ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



How the pharaohs were fed

Posted: Tuesday, July 01, 2008 5:41 PM by Alan Boyle


N. Moeller / Tell Edfu Project
This view of the excavation at Tell Edfu shows superimposed
settlement layers. Some of the grain silos from Egypt's 17th Dynasty
were covered by a thick layer of ash. At a later date, several storage
compartments were built on top of the covered silos.

Egypt's best-known excavations usually focus on the glittering mummies and grand monuments of the pharaohs, but for something completely different, travel up the Nile to Tell Edfu: The archaeologists digging there have uncovered ruins that shed light on the administrative and agricultural foundations of ancient Egypt's riches.


G. Marouard / Tell Edfu Project
The Tell Edfu archaeological dig is spread out in the
foreground, with the pylon of a Ptolemaic temple in
the background. Click on the image for a larger view.

The Tell Edfu site is significant because it preserves about 3,000 years' worth of history in a single mound - and because the ancient settlement served as a key link in the chain connecting Egypt's agricultural society with the lifestyles of the rich and famous.

"The problem has been that my colleagues deal with temples and monumental architecture, and settlements haven't been something that has attracted that level of interest," the dig's director, University of Chicago archaeologist Nadine Moeller, told me. "But they're actually really important for understanding the ancient Egyptian civilization."

Many of ancient Egypt's urban sites have gone by the wayside, obliterated either by farming or by centuries of urban renewal. So little evidence has survived that some scholars question whether Egypt ever had a well-developed urban culture, according to today's report from the University of Chicago about the Tell Edfu dig.

A granary ... and a bank
Moeller and her colleagues excavated what amounted to the downtown area in a provincial capital, south of ancient Thebes (modern-day Luxor). Thebes is hundreds of miles upstream on the Nile from the Great Pyramids - but for long stretches of Egypt's history, the city served as a pharaonic capital.

Among the most intriguing structures excavated so far are seven grain bins dating back to the 17th Dynasty (1630-1520 B.C.). Because grain served as a form of currency, this wasn't merely a granary - it was also the ancient equivalent of a bank, essentially managing tax collections for the provincial governor and the pharaoh.


D. Farout / Tell Edfu Project
Nadine Moeller of the University of Chicago's Oriental Institute supervises
the Tell Edfu dig. Click on the image for a larger version.

"Grain as currency provided the sinews of power for the pharaohs," Gil Stein, director of the Oriental Institute at the University of Chicago, explained in today's news release.

The administration of that power has been described in ancient Egyptian texts, but there's nothing like seeing the actual places where that power was exercised. The silos measure 18 to 21 feet wide, making them the largest grain bins ever discovered within an ancient Egyptian town center. 

Going deeper
Yet another layer of construction predated the silos. Moeller and her colleagues determined that a mud-brick structure with 16 wooden columns was used in the 13th Dynasty (1773-1650 B.C.), based on an analysis of shards of pottery and scarab seals found at the site.   The hall of columns served as a place where scribes did their accounting, opened and sealed containers, and received letters.


G. Marouard / Tell Edfu Project
This view of the ruins of a 13th-Dynasty
administrative building shows some of
the sandstone column bases.

Moeller speculated that the hall may have been part of the provincial governor's palace. "It was far more extensive than we expected," she said. "Actually, I still haven't reached the full limit of the whole structure."

For now, the dig has sparked more questions than answers: How much time did the grain spend in the silos? How was it distributed among provincial, priestly and pharaonic officials? What heights did Egypt's urban society reach more than 3,000 years ago? When Moeller returns to the dig in October, she plans to seek the answers to such questions and more.

Tell Edfu may not look as monumental as the Great Pyramids - but the dead city, and other sites like it, are just as important for learning how everyday Egyptians lived. If anything, such sites are more endangered than the pyramids themselves.

"We don't have many of these sites left," Moeller said.

For different takes on the Tell Edfu discoveries, check out this report from Lost Egypt and this one from The New York Times.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I hear about greek and roman money(currency). I wonder if they will discover ancient egyptian money from these eras.
what a beautiful image of a man made object...we do some nice stuff when there's no big rush, eh?
are those anthropogenic bricks?
This is a brilliant display of continued civalisation occupation within a single area.
It would be interesting to know what type of ash was present covering the 17th. Dynasty grain silo's, if it was volcanic, or due to invasion and destruction, or due to fire from natural or other causes.
This could be a very exciting look into this civalizations past experiences, which could shed light on this regions continued civalised occupation.
Alan,

