ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



Mars hoax lasts five years

Posted: Tuesday, August 26, 2008 5:40 PM by Alan Boyle


Alachua Astronomy Club
E-mail messages perpetuate the
annual August myth that Mars can
look as big as the full moon.

Does anyone still believe that Mars will look as big as the moon this week? Every year, some folks find a forwarded message in their in-box claiming that on Aug. 27, Mars will be as close as it will ever get until the year 2287. That's totally false, and if you were to go outside expecting a monster Mars tonight, you'd be gravely disappointed. But the funny thing is that there's a germ of truth to the "Great Mars Hoax" - and that it's still worth checking out the night sky.

The viral e-mail got its start in August 2003, when Mars really did have its closest encounter with Earth in human history. The planet was a mere 34.6 million miles away - and the next time it's due to come that close will be on Aug. 29, 2287.

Mars mania ruled during the summer of 2003, but even then, the planet's disk wasn't as big as the moon's disk. That part of the e-mail was a garbled version of the true claim that Mars, when seen through a telescope, would look as big as the full moon does to the naked eye.

The e-mail about August's "Mars Spectacular" has made the rounds every summer since then. I wrote about the return of the Great Mars Hoax two years ago, and if you look at the comments appended to the item, you'll see that the virus is still active.

Fortunately, space-savvy debunkers are still active as well: Jane Houston Jones, an outreach specialist at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory, has updated her page explaining the Mars e-mail hoax, and you'll find additional reality checks at Snopes.com and the Alachua Astronomy Club's Web site.

The fact is that this is an off year for looking at Mars: Because it takes the Red Planet twice as long as Earth to orbit the sun, close encounters occur every other year. Last year was a good opportunity to see Mars (though not as good as 2003). This year, however, Mars is on the far side of the sun - and is visible only for a short time after sunset.

That doesn't mean it's not worth looking: For the past couple of weeks, Mars has been part of a planetary foursome in sunset skies. If you're incredibly lucky, you can spot three planets - Mercury, Venus and Saturn - just after the sun drops below the horizon, with Mars a little bit above the tight trio. (This sky map provides a guide.)

The star of the show is much higher in the sky: As Houston Jones notes in this month's "What's Up" video podcast, Jupiter and its moons are taking center stage. It's hard to miss Jupiter if you look up into a clear sky after sunset.

If you're more of a morning person, you can catch another "star" before sunrise: Most North American observers will have multiple opportunities this week to see the international space station flying overhead in the predawn hours. Check out NASA's satellite sighting page for times and locations.

Early risers can also enjoy a thin crescent moon in eastern skies on Thursday morning, according to Sky & Telescope's weekly roundup of sky highlights.

Do you still have your heart set on a monster Mars? For now, the closest views of the Red Planet are available via Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter ... or Phoenix Mars Lander ... or the Mars rovers ... or Europe's Mars Express ... or the Hubble Space Telescope.

Mars' next close encounter with Earth won't occur until Jan. 27, 2010. Will the Great Mars Hoax be really, most sincerely dead by then? Stay tuned.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

My sister sent me this one again and I sent back to her that not only was it not true, but she better hope Mars never gets that close to Earth!
The email actually says that Mars will look as big as the moon when viewed with _____ magnification.  (I forget the amount of magnification.)  The problem people have is that the sentence is broken by the pictures, so the part in front of the pictures ends with saying that Mars will be as big as the moon.
The sky is pretty clear here...North Shore of Boston...but no giant Mars...PHOOEY!
I wanna be an early Hominid looking up at this exact same thing.
I can feel the sense of depth, movement and harmony between the planets.
Thoughts of how far away they are never crosses my mind.
In my basic Noggin, there is no such thing as that far away.
They are right there in front of me.
I have figgered out that up isn't in my repertoire.
There is no reason to question what I cannot effect.
Although...it is easier getting around and avoiding pitfalls at night when the brighter, whiter one is round instead of a curved sliver.
And the salty waterhole near the shoreline gets much bigger when the bright one is full...and also, when it goes away completely.
HMMMM!!!
How's that for a thought?
for more click my name
A few years ago WABC-TV morning news in New York broadcast the hoax as if it was a fact.
The whole statement about apparent size is meaningless. With the proper magnification Mars will look "as big as the moon" at any time of any year. Likewise, with the proper magnification an ant will look as big as an elephant. So what?
I have tried this, and if you look at the moon through field glasses backwards, it IS the same size as mars. So there.
In the email I received, there were no pictures, so none of the 'sentences [were] broken', as I read it.
What does surprise me is how many people actually believe it.  

I'm sorry but did you say "Mars mania ruled during the summer of 2003"?  It did?  Where?  With who?  In some university dep't in the science section of the times?  Mars mania?  What are you talking about man?

