ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



Newfound planet could support life

Posted: Tuesday, November 06, 2007 1:39 PM by Alan Boyle


NASA / JPL-Caltech
This artist's conception shows four of the five planets that orbit 55 Cancri, a star
much like our own. The most recently discovered planet looms large in the
foreground. The colors of the planets were chosen to resemble those of our own
solar system. Click on the image to watch a video from MSNBC's "Countdown."

Planet-hunters say they have detected a giant world that is nestled among four others in a planetary system 41 light-years from Earth. This newfound world is in the "Goldilocks zone" - a place that's not too hot, not too cold, but just right for the existence of liquid water and conceivably life.

The fresh discovery, announced Tuesday during a NASA teleconference, focuses on a star and planetary system called 55 Cancri, in the constellation Cancer. The system is already well-known to astronomers who search for the telltale signs of planets beyond our own solar system - but the newly detected planet has taken the search to a new level.

"We're announcing the discovery of the first quintuple-planet system," Debra Fischer, an astronomer at San Francisco State University and lead author of a paper due to appear in the Astrophysical Journal, told reporters.

Geoff Marcy, a pioneer planet-hunter from the University of California at Berkeley who contributed to the paper, said the planetary system is a "souped-up" version of our own. Like our own solar system, these planets make nearly circular orbits around the parent star - but they're super-sized.

The innermost planet is about the size of Neptune and whips around the parent star in less than three days, at a distance of about 3.5 million miles. The farthest-out planet is four times as massive as Jupiter and takes 14 Earth years to orbit, at a distance of about 539 million miles - or just a little farther out than our solar system's Jupiter.

The planets in between are in the range of Jupiter and Saturn, but the most interesting one is the fourth rock from its sun: a world 45 times the mass of Earth, perhaps a gas giant similar to Saturn or Neptune in composition and appearance. That planet is about 72.5 million miles out from the parent star, in an orbit that's similar to Venus' orbit.

55 Cancri is slightly fainter than our own sun - and that would put the newly detected planet in a habitable zone that should allow water to remain liquid on a rocky surface, astronomers say.


NASA / JPL-Caltech
This diagram shows the 55 Cancri system at top and our own solar system
at bottom. In each view, the "habitable zone" is marked as a green band.

A gas giant isn't a likely suspect in the search for life - but any rocky moons around it would be. Just as Jupiter's moon Europa and Saturn's moon Enceladus hold promise for astrobiologists, a moon around the newly detected planet could conceivably be a prime suspect in the search.

"Such a moon would have to be fairly massive," Marcy cautioned. "In fact, it would have to be about as massive as the planet Mars … in order to retain its water."

Jonathan Lunine, a planetary scientist at the University of Arizona, said temperatures on this hypothetical moon might be just a little bit warmer than temperatures on Earth. But like Marcy, Lunine said a bit of caution was in order. "I would recommend not buying real estate on any of these planets" until more readings were available, he said.  

Marcy said the discovery of the fifth planet "has me jumping out of my socks" - not just because of the habitable-zone angle, but because it indicates that planetary systems like our own appear to be more common than astronomers thought just a few years ago.

The new planet, like the four other ones, was detected using the Doppler radial-velocity technique, in which a planet's gravitational tug is detected by the wobble it produces in the parent star. In a long-running project funded by NASA and the National Science Foundation, observations of 55 Cancri were collected using telescopes at the Lick Observatory in California and the Keck Observatory in Hawaii.

The method is one of the most time-honored tricks for finding extrasolar planets - but it takes a long time to gather enough information about the complex wobbles to identify multiple planets in a system. More than 350 velocity measurements were required to untangle the wobbly pattern created by the planets at 55 Cancri.

"Discovering these five planets took us 18 years of continuous observations at Lick Observatory, starting before any extrasolar planets were known anywhere in the universe," Marcy said in a NASA announcement. "But finding five extrasolar planets orbiting a star is only one small step. Earthlike planets are the next destination."

As currently used, the Doppler technique isn't sensitive enough to detect planets around the mass of our own - but Fischer said an intriguing orbital gap in the 55 Cancri system is big enough to harbor Earthlike planets that could be found in the future using more precise techniques.

"There could be 10 Earthlike planets there, but we've just not detected them yet," Fischer said.

Finding new Earths around sunlike stars would be a "holy grail" for planet-hunters, Lunine said. Such worlds could harbor alien life, or not. Either way, the quest could answer humanity's deepest questions about life, the universe and everything.

