ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



Talk to the robo-bunny

Posted: Thursday, November 08, 2007 4:36 PM by Alan Boyle


Nabaztag / Violet

Nabaztag robotic rabbits like these are being adapted by the Companions Project
for an experiment aimed at creating long-term conversational partners.


How many of you have a special friend who's known you for decades ... who can recall all your triumphs and foibles ... who knows you so well that he (or she) can tell you what you need to hear when nobody else will do it? That special someone may well be a standard feature in the lives of future generations - and it may well take the form of an ankle-high robotic bunny.

At least that's one of the concepts that the Companions Project is working with as it tries to develop computerized language systems that are good enough to keep up their end of a conversation. In a classic case of life imitating Hollywood, NASA is already working on computerized conversational assistants for astronauts. (Imagine this future space odyssey: "Dave? This conversation can serve no useful purpose anymore. Goodbye ..."). The Pentagon, meanwhile, has been funding a similar project. (Did I see that in "The Terminator" or "The Matrix"?)

Yorick Wilks, who is a researcher at the University of Sheffield in England and director of the Companions Project, says such systems could eventually serve here on Earth as long-term life coaches who never forget what you've done or where you've been (unless you want them to).

Scientists have been working on "chatterbots" since the dawn of the computer age, as exemplified by such experiments as ELIZA and PARRY. In this week's issue of the journal Science, Wilks provides an update on the state of the art. The bottom line? In most cases, the technology is "still not accurate enough to build a reliable machine partner capable of understanding what we say," Wilks reports. But just you wait.

Wilks and his colleagues are working on a couple of experiments to develop conversational software agents that are good enough to keep humans engaged for the long haul. We already occasionally deal with such agents, of course, when we call directory assistance, or check an airline reservation, or order a pizza. But these next-generation agents would be more like companions than clerks.

"The key feature that links all the companions is that they're agents that remember who you are," Wilks told me. "Your companion is for you, and it knows who you are, and it will stay with you for decades. This concept is going to become stronger and more powerful."

Enter the rabbit
Here's where the bunny hops into the picture. One of the Companions experiments involves the Nabaztag robotic rabbit - a wireless Internet contraption that can speak, move its ears and flash its lights in response to user inputs. Researchers have hacked the rabbit for speech recognition as well, with the aim of creating a specialized companion - for example, a personal health and fitness trainer.

The robo-rabbit could conceivably check your vital signs, listen to you talk about your eating habits and exercise routine, judge your mood and make suggestions or offer encouragement. The trainer wouldn't have to be a rabbit - it could take the form of a disembodied voice on a mobile phone, or an avatar on a computer screen.


AsAnAngel

A virtual avatar with a
bouffant hairdo helps
senior citizens reminisce in
one of the Companions Project's experiments.


In fact, Wilks said another experiment uses a virtual avatar to chat with senior citizens in Scotland. "We're using a nice head that comes from the French telephone company," Wilks told me. "It's a nice, bouffant-haired French lady."

The aim of the experiment is to draw out details about the ups and downs of the seniors' lives, and link those stories with personal photos to create an enduring electronic legacy.

"We're looking at old people reminiscing about their lives and building up a narrative by talking to a machine - a kind of organized reminiscence," Wilks explained.

You could have virtual companions for different areas of your life, just as you have different people nowadays to handle your finances, arrange your daily schedule and offer a sympathetic ear. "To be honest, if this kind of technology works, there'll be companions for every possible application," Wilks said.

In fact, other researchers have speculated that robots could well make inroads in the sex-and-marriage realm. Although Wilks said the idea is not "totally serious," there's at least a germ of truth to it. Even today, the Nabaztag robo-rabbit is occasionally put to an amorous application, he noted.

"We have long-distance lovers keeping in contact over it," Wilks said.

What will it take?
Looking ahead, researchers are trying to figure out exactly what it will take to get to a natural-language nirvana. Is it just a question of building up a huge database of queries and responses? That's a brute-force approach to the challenge of conversation, analogous to the way computers came to outdo humans at checkers and chess. But Wilks believes it will take something more: Computers also will have to absorb the linguistic structures that humans use, through automated learning.

