ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



High tech to the rescue

Posted: Thursday, December 14, 2006 1:10 PM by Alan Boyle

Once again, high-tech types are joining the life-and-death search for snow-trapped travelers: Less than a week after the drama of the lost Kim family played out in southern Oregon, heat-seeking planes and phone-seeking gizmos are being employed to look for three mountain climbers missing on Mount Hood in the northern part of the state.

The last time anyone heard from the lost men was on Sunday, when veteran mountaineer Kelly James placed a cell phone call to his family and told them he was worried about the worsening weather conditions. Now James is thought to have sought shelter in a snow cave at about the 10,000-foot level of the 11,235-foot peak, while companion climbers Brian Hall and Jerry Cooke may have attempted a descent.

In cooperation with the authorities, T-Mobile has been "pinging" James' phone, and Hood River County Sheriff Joseph Wampler said that as of Tuesday, a confirming ping was still coming back. "The technology is still talking to the phone," Wampler told reporters.

Wampler said that technique can narrow James' location down to a level of a quarter-mile or so. Now North Carolina-based Iomax Management Group has brought in a phone-locating kit that can get much closer.

"Under ideal conditions, which we hope to be in up there, we're talking 10 or 20 meters," Iomax's president, Ron Howard, told me Wednesday. "If you look at what cell phone companies do for a living ... they have no reason to refine the technology to this degree."

Iomax's reason for refining the technology has to do with its government contracts. In fact, the same technology can locate the cell phones that bad guys use to detonate roadside bombs in Iraq, NBC's George Lewis reported from Oregon.

Howard didn't discuss that aspect of Iomax's work in detail, but he did say the Iomax kit should work even in Oregon's inclement weather, at distances of well over a mile - as long as the cell phone issuing the signal is on a line of sight from the detector. "If it's on, we should be able to find it," Howard said.

Time is of the essence, however: James doesn't have to be talking on the phone, but once the batteries run down, Iomax won't have anything to ping. That's why Iomax's team flew out from Florida and North Carolina just hours after Oregon authorities accepted their offer of assistance Tuesday night. They started their search efforts late Wednesday.

Colorado-based Aracar is also getting its search operation off the ground ... literally. Aracar specializes in search-and-rescue robots - the nonprofit organization's name is actually an acronym for the Alliance for Robot Assisted Crisis Assessment and Response. One of Aracar's founders, John Blitch, told me via cell phone that he and his team are getting their camera-equipped, remote-controlled robo-planes ready to look for the climbers' trail.

"We're getting ready to head up to the mountain," he said at midday Wednesday.

Aracar's unmanned aerial vehicles range in size from your typical radio-controlled airplanes to drones with a wingspan exceeding 3 feet. But even the RC-scale planes are packed with technology - including an autonomous guidance system that can take over if the plane loses contact with the remote operator.

The planes can be equipped to send back still imagery or real-time video, or even thermal imagery from a microbolometer. Such thermal images could identify the "plume" of heat rising from a warm body set against the colder background temperatures of snow and ice, Blitch said.

Blitch said he is a retired Special Forces colonel who has been involved in research and development as well as "intelligence collection for battlefield missions."

"Some of the systems that we have, have been used quite extensively in Iraq and Afghanistan," he said. "What I'm trying to do now is take that same technology and bring it into disaster response applications."

He was one of the founders of the Center for Robot Assisted Search and Rescue, which played a part in post-9/11 recovery, and he's also put search-and-rescue robots through their paces in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.

High-tech is coming to the rescue amid the ruins, on the battlefield - heck, even on snowy roads. If Blitch and Howard have their way, similar high-tech tools - and the people who wield them - will help get those three stranded men off the mountain in Oregon.

"We almost had no choice but to send our team out there," Howard said.

Update for 12:35 p.m. ET Dec. 14: Oregon authorities say Aracar's team wasn't able to send out their unmanned planes on Wednesday, and the Iomax team is working away but has not detected a ping yet. Overnight, Iomax's Ron Howard sent out this follow-up statement:

"Our core customers are the U.S. and allied governments worldwide.  Our solutions have helped to resolve hundreds of cases overseas, including high-profile terrorists.  We rarely have the opportunity to put our equipment to work at home.

"We're happy that we have this opportunity to use our technology to help.  We hope and pray that we can work with the rest of the team here to quickly find these guys.

"If the climbers' cell phones are on, our equipment will more than likely find them.

"The equipment we're using here today is portable.  It can be hand-carried where it is needed. We also offer a new service for installation inside networks. If T-Mobile was using our Emergency Services Locator solution, the network could have located the hikers without us.