[ALAN ADDS: How soon they forget...  ;-)

[Here are some samples:]

http://www.astro.umd.edu/openhouse/news/2003-08-27.html

http://www.usatoday.com/news/science/2003-07-13-mars-usat_x.htm

http://www.today.ucla.edu/2003/030923news_mars.html

http://www.astrohbg.org/gallery2/mars_2003

 

The fact that people believe this myth just goes to prove that P.T. Barnum was right..."There's a sucker born every minute."
I think Mars will circumvent the "big as the moon" theory radically. It true that it's proximity will be obfuscated, but only laterally for sunset viewers. It's twice as likely to be half as big. the proof is in the pudding, bub!
Funny how we pride ourselves on or brain capacity, yet are such sloppy thinkers!
My mother sent me that email a while back- I remeber thinking, "wow, the media hasn't reported at all that the world is about to end due to the effect Mars's gravity would have on the Earth and the rest of the solar system."

I wonder if surfers around the world flew to the greatest surfing destinations to ride the super waves that would likely be caused by this event...
I've heard this from friends the last couple days.  I was a little surprised that anyone could believe the idea that another planet would be as large in the sky as the Moon.  Nice to hear what the genesis of this misunderstanding is.
Js said "It's twice as likely to be half as big".
So does that mean it's AS likely to be AS big?  Sorry, couldn't resist
Yeah like I believe anything sent to me by somebody I don't know! Get real! I don't care what the subject matter, anything sent to you by a total stranger is a lie and could be even worse than just that.
On a different subject, why is it that we have never been shown a magnified picture of the Sea of Tranquility and the places where the boys landed on the moon back in '69? Surly there is good enough magnification available to see this.....strange!
One day the Moon and Mars may look the same size; a long time from now when the Moon is far enough away, seeing how it is getting farther.
I was had.  I stayed up for nothing.
I once told my wife that a man who came on stage to take a bow after a presentation of La Boheme was Puccini.  She said, "really?"  I'll try this one out on her tonight...
My faith in humanities intelligence has been partially restored thru the comments this has generated. Mars is right where it's supposed to be, objects in mirror are closer than they appear.
pv
I love when people throw the sucker phrase out as if their own mental capacities are superior. Actually, Barnum never said that. It was most likely uttered by a man named David Hannum, who was referring to Barnum's customers, then later attributed to Barnum by one of his rivals.

But if Barnum ever found an opportunity to make people think Mars looked bigger, I'm sure he'd jump at the chance.
And if you wear 3D glasses when it gets that close, it looks like all those little Mars orbiters are coming right at you when they come around from the back side of the planet.  You can almost reach out and touch them.
I HEARD ABOUT THIS ON THE RADIO AND GOT ALL EXCITED ABOUT SEEING IT. lol Glad to know that I am not the only one thats feels a little stupid right now.
This is really funny because every year I get this in my emailaand of course I know it's not true. I live in Southern Illinois and last year A little town named Vienna put out a 4 page color spread about this event in their news paper The Vienna Times. I couldn't believe it.
If you play Mars backwards on a record player, you can hear "...The walrus was Paul...".
 Sadly, folks will hit the send button before checking out any e-mail chain-letter they receive in their inbox. I routinely get e-mails from people who should know better about all sorts of hoaxes, scams, etc. I've gotten this e-mail at leat 3 or 4 times from various people.  

 A quick trip to Snopes usually sorts it all out. I then e-mail the link back to the sender and all the names in the CC and BCC.....
Way back in my college years (when dinosaurs roamed freely about the earth), I was trying to decide on a major.  The choices were genetics, geology, or astronomy.  Unfortunately, I chose biology because I thought it would be easier, and it was.  If there's anyone in that position, all I ask is that you don't take the easy way out and to challenge yourself
"and if you look at the comments appended to the item, you'll see that the virus is still active."

Does that mean that everyone who read it now has a VIRUS on their machine?????
Thankfully I have yet to see this hoax surface this year (and all the copies I've seen of it in the past via email, myspace, etc did not say anything about magnification, they all just said 'to the naked eye'), but last summer a friend of mine posted a bulletin saying the usual baloney saying Mars will be as big as the moon is to the naked eye. That doesn't even make sense, Mars is HUGE compared to our moon, obviously. I told that friend last summer that if she even looked up into the sky and Mars was as big as our moon is to the naked eye then it was probably a sign the apocalypse was upon us.
If you haven't tried it, a dime held at arms length will completely cover the full moon. Good way to prove that it's not actually bigger on the horizon.
"My mother sent me that email a while back- I remeber thinking, "wow, the media hasn't reported at all that the world is about to end due to the effect Mars's gravity would have on the Earth and the rest of the solar system."

