years in the future. Can earth really support >10 billion humans? Earth is already stretched thin and we haven't hit 10 billion mark.
I firmly believe that the time man has left on earth as we know it will prevent us from ever finding all of the things we would wish to know. Our universe is so very vast it's hard to comprehend. My question is this, Is the universe we know the only one? We know of other galexies in this universe but would it not be possible that there are others?
are we the only species in the universe? maybe there is something else out there. coz the universe is too big for us. we can't be the only species. maybe there is other worlds or other planets or earths in outer space.
I thought it's already been discovered just how rare a planet like ours is in the universe with all the prerequisite conditions nessesary for a planet to support life.  The chances of another planet like ours in our universe is too miniscule for any projects like this to be anything but a waste of time and taxpayers money. www.privilegedplanet.com
Well, I am not certain it needs to be a race.  Considering how long it took us to get here on Earth, it is hard to say what the life form status will be on the ideal Earthlike planet.  On the other hand, they (the ETs) may already know about us and will do their utmost to hide.
My son is going to college and pursuing his aeronautical engineering degree with hopes of working for NASA and exploring the cosmos.
I beleive when we do make contact with intelligent alien forms, they will look vastly different to us and in particular their chemical make-up.
Dear Chicago,

You better hope they get to Mars, and the moons of the outer planets first in your lifetime, because we
are alone, because, Earths are rare!!
I think the inherent risks, to our continued existence, of actually finding alien life forms far outweigh the benefits. We've got enough problems with disease and wars right here on earth without importing new ones, from some totally unknown life forms, from another part of the universe.
It is so obvious that WE are the Aliens on this planet.  Nostalgic and wanting to go Home!

I hope when we do lift off and land eventually;  we don't do the same to that planet and it's jungles and creatures.

Maybe, if lucky we will find an atmosphere that likes to dissolve Junk.
3-4 years seems like a long time to wait, but i believe the pay-off will be worth the wait. what an historic discovery that will be- another living planet around another star. after that, it'll be a race to see how many more can be detected. hopefully a means to contact that/those world(s) will be devised as well. from there, we just need for technology to advance to ftl travel. i know that's a long ways off,but feasible, we can do it.
This is very exciting stuff.  But it also seems to me that the transit method of planet detection needs to rely on the planet's orbit being in the correct plain in order to transit it's star from our angle of view.  If this is true, then we can only detect a small percent of the planets that are really out there.  Can anyone tell me if I'm right about this?
For the most part the current search processes require that earth lie close to the orbital plane of the distant star system.  If we are outside the orbital plane then the transit approach will not work as the planet will not pass in front of the star.  It would seem that the further we are off the orbital plane the less the wobble effect would be seen.

So if one were to assume that the relationship of Earth to distant orbital systems is evenly distributed, then what we have found so far implies an incredible number of solar systems exist that are undetectable by the current methods that assume the favorable relationship of Earth to the orbital plane.

Just an observation on my part.  
This is a very exciting time to be living.  All the knowledge we are gleaning about our own world and the possibility of similar worlds orbiting distant stars is fascinating.  It is almost like reading science fiction in the present tense.

I know I will never live to see us set foot on one of those alien worlds or make contact with sentient life outside our own solar system, but perhaps our grandchildren will.

The exploration of the universe puts everything else into perspective.

I wonder how the discovery of alien earths and possible alien life forms will affect the earth's major religions?

I'm reminded of the ancient Chinese curse, "May you live in interesting times."

The times ahead are certainly going to be "interesting."
I believe we may find earth like planets. But we may be a little disappointed when they are not any different than us. They learned to discover God. and  his plan. Why wouold one think that we are not advanced as well. Ever thought how a creature that appears to be skinny and without muscle could travel the universe and defy the law of physics. When the Lord returns- many answers will be answered. Do not be surpirsed that  the answers are really very logical.
Great article Alan!  I can't wait to see what the new Kepler satellite will find in the way of planets, especially potential earthlike planets.  I'm also chafing at the bit to see the next shuttle launch to the ISS and the Hubble servicing mission.  A good time to watch the NASA channel.

