ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



The 'Wow' mystery turns 30

Posted: Wednesday, August 15, 2007 8:50 PM by Alan Boyle


Courtesy of Jerry Ehman / BigEar.org
The code "6EQUJ5" indicates a radio signal detected in 1977 at the Big Ear Radio
Observatory in Ohio - a signal so strong that astronomer Jerry Ehman wrote "Wow!"

Exactly 30 years ago today, astronomer Jerry Ehman was looking over a printout of radio data from Ohio State University's Big Ear Radio Observatory when he saw a string of code so remarkable that he had to circle it and scribble "Wow!" in the margin. The printout recorded an anomalous signal so strong that it had to come from an extraordinary source.

Was it a burst of human-made interference? Or an alien broadcast from the stars? No one knows. The source of the "Wow" signal has never been heard from again - even though astronomers have looked for it dozens of times.

Now the SETI Institute is gearing up to look for it one more time, using the latest tool for seeking signals from extraterrestrial civilizations: the Allen Telescope Array in California.

The array combines observations from dozens of separate 20-foot-wide (6-meter-wide) radio dishes to produce an instrument that will eventually become more sensitive than the world's largest single-dish telescope, the Arecibo Observatory.

"Once the Allen Telescope Array is up and running, and that should be later this year, there's going to be a small project in which we'll look at the same section where the 'Wow' signal was detected, and of course the same spot on the radio dial," Seth Shostak, senior astronomer at the SETI Institute, told me today.

Although that area of the sky has been searched dozens of times before, the Allen Telescope Array will bring more sensitivity and wider spectral coverage to the quest, Shostak said.

The renewed search came as welcome news to Ehman, the man behind the "Wow."

"Back in 1977, of course, the computers weren't very powerful," he told me. "Nowadays, if you have the money, you can get excellent receivers, filter banks, computers - you can do much more now than you could in 1977."

But he cautioned that the search could well come up empty again.

"With the Big Ear Radio Telescope, we stayed on that same strip of sky for close to two months and didn't see anything," he said. "A few years later, we looked at that same area of sky and didn't see anything. That was frustrating."

After the single radio burst was detected, astronomers tried to track down a terrestrial cause. But they could find no glitch in the system, and no source that could have explained the strength and the frequency of the seconds-long signal. Since then, the "Wow" signal has stood as one of the central enigmas for alien-hunters, inspiring a scene in "The X-Files."

"The 'Wow' signal is the best evidence of extraterrestrial intelligence," says one character, who refers to Ehman as "my buddy."

Ehman said aliens weren't the first thing that came to his mind when he saw the Big Ear data and wrote his famous word.

"The 'Wow' was just an instantaneous response in writing," he said. "I had no expectations, other than 'here's something extremely interesting - and gee, let's try to find out what it is, or what it isn't.'"

Ehman recently updated his own report on the "Wow" signal for the 30th anniversary, but the report's conclusion hasn't changed over all this time.

"It's still an open question what the source of the signal was," he told me. "We just don't have enough information to determine that. ... We just can't draw any conclusion other than it still allows for the possibility that it was a signal from an extraterrestrial civilization."

Over the past three decades, signal searchers have developed strategies for dealing with "Wow"-type anomalies, Shostak said. For example, if an interesting signal happens to be on a precisely tuned frequency like 14.2700000 MHz, Shostak said it's safe to assume that "some earthly engineer" is responsible (unless E.T. also uses a decimal counting system and measures time in earthly seconds).

If astronomers pick up an interesting signal from one point in the sky, they'll shift their telescope's focus to aim at a different spot. If the signal doesn't go away, the astronomers assume that terrestrial interference is affecting the observations.

That kind of reality check will be much easier to do with the Allen Telescope Array, Shostak said. "You can very quickly switch the telescope to 'point' in a different direction without physically moving the antenna," he said.

For these reasons, the modern search for extraterrestrial intelligence hasn't produced a fresh crop of "Wow" signals, although every once in a while there's a false alarm that sets Shostak's heart racing.

It could well be that the "Wow" signal will remain in a class by itself for millennia to come: never repeated, but never eliminated as a potential alien transmission. I can easily imagine that a civilization might send out a one-shot broadcast rather than a continuous stream of signals. After all, that's what we did.

In 1974, scientists at the Arecibo Observatory sent a coded signal in the direction of the globular star cluster M13 for three minutes - and then just stopped. "It was really just a demo," Shostak said. It will take 25,000 years for the signal to reach M13, but once it arrives, the Arecibo signal might be as enigmatic for the aliens as the "Wow" signal is for us.

"If there is somebody on the other end, they're going to call it the 'Zork' signal, or whatever you want to call it," Shostak said. "They may puzzle over that for years."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

"Zork signal"... LOL!

I wish the best of lucks to the SETI crew in trying to decipher the mistery of the Wow! signal. I also applaud Paul Allen's patronizing of such important endeavours as the search of ET and opening the final frontier to the common man.