"This system is perfectly suited for backcountry cell phone networks or other high-risk areas where cellular networks are employed.  Networks serving areas like Mount Hood should consider installation of the Emergency Services Locator system of this kind.  If you become lost, and are carrying a cell phone from certain cellular providers, the Emergency Services Locator system will be able to locate you location within seconds.  To find out if your network technology is suited for our system, please contact us.  Our Web site is http://www.Iomax.net."

Update for 1:10 p.m. ET Dec. 14: Iomax's Ron Howard just sent this status report:

"The equipment is up and running at maximum power and has been since late last night. As of 10:00 a.m. PST, there is no response from our target phone, which is Miller's GSM Samsung flip phone. This could mean several things, good and bad. On the bright side, it means he is saving his battery strength for a more opportune time like a break in the weather.

"According to the intelligence we have been provided on site, our equipment is probing the proper side of the mountain where the climber was last located, which I think is the north side. Our equipment is emitting a continuous signal towards the last known location of his cell phone asking it to acknowledge receipt of that signal. We hope he has intentionally placed his phone in the off position.

"Worst case, and hopefully not the case here, his battery is dead and the phone will never be heard from again. Our guys will remain in place until they can get further up the mountain overland or in the air if the weather subsides. Currently it seems to us, Saturday is the day of reckoning for everyone involved. Our guys are currently co-located with the Aracar folks on the north face of the mountain.

"Interestingly, we have pretty well assessed the GSM (T-Mobile) network's ability to reliably talk to the phones which are located at altitude on Mount Hood. What we are discovering is, that around the 6,000 to 7,000-foot level, coverage is available, however predictably intermittent and unreliable. The signal strength where our guys are is bordering -100db.

"That is very, very weak and on the verge of becoming too weak for any two-way cellular communication to take place at all. Some calls still go through, some go through and are dropped, and most of the time they just don't get connected. Not knowing what the signal strength of the T-Mobile network is at higher altitudes, one can reasonably predict it will be significantly weaker than points further down the mountain, simply due to distance. This reinforces the fact that the network might only see the phone sporadically from here on out, or not at all. If the cell tower signal strength is as weak as it is, the signal from the handset to the tower will be several times weaker at this distance, very difficult for T-Mobile to receive and process."

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Lets hope this technology helps. That's my best friend's Uncle up there and we all hope he makes it.
Quit enabling stupidity, if these men were as experienced as all the news reports would have us believe, they would have checked the oncoming weather, Oregon's winter weather history and chosen a more appropriate time of the year to go risking their lives and their rescuer's lives on top of an icy mountain.
I agree with Ed Prineville, OR
I was married to a high altitude/alpine climber for years. We are now divorced. I was always worried he would not come back from a climb. He chose mountain climbing over me. Such is life. But I do miss him.
Ed in Prineville, these climbers can't help what they do. If they die on the mountain, that was their choice to risk everything. Believe me, I know. I lost my husband to the mountains.
I wish people would stop bothering with who is going to pay for this. I'm sure the families will pay for the search and rescue/recovery. Not an issue. This is mountaineering. Deal with it.
I'm sure the families are going to pay for this, regardless of the outcome. So sad. Mountaineering is a risky endeavor. I feel sorry for the families, as my ex-husband was lost to the mountains. Its in their blood. You can't stop it.
In and among my recommendations for more adequate municipal buildings, I've been calling for ranger stations to also have more robust facilities and equipment. A Sikorsky Cipher recon drone that can take off and land vertically was one of my recommendations for surveying areas after a natural disaster, looking for lost people, or looking for illegal poachers hunting wild game in the woods. It just seems more can be done at every front for safety and emergency assistance.
What person hasn't done something stupid they later regretted. Humanity seems unwilling to hear good advice when offered and for some reason insist on proving the opposite until the truth smacks us in the face. Still, stupidity shouldn't be a reason to condemn someone. I sincerely hope they are found and that none are lost in the process.
Why didn't these guys bother to utilize the locator devices which I understand are available to climbers on Mt Hood? At least then the rescuers would have a chance of finding them. With the whiteout conditions they could be in a snow cave and be walked over without ever seeing them.
Mt. Hood-specific locator devices are available for rent at many locations in the Portland and Mt. Hood area. I climbed Mt Hood a few years ago in a group of about 30 people. I was the only one humble enough to carry the device. I think there is a certain sense of invulnerability that climbers have if they have had a few successful climbs. It will be a tragic if these men don't make it simply because they didn't bother to rent a locator.
5 bucks for a transponder. Enough said.

