ABOUT COSMIC LOG

Quantum fluctuations in space, science, exploration and other cosmic fields... served up regularly by MSNBC.com science editor Alan Boyle since 2002.

Alan Boyle covers the physical sciences, anthropology, technological innovation and space science and exploration for MSNBC.com. He is a winner of the AAAS Science Journalism Award, the NASW Science-in-Society Award and other honors; a contributor to "A Field Guide for Science Writers"; and a member of the board of the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing.

Check out Boyle's biography or send a message to Cosmic Log via cosmiclog@msnbc.com.



What are you afraid of?

Posted: Monday, June 12, 2006 5:29 PM by Alan Boyle

How will catastrophe strike? In a survey designed to stir up interest in the Sci Fi Channel's "Countdown to Doomsday," a catastrophic series of terrorist attacks came up as the likeliest scenario for mass destruction - although a potential disease pandemic generated virtually the same amount of paranoia. More tellingly, those same survey respondents said they didn't feel very prepared for either variety of doomsday.

The results are contained in a survey of 800 U.S. registered voters, conducted May 22-25 by Public Opinion Strategies and Greenberg Quinlan Rosner Research for the Sci Fi Channel and NBC News Productions. The poll was done in advance of a Capitol Hill roundtable on disaster preparedness, due to be hosted Tuesday by the Sci Fi Channel. (Sci Fi is a network of NBC Universal, which has a stake in the MSNBC.com joint venture.)

You just know this all has to be tied in with a TV show - and indeed, "Countdown to Doomsday" is scheduled to premiere Wednesday.

The show goes through 10 possible doomsdays - including terror attacks and pandemics as well as global warming, asteroid strikes, solar flares, supervolcanoes, mass extinctions, gamma-ray bursts, robo-rebellions and alien invasions. The poll concentrated on the top four possibilities:

  • Terrorist attacks: Twenty-nine percent of the respondents said they believed a series of terror attacks resulting in mass destruction "will" happen in their lifetime, and another 51 percent said such a calamity "could" happen. Ten percent said they felt the country was very prepared for such a scenario, and another 53 percent said that the country was at least somewhat prepared. However, only 8 percent said they were personally very prepared, with an additional 31 percent claiming they were somewhat prepared.
  • Disease pandemics: Twenty-two percent said a pandemic "will" happen in their lifetime, with another 52 percent saying it "could" happen. Six percent considered the country very prepared; 51 percent said it was somewhat prepared; 8 percent said they were personally very prepared; and 34 percent said they were somewhat prepared.
  • Global warming: Devastating climate change was seen as something that "will" happen by 23 percent, and something that "could" happen by 24 percent. Three percent said the country is very prepared; 31 percent said it was somewhat prepared; 6 percent said they were personally very prepared; and 26 percent said they were somewhat prepared.
  • Asteroid collisions: Only 6 percent said a catastrophic impact will occur during their lifetime, and 25 percent said it "could" happen. Two percent consider the country very prepared; 13 percent said it was somewhat prepared; 4 percent said they were personally very prepared, and 8 percent said they were somewhat prepared.

Republicans tended to see the catastrophes as more likely than Democrats, but also viewed the country and themselves as more prepared to deal with it. Under-35 voters - and particularly younger men - were more likely to feel prepared to deal with terror attacks.

Yet another Sci Fi survey provides a different take on the doomsday question, with virtually all respondents conceding that at least one of the 10 catastrophic scenarios could conceivably happen ... someday.

Which begs the question: What are you afraid of? Does this match your personal paranoia index? Or is there any use to this kind of doomsday demographics? 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

First of all, every one of the aboved mention "Are" going to happen at some point, somewhere, somehow; so the whole "Will it ever happen?" is really a pointless question.

Frankly, I'm really not afraid of any of the above, because I look at it not from "Oh no, I could die, and everyone I love with me." because if I do, I get terrified and act irrationally.

Life is inherently littered with hazards to it, that is what ultimately leads to "balance".  Look, it doesn't matter whether we go out into the universe or stay here, we are in a war against nature, and at the same time, in a war to preserve it.  Diseases come and kill millions, and we seek to wipe them out, and new diseases arrise.  Call it evolution or call it god, the ultimate result is the same, a balance is sought.  The same thing with asteroids, the environment (got news for you all, it's become apparent life is extremely tough to remove from a place, so even it we kill us all off...the planet will recover....unless we shatter the whole sheabang, then the environment might have a worry), terrorism (unless human society fundamentally changes we all have an innate nature to cause harm to those who are different, some of us are just better at controlling it, and most just take it to differing levels, physical harm being the most extreme).

