ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



Martian mystery solved?

Posted: Wednesday, August 16, 2006 7:55 PM by Alan Boyle


Ron Miller / ASU
Sand-laden jets shoot into the south polar sky in this artist's conception.

Newly published findings suggest a solution to the mystery of the Martian trees – those dark, bristly spots on aerial photography of the Red Planet that some have compared to fans or forests. Even Arthur C. Clarke, the author of "2001: A Space Odyssey" and other science-fiction classics, has wondered whether Mars' seemingly branching "banyan trees" represent signs of biological activity.

But now researchers propose that the spots are of geological origin: They say the marks are left behind every spring when gas and dark sand blast through rumbling fissures in the ice. "If I was ever going to go to Mars, I'd want to observe this," said Arizona State University's Phil Christensen, one of the authors of the research, which appears in Thursday's issue of Nature.

The key observations behind the latest claims were made with the Thermal Emission Imaging System, or THEMIS, an infrared camera aboard NASA's Mars Odyssey orbiter.

Previous imagery, gathered by another orbiter called Mars Global Surveyor, provided ample documentation of the mystery spots, particularly in Mars' south polar region. That imagery led scientists to suggest the spots were the result of a defrosting process that exposed the darker ground beneath the carbon dioxide ice.

However, thermal readings from THEMIS indicated that the dark spots were about the same temperature as the ice. That led Christensen and his colleagues - Hugh Kieffer and Timothy Titus of the U.S. Geological Survey - to conclude that the dark material was actually sitting on top of the ice layer, rather than exposed below the ice.


NASA / JPL / MSSS
Dark spots (left image) and fans (right image) cover
the icy landscape near Mars' south pole in two
images taken by Mars Global Surveyor during spring.
Each image is about 2 miles (3.2 kilometers) wide.
Click on the image to see a larger version.

So how did the stuff get up there? Here's the scenario sketched out in this week's research paper, based on about 200 days' worth of THEMIS surveillance:

The process starts during the Martian winter with the buildup of carbon dioxide ice over a layer of dark sand and dust. That dark material is thus sandwiched between a couple of feet of CO2 ice on top, and the permanent polar cap of water ice below.

As spring approaches, sunlight shines through the CO2 ice and warms the dirt enough to make the ice just above it sublimate - that is, turn directly from a solid into a gas. Pressure builds up beneath the remaining CO2 ice, eroding the dirt layer in the process. Eventually, that pressure becomes so great that a blast of gas, sand and dust breaks through fissures in the ice - spewing out at speeds of 100 mph (160 kilometers per hour) or more.

The activity leaves behind a dark burst of dirt, surrounding the vent on the ice sheet. Wind may blow the dust into a fanlike pattern. But as the CO2 ice fades to nothingness, so does the burst pattern. All that's left is a spidery pattern of erosion carved into the underlying water ice. Those "spiders" provide a template for the process to begin all over again during the following winter.


NASA / JPL / MSSS
Spiders trace a pattern on top of the residual polar
cap after the seasonal CO2 ice slab has disappeared.
This image is about 2 miles (3.2 kilometers) wide.
Click on the image to see a larger version.

"Once a spider becomes established, it affects the surface so that a vent will form in the same place the following year," Christensen said in today's ASU news release.

Christensen told me that "it was that day-to-day-to-day imaging that really allowed us to unravel what's going on." A companion paper, yet to be published, will go into the detailed physics behind the phenomenon, he said.

"There isn't anything like it on Earth," Christensen said. "On Earth, this doesn't happen."

However, some researchers have suggested that a similar process may be at work on Triton, a moon of Neptune that also is speckled with mysterious dark spots.

As for those Martian banyan trees, Christensen said the phenomenon probably has its roots in a process similar to the one he and his colleagues have sketched out.

"It's a geologically sound explanation," he said.