Pushing the envelope.
It is a drive that makes history, creates change and can help to make things better, a natural human characteristic in some.
Climbers push the envelope; they make it a study.
Search and Rescuers push the envelope, they are driven to find.
Engineers push the envelope, and we are endowed with technological advances.
Here you have them all together in one scenario, each doing thier personal best, each finding and seeking to go beyond their limits, living life to their fullest, experiencing their uniqueness, their talent and finding just what they can be capable of.  It is actually a noble quality to have the drive to test your limits and reach.  It is when you are fully alive and aware of yourself.  Some people give their life to the mundane and safe, never knowing who or what they are. I wish I could be on that mountain looking for them.  I am a hopeless rescuer, just as some are hopelessly determined to climb or invent the animal that can do what we have found to be beyond our limits.
That is why we have Rudolph the rednosed reindeer, and that is what I think we need right now. Someone get a hold of Santa and see if we can get Rudolph out there until we come up with that Robot. And yes. I am waiting for those robots. Meanwhile, we need to keep climbing.  It is our nature.

Climb a mountain ONCE and you will know the passion it sparks. Adventure is a part of their life - one can sit in their homes and criticize those who take risks - but remember it is these type of people who discover new things, new ideas, and go where few people chose to go. Instead of slamming these guys we should all be praying and hoping for their safe return... On the other hand - if they are gone - at least they will pass doing something they love - how many people you know have died sitting in their homes DOING NOTHING! Where there are mountains - there are climbers... No mountain too tall... Godspeed my 3 friends... Mark
It is quite disturbing to read the comment above from "Oregon" ascribing the current situation solely as the result of "stupidity." The commentor jumps to the conclusion that these experienced climbers did not take all reasonable precautions including weather analyses and forecasts as well as carrying transponders/locators. Currently, we don't know all the details, and a rush to judgement is both callous and unhelpful. From our vast experience of mountain climbing around the world in all seasons, we have encountered a never-ending set of challenges even with the ultimate in preparation and caution. In our experiences, some of the most violent, precipitous weather changes have happened in the milder months of the year. Avalanche, hypothermia, pulmonary edema, equipment failure, complications of hypoxia, etc...such is the nature of the beast. Our focus here should be unified in the rescue of these men with the hope that they all are alive and well. This attitude would also extend to Ed of Prineville should he ever find himself in some predicament.
I understand people's desire to push limits and take risks. Please realize though that the search and rescue people take big risks trying to save people, who may or may not have been prudent. If they took the most difficult approach to the mountain at a bad time of year with approching weather, and didn't even have the respect to rent one of the emergency beacons, it sounds more like arrogance than true climbers who respect nature. If you take risks, you need to be humble about it and respect the people who may suffer because of them. Also, to those who say the families will pay, that is usually not the case... often these bills run literally in the 6-figures. I believe the Kim's were paying $1,000/hour for private helicopter services. Chances are they will only pay a small percentage of the real costs.
I was talking to friends yesterday about how someone should invent a GPS type device that climbers could rent at ranger stations or something. I guess I am behind times and I am not a climber. Either way, I hope these guys come out alive, with a great story. I dont think it matters if they checked the weather or not, things can change fast up there. You must admit, if in the morning the news was... "We heard what sounded like an R/C plane above us" God Speed to the climers and all the rescuers. P.S. Mother Nature, have a heart.

1st off let me just say I hope they are ok.

2nd off, when will these [people] learn that winter in the cascades and coast range are not something to test in the winter. Just like last week with that family in southern OR now you have these [people] who climb a 11,000 foot mountain in the dead of winter with storms stacked up off the coast. A few years back we lost a blackhawk helicopter looking for ... "thrillseekers", luckily the choppers crew was ok but we still lost a $30 million chopper looking for some people who should have never been there to begin with. I think everytime we rescue people like this it sends the wrong message. My feelings is if you purposely put yourself at risk "thrillseeking" then you will NOT be rescued by anyone but your own family. Why put other peoples fathers, brothers, sons, daughters lives in danger to look for you because you want a thrill.

ATTN: Dave, Costa Mesa, CA

The devices have already been invented:

There are three types of beacons used to transmit distress signals, EPIRBs (for maritime use), ELTs (for aviation use), and PLBs (used for land-based applications). PLBs can be purchased for $500-$700. They ping satellites monitored by the government and search and rescue teams are sent when they're activated. See www.sarsat.noaa.gov for more info.

I have to agree with the people who say everyone is human, people make mistakes. I live in Michigan, and I can not sleep at night for worrying about these men and their families. It is heartbreaking, and I can not fathom the attitude of "who cares, they knew what they were doing". This is human life up there, freezing, possibly hurt, I pray they are found alive, and I pray the weather breaks so the searchers can be safe also.