Although I do get the feeling that the procedures of SETI are somewhat akin to bushmen trying to use smoke signals to communicate with men living at New York...

Wow!

-30-
hopefully we hear it again,  we all know we're not alone! have seen something in the sky that still has me wondering and was quieter than a mouse! good luck and never give up.  
An infinite number of monkeys on an infinite number of typewritters and sooner or later Hamlet or at least the gettysberg address is going to be printed.  Doesn't mean Shakespeare or Lincoln is doing the typing...  
I hope we never find life out there we can't eat for it is likely then they will eat us.
What get's me is that no one in this story has contemplated the idea that perhaps the signal was alien---but not from a planet.

If you were doing long-range exploration, wouldn't you use satellites?  Or automated space ships?

Too bad the technology in '77 wasn't capable in searching for moving objects within the solar system.

But on the other hand, knowing what little we know of quantum physics and it's poosibility to create devices to communicate I would be surprised an advanced civilization would still be using ordinary radio waves to make a long distance collect call.
COSMIC WOWS!!!!  
I just read this on the 30th anniversary report of the Wow signal:

"The Big Ear radio telescope (which detected the signal in 1977) was destroyed in 1998 by land developers who purchased the land on which the telescope was located from the Ohio Wesleyan University, Delaware, Ohio, in order to convert a 9-hole golf course into an 18-hole course and to build aproximately 400 houses on the land that they had purchased."

Typical! :-(

PS: Am I the only one who thinks golf is a nasty "sport"? You ever cared to think how many water these fields consume annualy?
I believe, to not believe is a seriously arrogant thing consisdering the size of the universe. Keep it up!
Beyond Zork!!

The odds are against us being alone.  I really hope that in my lifetime we canfine some concrete evidence of extraterrestrial life.
mathematical odds suggest the cosmos should be teeming with life, consider the sheer enormity of the universe. the wow! signal could be centuries old. the photos we see of other galaxies are like looking back thru time upwards of billions of years so we don't know what they should look like currently. civilizations could have come and gone and we would never know of their existence. hopefully someone out there, as curious as we, would have sent more than one signal and it would be a shame if we missed the call. keep listening guys!! they are there...
It was Elvis, leaving the planet...
It was Elvis saying goodbye...
And interestingly enough, the next day, Elvis "left the building" for the last time... coincidence... I think Not!

Happy WOW Day!
It's a streetlight.
Interesting stuff! It really is conceited to think we are alone... and while it is understandable that scientists must err on the side of caution, their direction is always toward ruling out all possibilities rather than keeping an open mind. Wow can't easily be wiped off the slate, or it would have been.  This  is fascinating, exciting,  hopeful.
Don't worry, we are not alone. The God of the Bible is with us and always will be. And we don't need the SETI Institute, a lot of time and money or the Allen Telescope Array in California to find him.  
Reminder that you can help at http://setiathome.berkeley.edu/
I'm surprised the "Elvis has alien baby" fans haven't made the connection - this was obviously planet Xzyble calling Elvis home!  (Elvis Presley died on the same day this signal was detected.  Coincidence?  I think not.)
It may be Michio Kaku was correct in surmising other civilizations if they existed may have reached our stage of nuclear development and destroyed themselves. The "Wow" signal may have been a dying gasp, much like some hear the voice of a departed loved one.
Great work! There had to be something out there, and I'm so glad scientists are working on projects like this. Very cool!
whats the use if we never tried? It's good that we as humans never stop asking those questions that got us to where we are today. What's out there? How do I get there?
Has anyone considered putting a radio telescope in orbit to listen for faint signals? Seems to me that terrestrial interference might be enough to drown out the faintest signals. Afterall, its a long way across the galactic pond.
I didn't realize this happened the day Elvis died.

hmm.....
Maybe "wow" was a loopback from the 1974 signal, like an echo or a deflection.  Was there a significant nuclear test type event at the time of "wow"?  Didn't Elvis pass on in 1977? "Wow".
When you search again will you account for cosmic drift?
Don't worry about the transmission.  It wasn't from another planet.  Trust me.  AI
It is not a co-incidence that Elvis went under cover that very same day!!!
We all know they're out there some where! Good luck and keep looking!
I dont know if the WOW signal is extra terrestrial in origin, although I hope it is, but who really knows.  Its hard to imagine that we are alone on this spec of dust in space (man thinks he's so special) so the signal could be what we're looking for.  Of course how far away is its origin?  The senders could be long gone by now.  :)
The truth is out there!
WOW and Elvis dying the same day - a coincidence ???
Thirty years ago today!  It was probably Elvis going into the wild blue yonder
did you take in to consideration, that WOW may have been a spaceship, on a flight in deep space, getting into trouble sending a SOS to its home planet. which was picked up over here , at the same time causing the WOW effect
Conspiracy theorists may like this one:  Perhaps this signal was Elvis going home!  Same day as his death 30 years ago.  Hmmm?  Who knows?  ;-)

I hope we hear something again as I believe we are not alone.  Too arrogant of humans to think we are the ONLY life forms in the universe.
"If we are alone, it sure seems to be an awful waste of space"...
SETI is often criticized as being pseudoscience because it seems to have beliefs in it that are not testable hypotheses - famously, the Drake equation.