Go NASA!
It is interesting to think of what the discovery of our solar system would "feel" like from the point of view of another alien civilization. There is no reason to believe that another civilization would have developed science in general and astronomy in particular in the same way we did. However if they did, our Solar system would be an interesting case study.
The fact that our sun is a very stable and isolated star, and therefore more suitable for life harboring planets, would have made it a good candidate for observations even before the technology existed (say, in the 1980's of our time). The first radial velocity studies would be likely to detect the wobble due to Jupiter's orbit, but with a period of about 10 years it would take very long to confirm. Even then, they would notice that there seems to be another wobble in the orbit with a greater period, and postulate that this system has two giant planets, which we know as Jupiter and Saturn.
Now if they are lucky enough to have their line of sight aligned with the plane of the solar system they may see the transit of the inner planets and publish a big headline that this average sized stable yellow star seems to have at least one rocky planet at a distance from the star where water is a liquid. They may also detect the spectral signal of oxygen during a transit where the sun's light shines through Earth's atmosphere. Then they may say, "Hmm, didn't one of our biologists hypothesize that in a watery environment an alien life form could produce oxygen as a metabolic bi-product?"

Also, what are all those really weak radio waves coming from very close to the star? Could they be coming from one of the rocky planets?
As exciting as that would be, I don't think humanity is ready for such an encounter.  We cant even understand the differences in our own cultures and languages, how can we possibly come to understand alien life and accept it and all the implications it will have for us?
Space exploration will take off (ha!  pun intended) when it becomes commercially viable (e.g. mining).  I hope to live to see the beginnings of our permanent and/or semi-permanent outposts and mining operations...the moon is definitely doable and we could start there without having to worry about a 9-month trip home (like Mars) in the case of an emergency.  The moon is but a few days away...
I agree with the question of when will we be in contact with other life forms. I believe that we have already been visited, but have probably been deemed to be too primative, violent, and unstable to approach. I also hope that I live long enough to see our species make first contact with another sentient life form.
I hope all this effort isn't wasted on a bacteria growing on the far site of some moon.
Man's only hope of survival, as we destroy this earth, lies in the hope of discoving exactly what these individuals dedicate their lives to finding. let us hope that by time we find it we have invested in our ability to reach it before it is too late, and let us hope that we mature enough as a species to no longer be as destructive and selfish and ignorant as we are today. The majority of our world is so primative in it's thinking that we still argue and kill each other over the most childish issues. When will mankind put aside it's ego and realize how small we are in the scheme of things and learn to cherish what we have? Let us hope our children's children have a hope left by time they are born. It may well lie in the hands of these researchers and scientists that give their lives to the most noble of causes. Bravo !!! I wish to be counted as one human that recognizes your efforts and would support your endeavours above all short of immediate humanitarian issues. I caution, however; if the human race doesn't evolve substantially in it's thinking and behaviour, your efforts may be nothing but the beginnings of the destruction of another miracle.
I too am excited.  I'm waiting to see when this will happen.  Under the new administration, I hope this is sooner and in my lifetime.
It will be interesting to see how the public reacts to finding one or more Earth like planets.

What if life is strongly suggested by the data, how will that affect public interest.

This is the kind of stuff that will inspire human interest and push us out to the stars!
I'm thirty now, and I've worried about that for 20 years.  In my mind there is no question that we will confirm alien life soon, but will I be alive to see it.  I don't pray, but if I did...I would pray to be around when that discovery is made.  With the space spirit picking up in the western populace through commercial space ventures, our knowledge of the universe is set to accelerate exponentially, so my fingers are crossed.
If we find Earth-like exoplanets and spectroscopic analysis indicates nitrogen-oxygen-water vapor atmospheres (the signature of a living world as we know it), what do we do then?

Someone had better be working on some kind of exotic, revolutionary propulsion systems if we ever hope to actually visit, study, and colonize those worlds.
Too bad, they have already found you! Your disease, pollution, and destructive ways will always be kept in one place. You will find out in 2012.
OK so NASA's budget is like 18 billion dollars, it seems to me like that is an incredibly SMALL amount of money compared to what we spend on other programs that will be much less useful in the future. Lets spend some of that stimulus money on space exploration. A space elevator would be a good way to boost jobs, or how about the government SERIOUSLY attempting to encourage the private development of cheaper launch vehicles. We have the ability to start doing all of this but our shortsighted government ignores it. I think it was Sir Clark (or was it Asimov) who said that the human race would be in danger as long as all of our eggs where in the same basket. Well the baskets looking kinda worn out, maybe be should be looking for a new one........
keep on hoping because there is nothing out there but dust
Great stuff Alan. Please keep us all informed. :-)
though 15 i have a very strong view on the existence of intelligent life so it will be exciting to know just how alone we are.
Kirk,