But like all quests, this one has its bumps in the road: Marcy and Fischer noted that one of the extrasolar planets that was once thought to be potentially hospitable to life, Gliese 581c, is now said to be too hot rather than just right. (There's a debate about that.)

To reach the true grail, scientists will have to develop new ground-based telescopes and launch new spacecraft such as NASA's Kepler probe and Europe's Darwin flotilla. Most importantly, they'll have to cast a wide, wide net.

"If you  asked me where the right place would be to look for Earthlike planets," Lunine said, "my answer would be anywhere, and everywhere."

Update for 9:35 p.m. ET: Be sure to check out this video segment from MSNBC's "Countdown." Host Keith Olbermann discusses the newfound planet and other space news with Derrick Pitts, chief astronomer at the Franklin Institute.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Gaia Two would be right at home in the Goldilock's Zone...maybe that's what we should name this new planet...Gaia Two...Earth Two...same...same...
We must keep searching for earthlike planets, because one day in the not too distant future, only a handfull of us, earthlings, will have to make an escape to this other world to continue the cycle of life forwards, as our very ancient ancestors did for us.
Kitty, are you suggesting that life on Earth originated from outer space?  Do you have any research or sources, outside of the Sci-Fi channel, to state that?
This is all very interesting, but, how would we get there.  I don't see us having the Enterprise any time soon.  Anyway, do we even belong out there?  Us and our wicked ways?    
I love astromomy..can't wait for this one.
Kitty, are you suggesting that life on Earth originated from outer space?  Do you have any research or sources, outside of the Sci-Fi channel, to state that?

Jethris (Sent Tuesday, November 06, 2007 2:59 PM)

I was thinking the same thing...
If our conception of chemical physics is correct, it would be stupid to think that earth is the only place life is. Organic and inorganic is the basis of all things, according to the table of elements to date.
Sci-fi channel? About as reliable as Sunday School.....
make it so number 1.
with Humanity's luck the first planet we find will be the one our ancestors left.if Kitty is right
this is my theory i think we were put here by an alien race much more advanced than us, like kitty courts said our ancestors , we are still evolving ang growing with science , our ancestors the ones that visit us are already advanced they seeded us here and are wacthingus develop.we are still so far behind.
I think Kitty must have gotten into the catnip...
too bad that finding another inhabitable planet does not disprove god
Maybe.  It's no more unusual than the idea that some trascendent being called "god" breathed life into us.  There's truly a lot we will never know.  Origins may be one of them.
Jethris: No she has inadequate proof from a peer review standpoint to confirm this. She does however have all she needs to form a new religion, and start attempting to force everyone else to live by her beliefs.

We might want to get her to understand the difference between an idea and a confirmed fact now, well before the party she forms starts stuffing the justice department with those of like minds.
Jethris, in defense of Kitty, and in no way endorsing her perspective, I think your manner of questioning borders on the offensive with your reference to the Sci-Fi channel.  There actually is a large contingency of very qualified scientists that have also proposed such an origin of mankind.  They are not necessarily saying that a civilized race came to earth and started life, but that possibly organisms carried on meteors might have helped along the process by which life began.  

No one has the answers and no one should put down others because they think differently.
Jethris, Do you think that it's not possible? Nothing says that it's true or isn't true. Everyone knows people will believe what they want, nothing short of death will change that.
dude... just watch the movie Titan A.E. ... very credible.. will explain everything..
Hopefully, in the next hundred years, we can launch a long range probe that would give us a closer look at these newly discoverd planets. Wouldn't it be great to recieve actual video from these places !
I'm not going to hold my breath, 41 light-years, but it would be exciting.
Please, Jeth, keep your theology out of my astronomy.
Jethris...are you curious or does that scare you?
i like your statement kitty.  kind of how i feel too.
I took Kitty's comments to mean our far distant ancestors moved from continent to continent but I may be wrong there. The search for extraterrestrial life, intelligent or not, has always fascinated me. Are we alone?
As a romantic, I have sometimes thought that living during the 1800's and those times of the 'wild west' and booming technology, would have ideally suited me. Now, I am saddened that I will never experience the thrills of our future pioneers who will be able to journey to distant solar systems and explore planets and investigate other amazing forms of life. I guess I will just stare at the stars and wonder!!!!
Kitty, you must be in outer space to suggest such a comical situation and an unproven methical theory.
Does not any one believe in Creation??
I belive that is called scientology - 0ne who belives life came from outerspace
I can't wait for a space based interferometer to get real pictures of these planets. Hopefully within the next 10-20 years NASA and it's international partners can get TPF funded as it is currently "deferred indefinitely". :(  oh well