"That might be closer to what our own cognitive structures seem to be," Wilks wrote in his Science report.

Based on researchers' experience with speech recognition, the chances are good that machines will eventually become adequate conversationalists, if we let them, Wilks said. "Twenty or 30 years ago, the idea of computerized recognition of speech was a dream. Now it's really not bad," Wilks said.

In fact, Wilks wonders why we don't have more chatterbots in our lives already. For instance, he's puzzled over the lack of bank machines that could chat with you about cashing a check or paying your bills.

"If I was a good entrepreneur, I'd have a go at it myself," he told me. "But I'm not. I'm a lab rat."

Would you have a go at it? Would you strike up a conversation with a bankbot, or a trainerbot, or a lifelong virtual companion? Going a bit further, are you game to have robots call the shots, or would your first instinct be to flee the robot uprising? Either way, feel free to add your comments below.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

"Even today, the Nabaztag robo-rabbit is occasionally put to an amorous application, he noted."

Considering my first thought was "OMG - That's two vibrators!" I'm not at all surprised.
who is the artist that got famous for little bunnies like these?
they were supposed to be famous people, but all looked alike...
I think this sound’s like a great idea for the elderly and the infirmed. I believe this could assist the handicapped as well. Also think it has great potential with children and learning. Can’t wait to see what’s next.
These sound SO cool. I'm sure if they ever do manage to finish this it'll be really expensive, though. >_< Oh well, I'm looking forward to some updates!
I think that the life-long friend to cheer you up is a GREAT idea!
Although I understand the concept, how very sad and pathetic.
I agree with Dennis Towner: It's pathetic that people are so lonely they need to buy computerized artificial friends, instead of going out and making real artifical friends the old-fashioned way! On the other hand, a computerized artificial friend you can have sex with?Now, that's progress! Only, who needs to talk with the thing? The real artifical friends talking is what got us into this predicament!
And who wants yet another device that knows your entire life story and all your secrets and can betray you to the first decent hacker who comes along?  
ZabaWare.com makes a great little learning chatterbot and Digital assistant(computer avatar). I've actually talked to my little frog 'Zaba' for over an hour in one sitting! :)
I agree with sad and pathetic.  Have we become so gadget oriented that we have to invent things to talk to our elderly than just caring for them ourselves? When I am elderly and someone tries to pass one of these things to me, I will feed it back to them.
I have no friends. I'm used to it. People annoy me. The only advantage to the robo bunny would be that you could destroy it in a violent manner whenever it became too annoying. Die, bunny, die...
Hurry!  I need one of these for my aging mother with Altzheimers!  Wouldn't she love telling the same stories over and over again to it (and wouldn't I)?
I do not consider this sad or pathetic.  First, it provides motivation for advancing the technology, and second, if they make sufficient progress, these things might become good advisers, mentors which supply is limited and precious.  (The pathetic thing being our society and not the individuals who might use them.)
I would interact and respond to an "I, Robot" or "AI" humaniform robot. I see a need for these. There are many pieces of technology which need to leap in order to make them viable and buy-able in the next 20 years. On top of it all, there is no system integrator which has stepped up to the plate to integrate all these disparate technologies.
cool
Pathetic.People with no friends ha-ha
i guess it would be cool if you dont have friends
hey i likea da bunny bunny but it is kind of creepy but a good idea at the same time
neato borrito what if they got smarter than us and took over the world!!!! crazy stuff to think about..
hey i like the bunny thing beacuse it is kindy cool beacuse if you were lonly that could make you happy to talk to some one or a bunny so i think that it is cool.
I don't like humans so a robot friend would be pretty rad, lol. :|
i think this might be a good idea because there are some things you would never tell someone, and may be you don't want anybody to know.
this was cool i gues
This is a great idea especially for those people who don't have any friends.No offense to those people but this could really help some people.  I would definately buy one.
I think that this is a good idea for people who are in an office all day and can get lonley but as for me i think that i am better off going to my friends is better for me. people have different personalities, so for some people, i say, "go on ahead!"