Do you agree? Feel free to weigh in with your comments below.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Nah, I think they're shrubs.
I think that this confirms the fact that there is no life on the Martian surface.  If any exists it is probably microbial and exists in a strata below the planet's surface.  I also think that if we were to find life (either as we know it or foreign in origin) it will be outside our planetary system (9 or 12 planets, as you wish).

Simply said: "There ain't no life nowhere but here".
I was wondering where the tax money went for landscaping. Now I know, NASA spent it on "Trees for Mars" program.
No way. Those are Martian Figs !
Good science has great effects.
Does this indicate that there's a prevailing wind pattern in that area of Mars? If so, it would be interesting to know how strong and could future explorers harness it.
Where does the dark color come from in that case? Last I checked the sand there was red. Also, these features appear to have height. Unless we caught them in the act, which is unlikely, I think these folks are searching. How about sending one of those rovers? Seems like they could have been there by now.
thats oil! no wonder bush wants us to go there!
The trees are likely caused by the pressure melting Co2 and sand underneath the ground. Big deal!  NASA needs to spend most of their money on methods to build a self-sustaining for human space craft that can house scientists, engineers with their familys for centuries at a time while traveling in outerspace. Since that is how long it will take to get to the nearest solar system that has potential life. Besides Earth, we as a civilization will never find sentient life in our solar system. The need to go outside it is our true destiny for exploration. Their is more life in my toilet than there is on most of the 11 other planets in our solar system. Just don't need to spend billions of dollars to confirm that.
What a wonderful time we live in as our hungering minds search the heavens for the very answers that keep us moving forward, understanding and thirsty for truths in this vast universe we live, eager to touch new worlds and travel end-lessly, leaving our minds to wonder and question...questioning is our right to do as we are born of them.....69
Simply said: "There ain't no life nowhere but here...  wow, thats pretty narrow minded and arrougant thinking.. In a universe thats 18.5 billion light years across and we are the only living thing... I dont think so... as for the martian trees, my bet is that they are pine trees..
Who cares?  Martian trees won an historic strategic victory over Israel.  That's all that counts.  Allahu Akbar!
There goes the value of my Martian real estate.
The real truth about Mars is about to be published by Sense Of Wonder Press...October this year.  COMMONALITY (a new Science Fiction tale) explains their history.
Everyone is missing the obvious.  George W. has his oil companies up there & they are drilling for oil. Soon look for the Martian pipe-line
I wish they were trees - or atleast some kind of life form. If there is, then theres the knowledge that we are not alone ! Maybe that will eventually stop all the wars we have here in the name of religion (bah - God - the sick solace of a civilized ! race thats unable to be civilized - the animals have it better !)
Yes they are geological. They are the geo thermal vents for the Martian society deep under the surface of the planet. This occurs at scheduled intervals. Once enough pressure has built up this occurrs. I believe this can be proven with a longer study of the area to show just how regularly this happens. Andwhen we are able to get probes deeper into the planet's surface The height of the blast shows the masssive build up of pressure.
I think that our solar system is teeming with life.
It may be microbial and it may be far different than
on Earth, but the more we know the more the chances
are increasing for life else where INCLUDING inside
our planetary system.  It's too early to tell based
on what NASA releases to the public, but look at the
methane signatures and where we keep finding life
on this planet.  There's water everywhere, there is
certain to be life on our neighbors as well.