At this point there is more likely to be a recovery operation than a rescue.  The searchers should be considering their risks.  Go climb, cave, BASE jump, whatever, but don't do something that requires other people to endanger themselves to come looking for you.

How about requiring a bond be posted to cover a week's search before setting out without an ELT?  How about a ring of cell phone towers or better yet, one on each peak!

I never minded being called out at 4 AM (always seemed to be!) for a search.  It irritated me when the person we were looking for neglected the most basic safety needs and then expected someone to be there to catch them.  Examples:  no flight plans, no survival gear, penetrating weather (with or without instrument ratings) that they should have waited out or gone around.

At this point, my concerns are with the SAR personnel.

We will fund 12 million illegal aliens medical costs without a whimper,but let someone get lost or hurt climbing a mountain and we worry about who will pay for it. (obviously you have never been up a mountain.) These are the risk takers, and usually contributing members of society as well I might add. Get real.
Ed of Or. You would not be so careless with your words if it were YOUR loved one on that mountain.. I know Brian,and if it were YOU in that situation,,he would be first in line to risk HIS life to save you,,stranger or not!!!!!!!.....

As far as i'm  concerned, these guys were gambling they  could  go  up  and be down before the  weather  got too bad.  Well  guess what , it's time to pay up. They  rolled the  dice , let them live with the  consequences.  Crazy's  what it was in my mind. With cold storms possibly coming in, taking the hardest route in some places a 50 to  60 degree slope, all it takes is a few things to go wrong .. and it looks like they  did. I think  many of these risk takers  are  thinking  "well if we get into trouble  they  will come rescue us" and are throwing the scout motto of  "be prepared" to the wind. If  we stop running to  their rescue maybe they  will be more  cautious in the future. I think   we  shouldnt be  risking any more lives up on that mountain is  what i think.

Extreme adventure is sometimes too extreme in my mind .. just rolling the dice .. pretty  silly. Life is too  precious to be gambling with it on some of these things  , pocket Aces  get  beat all too  often. 

I have faith in god, and also in the goodness of the hearts of those who are willing to risk their own lives to save others. Is this not the season for giving truly from your heart?. I wish with all my heart that these individuals are found safe and well, and I will pray. As for the rescuers, this is what they chose to do, and blessed be their hearts and courage.
As a member of my local Search and Rescue, know that most teams are completely volunteer with only minimal state funding. (Gas to location can be reimbursed) But most of the time, the resucers are taking time off from work and donating their time. Please donate to your local Search and Rescue teams. The only equipment we have is bought from money collected from Fundraisers and Donations. Please be generous and maybe we could afford all the high-tech equipment necessary to get these folks off the mountain.
Please do not write any insensitive comments(i.e Prineville, Craig)regarding anything having to do with my family as we are all suffering from this situation.We've thought of every angle of this situation and do not need to see anything negative from you. I ask that you PLEASE keep it to yourself as if it were your family.
These are human beings we are talking about. So doing the humane thing and rescuing these men is without question the appropriate measure to take. Where in the world does judging these men and throwing our arms in the air to suffering the consequences do justice to anyone. Our hope and prayers need "only" be allowed here, period. Any other opinion is down right shameful.
I've never climbed a mountain nor have I known anyone with this passion. That is NOT the issue. These are human beings and some of the cold-hearted comments that have been posted are unbelievable and the authors should be ashamed. This is a horrible, unfortunate situation.....period. I pray that the weather lifts soon and this mission results in a To the families of these three hikers--stay strong. MOST of America is praying for you.
I just want to say my thoughts and prayers are with the climbers and their family. You will be in my prayers. God Bless - Joy
There is no price that can be placed on a life. When lives hang in the balance, it doesn't matter if the victims are foolish, victims of circumstance or any other descriptive. All that becomes irrelevant. All that matters is saving that life. Berating the victims for causing their situation is not only callous and insensitive to family members that might read these comments, but it's also completely pointless at this stage.

These men are not only mountain climbers, but sons, husbands, fathers, and dear friends. It is not only their lives that are affected. It's a small world and we should care for one another. There is a tendency just look at the surface of these stories. We often don't remember names. They become "those mountain climbers in Oregon." This really hit me today when I realized that Kelly James is a very dear friend to two people that are important in my life.

This is not just a story--it's the lives of 3 men. Men who have friends and family who are sick with worry.

As we pray for them let's not pray for the "Oregon mountain climbers," but for Kelly James, Brian Hall and Nikko Cooke.