You are right about the fact that transits are very rare due to the special geometry needed for us to observe a system as a transiting system. As an added rarety consider the fact that a planet will transit for only a tiny fraction of the total time it takes to complete one orbit and we must observe it at that time to see the transit.
The Kepler mission is beautiful in its simplicity in the sense that it will observe a wide patch of sky for a very long time. Sort of like watching flowers grown in a huge garden. Every now and then a petal might snap open, but for the most time it is just staring into space. this can only be done from Earth orbit, as the natural day/night cycle here on Earth would mean that we would only be able to observe for on average half the time.
Serge
dieterich@chara.gsu.edu
I say that we use that money they will be spending on this project to help ourselves out of our current situations around the globe.  Since there is no way for even generations after us to explore these worlds first hand we could do more to help our own world from destruction. Rock on 2012!
Planet Earth was a failed experiment, spoiled by the obnoxious, self serving greed of man.  We will be viewed by intelligent extraterrestial life as something to be avoided, much like a poisonous snake.  With all the beliveable UFO sightings it seems apparent they know quite well we are here but damn sure want nothing to do with us.  Who could blame them?  Put us out of our misery as we have ruined this planet.  But no, they will apparently permit us to do ourselves in.  Fitting.
The Universe is a rich stew of galaxies and planets. Life probably exisits on millions of worlds but not necessarily in the forms that we are used to (carbon based) Silicon based, nitorgen based, machine based, the possibilities are endless. Single celled to intelligences so far evolved beyond ours that they no lonnger require a physical body. The unverse is vastly more complex than we can ever hope to understand. We are children trying to understand something more complex than all of the science that we have been able to postulate, theorize, and  describe to date. IF we don't end up destroying ourselves and our fragile planet we will eventually find out that we are one of many. Stay tuned.
What gives us the right to claim these planets for ourselves if there is intelligent life on these planets? I mean seriously! Leave them alone or make peace. What is it with our obsession and need to attempt to conquer everything we see?
Only the small minded or those constricted by narrow religious beliefs can deny that it is mathematically impossible for there NOT to be life on other "earth-like" planets.  
I look forward to the day when these new next generation space vehicles will not only detect other "earths" but be able to capture details like illuminted urban centers, traffic systems and orbiting artificial satellites.  
I can only hope that such a discovery will help mankind realize that we need to stop our petty bickering and childish arguments over religion and territorial issues and raise our awarness that we are only a small part of a greater community that spans many solar systems and light years.
I love how people pull the old 2012 chesnut out of the fire whenever an intelligent positive discussion about other worlds and potential life forms comes up.

For folks who don't know what that is all about... the Mayan calendar (which has been hideously accurate for thousands of years) is due to run out late in 2012. Many people believe that it hearlds the end of the world. Not likely.

Let me say this plainly. When your 2008 calendar ran out on Dec 31st did the world end? Nope. It reset to count off the next peroid of time. The Mayan calendar will do the exact same thing... it resets 22,000 (approx) years and starts its long count down all over again.

As for alien life and contact... don't expect to met any other lif forms until we get off this planet. And I don't mean a trip to the moon. Once me have established colonies on some of the other planets in our solar system, its a clear sign that we have advanced beyond the confines of our own planet.

Until that time the only folks meeting aliens are the "abductees" who may or may not be meeting aliens.
It would be nice to know for an "fact" that there is other species beyond this 3rd rock from the sun living and breathing just as well as us humans. I hope the research of scientist pushes us closer to reality than fiction.
I do not think we are alone in this universe. One of my favorite writers wrote, and I paraphrase, "In a situation of infinity, all worlds that are possible must exist - not just once, but an infinite number of times." To think we are unique in the universe seems like the ultimate form of hubris.
3-4 years?? I better get packing!
"I thought it's already been discovered just how rare a planet like ours is in the universe..."

The only way to be sure, is to look. One good solid observation is worth a thousand arguments, however well reasoned. (And, of course, you may turn out to be right. But still, we'll all be more certain.)



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1799004

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google