However, that is a superficial argument.  If you take the negative hypothesis "Aliens do not exist" it would indeed be falsified by the discovery of aliens.  Also, you can take a problem and break it down into pieces: "There are non-Earth originating artificial radio signals from Sun-like star systems within 50 light years of Earth" is a testable hypothesis.  If proven false, expand the search to Sun-like stars within 60 light years.  Then 70, and so on.  Eventually you will either observe the entire Milky Way (and stumble across new scientific discoveries along the way, which alone justifies the money spent on SETI) or you will find alien radio signals.  Either way you will expand humankind's knowledge.

The pity of the "wow" signal is not that the event was never duplicated - its that we don't understand what it was.  The antenna that recorded it, by the way, was torn down to make way for a golf course.  Ah, Progress.


Ahh yes...those of us in New york are at a distinct disadvantage when it comes to true communication with bushmen...after all, bushmen are generally honest.
It took 30 years, but we're finally going to see an appropriate response to this significant event.
30 years ago today Elvis died---perhaps this "WOW"
mystery was Elvis's last concert on his way out of the earthly realm!.......the sounds of a dying star.
I have an intuition that we will be Wow'ed again in the near future, but only when the Wowers feel that we are ready.
That Wow! was Elvis leaving the planet.
I support continuing the various SETI projects but I must say that it is disappointing not to find anything compelling.  The Wow signal is probably Not from an alien civilization, simply because in my opinion where there is one signal, after 30 years of listening there would surely be another of some sort.  And I believe in viewing such things with a healthy skepticism until there is additional evidence.  On the other hand I believe that there must be life and probably intelligence throughout the universe.  I agree with the idea, "If in the vastness of the universe, we are alone, what a terrible waste of space."
Since Earth took 4.5 billion years to evolve sapient tool-makers (us), it seems to me that our section of this galaxy is probably open territory.
There is probably carbon/water-based life wherever conditions are right, but finding evidence of other sapient tool-makers is highly, HIGHLY unlikely.
But if Seth Shostak and the rest of the SETI crew want to keep scanning the sky for radio signals, there's no harm in that.
Science, when done openly & honestly, without bias or social and political suppression, can indeed produce Wow moment.

Was it some random alien signal or a more mundane terrestrial one? Who knows.

But if it drives an entire species to discover more of the Universe, to discover (even inadvertently) amazing truths, then that is the real Wow! moment.

Thanks for making me raise my head out of the daily routine. Suppose its time for me to put it back down & plow.

Good luck.
"The "Wow" signal may have been a dying gasp, much like some hear the voice of a departed loved one."

So Samuel D. G. Heath, you're actually proposing that
the Wow! signal was an Andromedan yelling "D'ough!" after his tentacles hit the wrong button? ;-)

PS: To all you Graceland boys linking Wow! to the King: Thankyou for making my day start with a laugh!
Stupid!....waste of money
After essentially glossing over his own report, it's obvious Ehman went to amazing lengths to make definite conclusions about the source of this signal. It's funny that inspite of that, there is no conclusion. Much like trying to determine if life ever existed or exists on Mars! No matter how much hardware and carefully designed robots you send, there is no conclusion that is an absolute yes or no answer.

Ehman considers spent space vehicles in earth orbit as reflective sources of possible harmonic signals but didn't mention discarded stages from Apollo or other planetary probes at the time. It could be possible (although very improbable) that a rocket stage that far in space could satisfy his criteria of low rotation rate and little change in position relative to fixed stars. Can you imagine that a spent rocket stage just happen to come into line of sight for some 72 seconds far out in space? I can't because I suspect the energy of the reflected harmonic would be too small. I believe it was of an ET source. But so what? It's just a belief.



We here, with our very limited imaginations, assume too much about what an alien civilization would be.  The truth is that we know almost nothing about the nature of the universe or how life begins and evolves.  In order to advance, we have to keep searching for answers.   This is human nature, and part of the reason that we've advanced as fast as we have.  We've not allowed ourselves to become stagnant.  Our lives depend on us advancing and solving problems i.e. "Will this pointed stick help me kill prey better without injuring myself", "If I use this 'basket' thing I made, maybe I can carry more nuts and berries."  I hope they find an answer for the Wow signal.  But most importantly, when they do, I hope the answer brings with it a whole new set of questions that we would never have thought of.
Back in 1977 there were more reports of alien messages other than the Wow signal-- check out this link.

http://www.ideocast.com/archive.asp?aid=10158

Also this link

http://www.ideocast.com/archive.asp?aid=10101


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=319127

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google