Is there any indication whether the ash layer, referred to in the caption, was due to a one time structure fire, such as an accident over the whole city - like Rome, or an intentional cerimonial burning - like completing a task then leaving -- or -- was the "thick" layer due to several burnings over time?  Or was it something like volcanic ash?
On the ash layer: Nadine Moeller has a wonderful collection of newsletters on the dig, and you should check them out to get more info about all this. Here's a quote from her 2006 newsletter (and the parenthetical exclamation point is hers, not mine):

http://homepage.mac.com/nadinemoeller/
.Public/Tell%20Edfu%2006.pdf


"... Numerous square structures, which seem to have functioned as cellars, were found close to walls belonging to larger buildings. Some of these cellars were built into the substantial ash layer covering much of our area, which provided additional protection for stored foodstuff against insects and rodents. The ash layer, which is in parts several meters thick (!), has been deposited in an earlier occupation phase than the cellars and is a sign of industrial activity here, most likely related to bakeries. ..."

You can find the newsletters as well as photos and more info at Moeller's Web site:

http://homepage.mac.com/nadinemoeller/Menu5.html


Could these graineries be the same that Joseph used during the 7 years of plenty in preparation for the 7 years of famine?
So what grains were in the bins?

What kind of grain? Here's the word from Moeller:

"Grain, which was usually barley or emmer wheat, was used as food and medium of exchange. One form of payment was the monthly ration of grain."

http://egyptology.blogspot.com/2008/06/
more-re-ancient-egyptian-administrative.html


Flax was another type of grain typically grown in those days.

As for Joseph and the granaries, you might find this story interesting:

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/976470.html

It's interesting to hear that the Egyptians mixed sand with the grain to fight off bugs. Come to think of it, having a layer of ash underlying your granary might have served as a similar type of anti-pest measure, as Moeller has noted.

Sounds like that sand may be diatomaceous earth, fossil remains of a hard shelled algae.  It's safe to use in foodstuffs, as it is too small to slice up our insides, but it makes little slices in the crawlers and kills them.  If there was a mine or outcropping anywhere in the region it could have been dispersed all across the known world, nothing needs to be done to it, it's ready to kill just about any insect.  Not sure about locusts, thick shell and if they don't drag their belly ...
Uh, don't know about the diatomaceous comment! diatomaceous material would look as white as chalk, but nice try Indy.
Grain used as a form of money...payment. Over 5,000 years later and grain/oil could be making its way towards that exchange again. Another example of this world and civilization coming full circle again........
Looks like the stories in the old testament are true.
The picture showing the stratification should be textbook material for every archaeology student on the planet. Makes one wonder what Troy would have looked like had the same policies been in force back then.
This is awesome news! Give us more news like this!
As far as I know, coinage was invented around the 6th century BC by the Greeks.  There are almost no coins with hierogpyphics on them, as coinage was introduced by the Ptolomies after Alexander the Great's conquest.  There is actually one Egyptian coin I have seen that has hieroglyphics on it...
Were there any documents (stone or otherwise)found?  What other information was found that could indicate time?  What does the ash indicate?  Was it just left over rubble that covered the previous layer?  
Similar to the Tel Edfu granary I was pretty impressed when visiting Versailles one year and touring the King's Kitchen Garden.

Royalty in many civilizations had the best foods and creature comforts which made up several levels of wealth. All these things make up a most interesting part of each culture.
gdog,
After some study, because I thought making any comments made should have some value, hint, I found some interesting things.  Currently, 16 grit sharp sand, crushed granite, cinder ash or pumice are used for termite control.  They're used to make a physical barrier, minimal sizes for each dimension are 20" wide and 3" thick.  Of course, any one place recommended either wider or deeper.  Tamping is recommended.  It provides a physical barrier in that the larger grains are too large for the termites to move and if they try to squeeze between the smaller grains the get cut.  This proccess relies on the concentration of the sand to work.  Although mixed in with the grain I imagine insects would sustain cuts as they travelled that would compound each other.

More interesting is the use of wood ash as a desiccant.  After being sliced open by the sand the insects would have been dehydrated.  Capping a full silo with a thick layer of wood ash would also have sealed this access point to the grain from insect attack.  This would be the effect noted in the excerpt from Moeller.

Of course, for this sand to work it would have to be unweathered.  I don't know of any convenient way to sort old and new sand from each other, but they may have produced it by crushing material in a mill.  Collecting sand from a dune wouldn't work for reasons pointed out in my earlier, DE, post.

Wood ash has adds a further element to pest control in that it raises pH to a level which may be an irritant to pests.  And still both ash and sand are easily separated from the grain.  I wonder if leaving the ash helps with digestability.
Could it be that the ash was scattered on the city deliberately to get rid of some kind of pest like lice, or cover up a virus that was causing sickness?
I heard that the Egyptians added sand to grain to make it easier to grind - but it also wore away their teeth.
The earlier referenced Tell Edfu project website has changed and now can be found at: http://www.telledfu.org



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=1177846

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google