  Matt, that's the logic I keep trying to tell all those I know who send me *any* viral e-mails. No matter what it claims, the first thing you should ask is, "Whu haven't I heard about this anywhere else?"

  That is, anywhere other than an e-mail of unknown origin (yes, it came form soemone you know, but they only got it from someone they know, etc...) rather than a news organization or somplace/someboty that can be held accountable.

  The answer, 99% of the time will be; "Because it's not true."

  Be espically wary of the political ones, espically the ones you're already inclined to believe. (That is, the ones bashing a politician/candidate you *already* don't like. It still doesn't make the bashing a fact.)
Well.. I can understand that it's a hoax, but not why you found a need to write about it..
Don't forget the optical illusion that causes a full moon to look much larger when near the horizon than it does when overhead!
Someone distorted a simple statement. everyone wants to act like it's a Big deal. It's not. Plain and simple. Get over it.
so typical.The American public is so scientifically
incapacitated it is amzing most even have a clue that Mars is a planet. I teach advanced science courses and am appalled at the lack of general knowledge of science by college students  much less the less educated masses.
If Mars get that close again, let's get our rockets ready--  it's time to colonize another planet while we have that chance!
I feel really confused b/c last year in August I heard about this around the same time as a lunar eclipse. I woke up at 3am to check it out and it looked like there were two orange moons. Does anyone know what I might have seen (other than the most vivid dream of my life)??
What good is education when people abandon common sense? If common sense was gravity a lot of people would fly right off of the planet. The simplicity of ignorance may be bliss but it seems an awful waste. Enjoy the miracles of creation and do try to stay out of the way, or at least fight the urge to raise your hand when someone is looking for an answer that makes sense.
Was reading this late today,not only it will ever get as big as the moon,it will never be another safe haven for human.God never meant it to be.Hats off to those people who reserved their seats to the moon or is there also a someone who just bought a plot too??!! Hoax news,makes NEWS...good reading though,i must admit.
"The proof of the pudding is in the eating." It bugs me when people say "The proof is in the pudding."
Quoting: ..  A few years ago WABC-TV morning news in New York broadcast the hoax as if it was a fact.
j (Sent Wednesday, August 27, 2008 7:41 AM).......


                 That is by far the most hilarious thing I've seen yet for postings/comments. For real? How diligent of their news team. Wow... I almost forgot why I quit watching most newscasts... Thanks for the reminder, j. LoL
ps: I do however, recall the line reading something about magnified viewing and the comparative size when viewed in such a way. But alas, it was not in-your-face clear about the instructed/advised form of viewing in regards to the would-be percieved size of Mars.
How can these people get suckered on these things?  Whoever "desinged" this stupid hoax, which I had to tell my co-workers if they had every seen that in the sky, and of course no one on Earth ever saw it either.  It irritates me to the core.
"Space-savvy debunkers" - are these the same people that claimed the universe was "contracting" about 30 years ago when they forgot E=MC2?
Have any of you ever heard of Snopes.com?  Anytime someone sends me something that sounds dubious or too good to be true, I check it out there before I believe it (if I care one way or the other).  I've never had such an issue or claim NOT covered by Snopes.  If everyone would do so, we could cut way down on needless and misleading "news".
"the proof is in the pudding, bub!"

Sorry, but the proof of the pudding is in the eating.
I got it sent to me by a friend..and passed it on..I just sent all those people a note saying... it was a hoax..but it did crack me up....just think tonightI would have been sitting outside with my coffee in hand waiting to see this..lol...I did think it pretty odd that they said it would be 34.5 miles away from earth..but didnt stop to think ..yikes...still cracks me up....good thing it is a hoax!
I agree that we should spread the word about the existence of Snopes - and encourage folks to use it. But please, if you are going to send the link that exposes something as a hoax, send it only to the person you got it from. Spare all the people in the cc and bcc boxes - most of us have checked it out already if we cared enough in the first place. You mean well, but we end up with dozens more emails telling us that it isn't true...and we know that. It's almost as frustrating as getting all the junk emails in the first place.
I got the email. Oh well. I guess I won't stay up late tonight. I didn't think it would be that large anyways. Oh well. Did you know that there is an asteroid headed right for earth, traveling at 24.000 MPH? The good news is, it won't hit us for 2000 years.
An update for Alan Boye:
Yet another satellite is orbiting Mars collecting science right now. Mars Odyssey is the oldest operational orbiter of the 3 (Mars Express and MRO). One f its biggest jobs is relaying science to Earth from the other 3 landers Spirit, Opportunity, and Phoenix. It was launched in 2001 and still "cookin with gas"!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1294160

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google