Doesn't anyone seem to think that the ice isnt a frozen past, but a frozen future? Let me explain; When God's day comes he will judge all of us, those who stay and those that don't. Those that don't are just no more, no hell no forever torture, God is not an evil being, he stands for love and mercy, why would he do such a thing as to put someone in a fiery hell or a place where they are forever being tortured, Hello! Anyway Those who stay are resurected to a life on earth, how can you be resurected if you are in heaven already when you die? As the Catholics and others would have you believe. Anyway, those resurected to earth will multiply and at some point the earth will be crowded, so wouldnt it make sense that God prepare another planet for us to use? When he is ready the ice will melt and become rivers and oceans and lakes just like earth. Mars and other planets are being created for us, but all in Gods time, not mans.
That's not Mars that's the Great Salt Lake in the springtime
The God stuff scared me in the comment section, I like the Oil Idea, Go George, get that oil, at least we're only killing Martian Trees.
I think someone should go check it out and let us know???
You cannot blast NASA for taking the time and effort and money (it is what makes the world go around by the way) to give us an answer on what the hell those fissures where, so they are dark sand orgasms...awsome, but weren't most useful discoveries fueled by our curiosity and intrigue, and yes maybe even passion of discovery? Just the anxiety to know what? Oh and to the guy that wants us to send a family with there scientist father into uncharted, deepsea space exploration? I wanna know whats in my backyard before i look over the fence into my neighbors. baby-steps.
How is it possible for NASA to find life on Mars, when they can't even find the moon landing videos in their own archives here on Earth. Speaking of..where are the pictures from the other side of the moon anyways?
It's a great theory, and until we get on mars or
more advanced methods of research become available,
it will remain a theory.  That's my theory. :)
It's another elaborate stunt by the martians, they know we're watching them - they are responsible for crop circles afterall.
NASA doesn't always succeed at everything, but no one is going to beat them when it comes to spreading bull (except politicians of course). I've seen so many plants and artifacts in the photos I can't even count them. What a vivd imagination NASA has!
There IS life on Mars. It is US.
It's my blast furnace, stolen by the Martians last week! They put it underneath the soil and now they're having majestic geological effects!
Well, this observed periodic (seasonal) effect described and photos was intriging enough to induce me read  the letter submitted to  Nature 442, 793-796(17 August 2006) by Hugh H. Kieffer, Philip R. Christensen3 and Timothy N. Titus. Attributing what appears to be subsurface expulsions of sub surface resident material to CO2 expansion past a sublimated crust is as good a guess as any at this point. The suggestion that there is a darker ground material related to this process suggests to me that there may be some volcanic (basaltic) like process involved. A lot of heat and a lot of cold, good place for life don’t you think?
god has nothing to do with mars...he only created earth remember? if we were to ever go to mars, god ain't gonna watch our backs.
Is it me or does NASA researchers are trying REALLY hard to say "There is NO possible way there is life on Mars." ???
That thars oil in them thar hills!!! Call W & Haliburton. We'll all be rich. Now they need to find the Martians to screw over and that makes for a great day. Mayhaps sell them those defective "bullet proof" vests.
whatever the objects are, it is doubtful that a human in this generation or the next will physically touch them.the islamic terrorists have got us spending so much money we cannot afford to go to mars with astronauts. i remember as a child looking up at the moon in wonder on a warm july evening in 1969 thinking what a wonderful universe we would be exploring in my lifetime. not to be the case, though. hizballah,al queda, ahmedinejad...they managed to wipe away the small progress some nasa engineers and robert goddard made in my youth.
who brought God into all of this? And the afterlife? kinda narrow minded to think we're all headed back here. And i think the "ain't no life" person was speaking for here in the solar system, or at least i hope he was. we're talking about trees, or shrubs, or gysers. I like the latter; most of the explanations for that make sense. But if they are trees, who'll be the first to decorate one for Christmas?
I believe if there is life somewhere out there, then it will be in a black hole or somewhere like that.  Not saying that there isnt life but I want proof before I believe anything.  The alien in Signs sure was scary though.lol.
We should name it Redstone National Park,Like Yellowstone!
"Honey load the kid's up where off to the Park"
It just reminds me that Mars is a cold, alien world. If terraformed, it'd be the same as living in twilight in the high Andes.