this is a horrible thing it looks like it will be very creepy just talk to a real person
this is for one lonley person. but thats ok because maybe they can practice talking with the bunny before going and talking to a real person.
wow that sounds cool i would buy one that would be so cool
Sounds neat... but why? Its like they're trying to create a human: someone you can to talk to and communicate with. Why try to create something we already have?
Ok, umm slightly creepy and a litle off the wall, bunnies?? why? But at the same time an interesting idea, unconditional companion...Big seller with the Loners of the world. the whole sex thing tho? come on, get laid.
i think that this is very cool neat idea and i wonder if it will ever become something that me and my family have in our house.
I wouldnt want one, but other people might appreciate it.
Well I think this would be very useful, but it would creep me out quite a bit. But they sound like they would be a lot of fun.
I think this is a neat little piece of equipment. It is also very cute and amusing.
I think that this is a kind of idea that could help some people with their lives and minds. For people who are very lonely and have personal issues it could be very benificial. For others it could cause security issues because if it were to get stolen.
this is a cool ittle thing we got going here.Haveing a little bunny or an "avatar" would be really cool and help full!
i think this is a horrible idea because if we have robot soldiers thay won't have human reactions or instinct. i also want to fly planes and i wont be able to if it is a robot.
This seems like a really cool new toy. It would be really neat to be able to go onto your computer and talk to it. It would also be very useful for people who are lonely and/or people who need a personal trainer. Can't wait to see if this will be something that I will see in my life time!
I think it's a good idea because in the future some people might be lonely and they might want somebody to talk to.
The idea, though very appealing. Is kind of dangerous for any "unwary" youth. Identity theft and such. I think it's "begging" for trouble
This could potentially be the next great invention! I'm sure this would be phenomenal for not only children and the elderly, but all age groups. It is nice to have someone(or something) who you can talk to and tell them everything, and know that they will not tell anyone these things.
If it reads the news I'll be happy with it too! If it coaches me on something worthwhile for understanding I'll be happy, but if it chatters I'll kill it! :)
which is more pathetic, the people who use these gadgets for entertainment or the ones who spend hundreds of hours screaming at over paid, under educated, egotistical athletes they watch on tv or worse yet in a large stadium that cries out to be a terrorist target. yeah i'll take the bunnies.
I like the whole avatar thing.It would be sort of like MegaMan.And if we could could have the robot itself look like a character it would cool.It would also be nice because you could practice for an interview or tell it your secrets if you don't have a friend you can trust with secrets.But to cut that down to short words it would be cool.
Sure, it is all warm and fuzzy right now but when will we see people going on strike because a "robot" took their jobs. It is too easy to say we'll let the machines do it. We already spend too much time with our computers.
I don't see why people are calling the people who would get something like this pathetic and sad.  For one it's an assumption that this bunny would be their only companion, even the most reclusive people have friends (even if it's long distance or internet based).  Plus, does everyone tell their friends/best friends Everything?  I know I don't for sure, medical, financial, personal problems I tend to leave out of conversations (especially with some specific friends else everyone they know will know about my problems).  If this bunny is going to be a companion then I see this as more of a novelty companion.
AS someone who is getting over a CVA (A stroke) I would love to have these robo-friends for a while. I do get human interaction at work, and I am back to work, but it gets lonely at home. The cats (thank God for my pair!) can't talk back and can't tell me (except in most basic ways)that I have done something incredibly stupid.
6 billion plus people on the planet and we can't find anyone to talk with or be friends with?? Got to talk to a machine? This is the epitome of pathetic....and shows the wrong direction we're headed in. Make friends for pete's sake!
Sporty...go Bubba, go...ya might have a good idea there, eh?
It's kewl...Wonder how long before it becomes bilingual...Not much use in the U.S.A. if it's not.  :-S
Hello I am JoDEK and I thought that the online avatar reminds me of a videogame called Megaman the newer one not the older one


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=455748

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google