Don't get me wrong, I believe we should do everything we can to prevent disaster, but I'm just pointing out it is, always has been, and always will be a constant fight, regardless of technology, something will come up that can get you.
Wow… I’m kind of surprised that AAMD (Arsenals of Absolute Mass Destruction) did not even make the list.  Nuclear terrorism is a pittance compared to even just one U.S. Ohio-Class ballistic missile submarine, which has the destructive force of 4,000 Hiroshima bombs.  That is the kind of doom that really could spell the fall of man, not some 200-pound dirty bomb.  

Alien invasion is an outright silly idea in that any alien species that can travel this far to even get here doesn’t need anything from us!  Most of the others on the list seem pretty hokie and far fetched (in geologic terms) compared to the real dangers of Natural disasters.  An 8.0 under San Fran or a Katrina-like hit on Miami or Huston and you’d be looking at some big problems!

As for being prepared, nothing beats knowing about edible wild plants that you can eat from your own lawn!  Peterson’s Field Guide to Edible Wild Plants is the best reference and it only takes about three months to learn.  They are everywhere!

Alan, my web site still has my article Preparing for a Super-Disaster as the excerpt text.
And the point of this chicken little survey is ..?
I'm more concerned about the cumulative effects of many little disasters.  

How do we prepare for ten suicide bombers in ten different American cities walking into airports and blowing themselves up at the metal detectors within a few minutes of each other?  How do we prepare for a similar scenario involving the Lincoln Tunnel, Golden Gate Bridge, or at a series of electrical substations?

American commerce would come to a screeching halt.  Game over, thanks for playing.
Israel has been living with terrorism for many decades. Statistically speaking, it's still significantly less dangerous than road accidents.

The fact that terrorism stars at the top of the list of things americans are afraid of says more about the effectiveness of your government's scare campaign than about the actual level of threat.
Our civilization is based on cheap portable energy. No energy, no civilization, period. Nothing presently is a feasible replacement for current sources, at least with the level of population the world has right now. The biggest and most pressing danger is mankind breeding itself beyond the numbers supported by available resources and then to extinction but you won't see that on any research paper released to the public.
what is the problem??? we will without doubt all die some time. Yes we could be a little more prepared but most of humanity want's someone else to do that for them, and we still would die. So enjoy your life (while you have it)and care for others, a least that way our lives would be a bit nicer.
Life is an adventure, it is up to you whether it is good or bad, whichever you choose you get back just what you gave to others. Forget about dying. That will take care of itself. Concentrate on living and treating people they way you want to be treated.
The parts of the show that I was able to tolerate were actually pretty good.  I knew about super volcanoes but did not realize that Yellowstone was sort of overdue (perhaps within another 100,000 years).  I am glad to see they mentioned the Canary Island volcano that could cause an East Coast Tsunami.  There points on solar flares was not as hockie as I thought they would be and I liked how they addressed human induced mass extinctions.  Not a topic many cover.  If they could have only left out alien invasion and robot revolution I think I would have felt a lot more comfortable.  They really did have good graphics!
The only disaster scenarios I can really give any credence to are the super volcano, the pandemic, and the solar burst/EMP attack.  
The idea of possibly facing a situation that we are "AFRAID OF/CATASTROPHIC"is as old as the universe.                                                                                                                                                  
There have been innumerable such occassions described in mythology.  THE MANKIND has been facing such situations frequently and has survived  amazingly! I totally agree with Bobby Palmer  let us concentrate on civilized  living and  discretely breed mankind (Dennis, CA )
What am I afraid of?  Another Katrina.  The Middle East Crisis.  Bird Flu.  Alzheimers.  Why?  I have no control over these things.  
Is this the same film as The History Channels "Last Days on Earth"?


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

TRACKBACKS

Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://cosmiclog.msnbc.msn.com/trackback.aspx?PostID=374

Latest Tech & Science News

Syndicate This Site

Add Cosmic Log to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google