Still cool news that astronomers have detected this new world.
We are not alone. Just play the odds and some where there will be intelligent life. Intelligent life on earth ( sometimes debatable ) is not the only thing around.
Jethris: you might want to go online and view all the depictions of UFO's from Egyptian times to 16th century painters to aboriginal drawings. You think EVERYONE is making this up? Please.There ARE advanced beings out there, way ahead of us.
How about you Jethris... do you have any research or sources to the opposite, other than an insignifigant piece of misinterpreted fiction left behind by people less intelligent than us?
Don't get your hopes up. We will never get to these planets, as far away as they are. So that means we need to take care of our own planet and control our overpopulation.
I think this is a particularly interesting piece of scifi news. I just love the possibility that we may not be the only intelligent life forms in the Universe.  Maybe some of them could come here and straighten men out.  Not women, we're fine!
Jethris,

I believe what Kitty was trying to say was that life, in its simplest forms could have come from outer space. In the early stages of Earth's life it was a hot, motlen rock being bombarded with asteroids and comets from all directions, each one bringing a variety of chemicals and elements.  I hope you're not trying to suggest that an invisible man that no one has seen or heard from magically created us.... This is a webpage of science not theology. If its theology you're looking for I suggest visiting the Creationism museum located in Kentucky.
Battlestar Galactica was cool and all that, but SHEESH!  Have at least SOME originality.  Like we came from....Galactic toads or something even MORE convincing!!
I would love to hear more on Kitty's theory of our earthling's beginning
I don't know about our previous ancestors being from another planet, what with the cavemen and evolution and all, but I can see how we would be the first of conceivably many 'cycles' of our race that might have to spread out amoungst the galaxy. Not only because of war and famine or the such, but because we will have simply overstayed our welcome here on Earth. Life will become impossible here for us, and after we leave, the Earth will renew it's resources, possibly starting over completely, and the cycle continues. It is an intreging thought
I assume that the "life zone" being discussed is the liquid water life zone.  Or are these researchers also considering the possibilities of life on worlds with liquid ammonia, methane, or hydrogen fluoride?
Locating earth-type planets is critical to our uniting as a species on this planet; that we are not alone in the universe gives us perspective in being human to each other, finally respecting one another as star dust.
As  we vacated MARS millions of years ago after destroying it, future generations will have a new place to go when we discard the earth!!!!!!!
Jethris,  Now don't slap around kitty.  She's just stating that before all the world goes to hell in a hand basket we (the one's that have the desire to continue on) need an escape plan, and don't you think that we need to start the next earth with people who already have evolved intelegently like.  Not that Jerry Springer isn't entertaining, but who want's to start over with monkeys.
I don't know about the rest of you, but I find this mildly exciting. Super earth-like planets in outer space...this is just speculation/borderline fantasy but what if there are already living organisms there? Who knows, it may be other humans like us living in their own world...probably exploring space just like us. Haha.

I can see it now...in a couple of centuries/millenia there could be intergalactic networks, REAL space travel & all that good stuff.

Who wants to go Cancri? I do!
It stands to reason that we will need to expand our horizons if we're to remain a viable species for any length of time to come. Good hunting!
This is were the aliens live that visit our earth time to time. We need to try to visit one day to meet them.
Jethris, it's unlikely that life on earth came from outer space.  There's no Oxygen out there.  Kitty, I think Venus is a likely suspect for our origin since it now suffers from destructive global warming effects and Earth is on it's way there.  Human kind will never learn.
Kitty can state what she wants to, it's her opinion.
Question:
How do you see 41 light years away? I do not understand how you get the information back before 41 years. I did not understand relativity very well in school. Please help.

Thank You
seems more plausible than the bible
I think we will destoy this planet for the human race way before we make an outpost on some other planet. That is not to say other forms of life will not continue to live here...just not human.
Jethris, do you have any proof that God created man from the earth and the female from his rib?

Yup, didn't think so.
Captain Picard and his mentor, the foremost preeminent archeologist already proved it.  It is a fact.  Life did originate from outside of our solar system!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=451256

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google