Worse, the gravity is insufficient to hold the atmosphere for more than a few 100's of thousands of years. The planet is geologically dead, so the biosphere would have to maintain the atmosphere. That leaves out our own selection of plants and animals. We'd have to engineer everything; including our own children.

My dog would hate it.

With no areological activity, everything will simply erode in the more active atmosphere we'll have to introduce. In addition, everything, and I mean everything, we mine from our earth has been processed for our use by biological systems. It'll be a hardscrabble existence with an enormous share of the planetary gross economy devoted to merely maintaining the habitability.

If you think that sounds inviting, I've got some land in Western Kansas I'll sell you for a winter resort.
Too many wild theories,not enough proof.Could be sand fountains,could be rock formations (or trees).Most of what we learn about space is based on asumptions of one or two people,not based on real logical science.Space science needs more scientists and less dreamers.
Much of what I have read here shows me that there are alot of narrowmindedness in the world, especially in our country.  I guess it is true when scientists say that we only use a small portion of our brain.  Some of us use alot less than others!!
Reminisent of sand blows in alluvial material from a decent sized earthquake!  Check out aerial photos from the Charleston, SC and New Madrid, MI earthquake areas.  They will be white on dark.

I checked out the Star Trek site and down-loaded a wonderfully apropo desktop.  "Logic - It's not as prevalent as you would wish!"  OY VEY! So true!  I suppose there may still be some faint hope if they are reading Cosmic Log!

So, Astronomy is finally developing a logical definition besides the "wanderer"!  Joy.  A science center spokeswoman from Baltimore said something to the effect that Nature makes planets we just describe and name them.  Yup.  So now we get to tote up the plutoids in the KBOs and OC.  Really, how hard was this?  Round because of sufficient gravity, orbiting a star, not a star and not orbiting a planet.  Now all we need are easy classifications like "S" for Silica, "G" for gas or giant if you prefer and "I" for Ice.  That should about cover it.  Bigger than G and you have a brown dwarf, smaller than gravitationally rounded and you have an asteriod or a KBO or OCO.

Heard someone claim Pluto as their astrological planet!  Right!
I'm not sure if the definition of "universe" is well defined yet, considering what is going on in Prague with the "planet" issue,  but I have always assumed it ment the whole "thing"...meaning infinite. People seem comfortable with a beginning and end and age, but since I was very young I could never picture this. If you could travel at speeds much greater than light and do it for billions of years, I believe you would never see an end...there may be points where there are no galaxies for billions of light years, but eventually, you would find more. To find out we need to start with our own solar system. Our moon is a great launching site because it is the easiest to get to and relatively close and Mars is next with its similarities to earth. Considering all but gravity, if you can make it work on our moon , it should work even better on Mars. As we build out, we will peer farther out to our infinite universe. Other beings likely are doing this as well and our best chances of meeting are somewhere in the middle. If we don't deal with a mass extinction event in the next 10,000 or so years, we will need to find other places to live. This planet can only take so much. Baby steps will get us there!
A very interesting article. Although this exact phenomena doesn't occur on Earth, Old Faithful (and other geysers) demonstrate the basic principle rather well. As for the "spider" patterns produced- didn't David Bowie once have a song about "Spiders from Mars?"
I belive the current scientific asessment reflects the desire of our scientists and politicians to assure the public they are: a. In charge and b.Know what to expect from the universe around us the "trees" are probably indeed a sort of simple lifeform similar Fungi similar size fungal colonies do grow on earth.
Maybe we should leave it alone whatever it is, lest it become another Iraq.
Intelligent ideas wanted here and not would be comedians comments. Trying to be funny and not succeeding.
Perhaps we should be more aware that we are not alone in the vastness of the universe.
We keep sending our radio signals out into space hoping to get some type of reply.
Doesn’t it occur to anyone that we may not like the response. We are doing a reasonably
good job of killing each other here on earth, why should we wave a red flag at any thing
out there and disclose our cover. “They” could be more accomplished  warfare that we
could imagine. Let’ keep our heads down and stop looking for trouble!
Hey, It looks like a bunch of dark colored Martians staring up at our funny looking probe.
I think they just found where they get all that Etch-a-Sketch stuff.  
lets send a nuke to mars to try kickstarting its eco system.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=2090

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google