God Bless the rescue attempt and the rescuers. I hope all works out. Those writting negative comments may want to think about help they may need in the future.
Fred - There is a whole slew of people here in Boise Idaho who are praying for Brian, Kelly and Nikko!!! We pray for God's hedge of protection around these 3 men, a break in the weather and their safe return! We are behind you as prayer warriors!
Hey, people. Ever heard of GPS. Rquire all climber to carry somethnig like "Onstar". Always on condition. Can be tracted, to within 3 meters. In any direction.
I just want to say to the families and friends of the climbers: the hearts of the nation are with you and your plight ,at this very hour! We care! God cares!
For those ones that have said only negative things, shame on you. We are all human beings and I think that the three of them need all our prayers right now. God Bless there family and hope that we find these men safe.
You never leave a fellow climber/hiker behind or missing unless that's the only life-or-death choice remaining. ("Touching the Void", Into Thin Air", etc.) That's why the SAR folks do what they do: because they care. Deeply. They will not take stupid chances, but they will not give up until they either find their people or they're pulled off the mountain. That's just the way it is, always has been and always will be. It's that simple. It's the Golden Rule. It's Karma. Send a warm and strong light from your heart to each and every person on Mt. Hood. P&L
What makes people climb mountains? I don't know. People who participate in Search & Rescue are the same kind of folks who run IN to a burning building when everyone else is running OUT -- I know some of them. They value human life -- they don't care WHY someone is lost, they just try to find them. All the prayers and energies we can muster should be with those who are lost -- and those who seek them. Blessings to you! Know that there are people who will hope and pray with you through this -- I and my household are some of them.
God Bless Us Everyone! Peace, Love and Hope to these guys and their families.

After reading all of the above comments, my comment is that almost everyone has some valid points in what they are saying, but I don't agree with all of them.  It may be valid that no one wants to pay for someone else's mistakes, but the point is not who pays, who made mistakes or who might have to pay for it in the end.  The point is, who are we as human beings?

Are or are we not our brother's keepers, which translates into do we or do we not reach out to others when they are in desperate need?  The above commentaries are certainly a cross section of our society and how we react when others are in trouble. Thankfully, the majority are showing compassion and concern.

As a final comment, Jesus Christ came to save us from all of the mistakes that we each make and he told us not to judge each other.  I intend to spend my energy praying for these men and their families and I encourage the rest of you to do the same.

i wonder if it is possible to put in place a temporary cell phone network to reach their phone.
If these guys are experienced climbers they must have known that bad weather was certainly a possibility. Is it common for people to tackle this mountain at tihs time of the year? It doesn't make sense to me.
I hope the climbers are rescued and reunited with their families. But whatever happens, it won't be because of anyone's superstitious prayers to a non-existent "supreme being". You might as well rub a rabbit's foot or consult a Ouija board.
Yes. Do everything we can to get them off the mountain safely. The rescuers do not need to hear that their efforts are without merit, they are putting their lives in jeopardy doing what they know is important. There are a lot more senseless things going on in the middle east, at our expense, than what is going on in this rescue. We certainly shouldn't worry about who pays for this effort to save lives.
Could be that something unforeseen happened,and they were prepared to climb in the time-frame they had planned, and get out before the weather came in... but maybe someone had gotten hurt, twisted ankle, or something... and it forced them to stay longer. It has happened to me and I understand how a situation that you have completely under control comes to a situation where you may be fighting for survival. Don't judge, people.
Dr. Frank James, Everyone at RTS Orlando is praying for you and your family that your brother, Kelly, and the other two men will come home safely. I know the Lord Jesus will help you and your family persevere through this difficult time...
The Search and Rescue motto is "So that others may live" that's why we do this. Good luck you guys and Godspeed.
Frankly, I'm shocked at how much negativity and pure bitterness I've read here. I happen to know that these 3 men, Kelly, Brian and Nikko are very fine men. They are highly intelligent, good friends, family members, and contributors to this world. I pray, my family prays and my friends pray, that Kelly, Brian, and Nikko are brought home safely to their families and friends who are in so much agony just waiting for a bit of news. We pray for everyone involved in the search, and we thank them. We also pray for a break in the weather. If you don't pray, then go hug a tree, or rub a rabbit's foot, do whatever you do when someone you love is in trouble, for heaven's sake, do SOMETHING!! But please, remember what your elders taught you, "If you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all"! Fred, stay strong. You and your family as well as Brian and Nikko's families are all wrapped in the arms of angels.
Whether or not it was wise to climb the mountain, they went and are in trouble. God speed to the rescue folks, may GOD keep you safe and help you find these men alive.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=20506

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google